The URL can be used to link to this page

07/16/2019 City of Niagara Falls Agenda City Council Meeting Tuesday, July 16, 2019 @ 5:00 PM Council Chambers Page 1. IN CAMERA SESSION OF COUNCIL - 4:00 PM 1.1. July 16 - Resolution to go In-Camera 8 2. CALL TO ORDER O Canada - Performed by: Jaiden Atkinson 3. ADOPTION OF MINUTES 3.1. Council Minutes of June 25, 2019 City Council - 25 Jun 2019 - Minutes 9 - 26 4. DISCLOSURES OF PECUNIARY INTEREST Disclosures of pecuniary interest and a brief explanation thereof will be made for the current Council Meeting at this time. 5. MAYOR'S REPORTS, ANNOUNCEMENTS 6. REPORTS / PRESENTATIONS 6.1. MW-2019-18 Former Parks, Recreation and Culture Building - Proposed End Use Mark Richardson will give a presentation to Council on a proposed strategy to incorporate the property into the current landscape of the Lundy's Lane Cemetery. MW -2019-18 - Former Parks, Recreation & Culture Building - Proposed 27 - 70 Page 1 of 192 End Use MW -2019-18 - Attachment 1 - CD-2013-05 - 7565 Lundy's Lane - August 13, 2013 MW -2019-18 - Attachment 2 - Aerial of Proposed Redevelopment MW -2019-18 - Attachment 3 - Proposed Redevelopment & Layout of Landscape & Columbarium Features MW -2019-18 - Attachment 4 - Proposed Landscape & Corner Gateway Feature MW -2019-18 - Attachment 5 - Proposed Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature-Spring MW -2019-18 - Attachment 6 - Proposed Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature-Fall MW -2019-18 - Attachment 7 - Memofrom OESN - Former Parks & Recreation Building May 2019 R1 MW -2019-18 - Attachment 8 - Letter from Morse & Son Lundys Lane BIA - Letter of Support for Demolition of Former Parks Recreation Cultural Building - July 10 2019 2019-07-09 - Letter of Endorsement re Lundy's Lane Expansion Letter of Endorsement - Hetherington & Deans 6.2. F-2019-31 Adding Provincial Offences Act (POA) Fines to the Tax Roll F-2019-31- Adding Provincial Offences Act (POA) Fines to the Tax Roll F-2019-31 Attachment 1 71 - 78 7. CONSENT AGENDA The consent agenda is a set of reports that could be approved in one motion of council. The approval endorses all of the recommendations contained in each of the reports within the set. The single motion will save time. Page 2 of 192 Prior to the motion being taken, a councillor may request that one or more of the reports be moved out of the consent agenda to be considered separately. F-2019-30 Municipal Accounts F-2019-30 Municipal Accounts F-2019-30 Attachment 79 - 96 MW-2019-19 Cast Iron Tactile Walking Surface Indicators (TWSI’s) MW -2019-19 - Tactile Warning Plates MW -2019-19 - Attachment 1 (Testing Different Materials for Tactile Walking Surface Indicators – Pilot Project Evaluation Report (March 28th, 2014)).docx 97 - 112 PBD-2019-45 GTY-2019-003, Gateway Community Improvement Plan and Municipal Employment Incentive Program Application 4749 Buttrey Street Niagara Energy Products PBD-2019-45, GTY-2019-003, Niagara Energy Products, 4749 Buttrey Street 113 - 118 R&C-2019-15 Niagara Falls Review Agreement Extension R&C-2019-15- Niagara Falls Review Renewal Agreement 119 - 120 TS-2019-22 Inter-municipal Transit Coordinating Committee Update: Establishment of Common Fare Structure TS-2019-22 IMT Coordinating Committee Update - Establishment of Common Fare Structure 121 - 124 Page 3 of 192 TS-2019-23 WEGO Advertising Contract Renewal - Adfuel Media Inc. TS-2019-23 WEGO Advertising Contract Renewal - Adfuel Media Inc. 125 - 126 8. PLANNING MATTERS 8.1. Public Meeting PBD-2019-044 AM-2019-013, City Initiated Zoning By-law Amendment Derelict Dwellings in the City's Tourist Core PBD-2019-44, AM-2019-013, Zoning By-law Amendment, Derelict Dwellings in the Tourist Core 127 - 132 9. COMMUNICATIONS AND COMMENTS OF THE CITY CLERK 9.1. Support of Auditor General's Recommendations - Niagara Peninsula Conversation Authority Composition RECOMMENDATION: For the information of Council. Niagara Regional Councillors - Auditor's General Recommendation - NPCA Composition 133 - 134 9.2. City of St. Catharines' Resolution: Free Menstrual Products at City Facilities The attached resolution from the City of St. Catharines regarding free menstrual products at City facilities was passed at St. Catharines' Council on June 10, 2019. Forwarded to City of Niagara Falls for consideration and support with a suggestion to forward resolution to local school board. RECOMMENDATION: For the information of Council. Resolution - Free Menstrual Products at City Facilities 135 - 136 9.3. Noise By-law Exemption and Special Occasion Event - Night of Art Request from Clark Bernat, on behalf of the Niagara Falls History Museum, seeking an exemption from Council to the City's Noise By-law to allow entertainment until 11:00 pm on Thursday, September 19th. 2019 for the Night of Art event. Furthermore, to obtain a Special 137 Page 4 of 192 Occasion Liquor License from the Alcohol & Gaming Commission of Ontario (AGCO), to recognize the event as a public event of municipal significance. RECOMMENDATION: For the Consideration of Council Noise By-law Exemption - Night of Art.msg 9.4. Bridgewater Street Parking - Chippawa Residents of Bridgewater Street circulated petition (found in Councillor's folders) to allow the use of the boulevard. RECOMMENDATION: Refer to Staff for a report. Bridgewater Street Parking-Chippawa.msg Letter to Mr. Bill Matson - Bridgewater Street parking 138 - 141 9.5. Regional Niagara - Regional Report PDS-21-2019 - 2018 Year End Growth Report RECOMMENDATION: For the Information of Council. CLK-C 2019-115 PDS 21-2019 142 - 153 9.6. Special Occasions Permit - 2019 Zombie Mud Run In support of Crohns and Colitis Foundation Canada, a request is being made to have their annual Mud Run taking place on Saturday September 7, 2019 at Campark Resorts, 9387 Lundy’s Lane, be declared by Council as an Event of Municipal Significance in order to assist with their request for a liquor licence through the AGCO. RECOMMENDATION: That Council approve the request. Special Occasions Permit - 2019 Zombie Mud Run 154 9.7. Proclamation Request - Brother-Sister Community Day The proclamation request is to recognize Brother Sister Community Day on Thursday, August 15th, 2019. RECOMMENDATION: That Council approve the request. Proclamation Request - Brother-Sister Community Day 2019 155 - 157 Page 5 of 192 Brother Sister Community Day 2018 9.8. Flag Raising and Proclamation Request - National Polycystic Kidney Disease The Polycystic Kidney Disease Foundation is requesting approval for the 2019 proclamation to recognize Wednesday, September 4, 2019 as "National Polycystic Kidney Disease Awareness Day." Also requesting the flag to be raised on this same day, September 4, 2019. Proclamation Polycystic Kidney Disease - Awareness Day 158 9.9. 9th Annual Heaters Heroes Run for Children – requesting that Council grant an extension to the City’s Noise By-law until 10:00 p.m. on Saturday August 10, 2019 for their annual event taking place at Oakes Park, and that Council declare the event as being municipally significant so as to assist with the liquor licence through the AGCO. RECOMMENDATION: For the Consideration of Council 10. RATIFICATION OF IN-CAMERA 11. BY-LAWS The City Clerk will advise of any additional by-laws or amendments to the by-law listed for Council consideration. 2019-81 - A by-law to authorize the payment of $16,863,038.46 for General Purposes. 06 - Municipal Accounts 190716 159 2019-82 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 2002-081, being a by-law to appoint City employees, agents and third parties for the enforcement of provincial or municipal by-laws. 2019 July 16 By-law Enforcement Officers 160 - 163 2019-83 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 79-200, to rezone Lands DTC conditional on the dwellings that are located on the Lands being demolished and removed within two years of the passing of this by-law (AM-2019-013). AM-2019-013 By-law 164 - 165 Page 6 of 192 2019-84 - A by-law to authorize the execution of a Road Maintenance Agreement with the Town of Fort Erie, respecting the road maintenance activities for Lapp Road and Schaubel Road. Execution of Road Maintenance Agreement - Town of Fort Erie 166 - 172 2019-85 - A by-law to amend the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan for Niagara adopted through By-law No. 2018-32. Lundy's Lane CIP Amendment (Amending By-law 2018-32) Lundy's Lane CIP Boundary Amendment (Amending By-law 2018-31) Schedule 1 173 - 174 2019-86 - A by-law to amend the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan Area adopted through By-law 2018-31. Lundy's Lane CIP Boundary Amendment (Amending By-law 2018-31) 175 2019-87 - A by-law to provide for the levy and collection of sums required by the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area for the year 2019. Main and Ferry BIA Levy 176 - 177 2019-88 - A by-law to authorize the execution of a Licence Agreement with Ontario Power Generation Inc., respecting the granting of a licence to the City for the construction, maintenance and operation of a Boat House and Dock for use by the Fire Departmen t on lands located on the south side of the Chippawa Creek. Execution of Licence Agreement - OPG - Boat House and Dock - Fire Department - Chippawa Creek 178 - 191 2019-89 - A by-law to adopt, ratify and confirm the actions of City Council at its meeting held on the 16th day of July, 2019. 07 16 19 Confirming By-law 192 12. NEW BUSINESS 13. ADJOURNMENT Page 7 of 192 The City of Niagara Falls, Ontario Resolution July 16, 2019 Moved by: Seconded by: WHEREAS all meetings of Council are to be open to the public; and WHEREAS the only time a meeting or part of a meeting may be closed to the public is if the subject matter falls under one of the exceptions under s. 239(2) of the Municipal Act, 2001. WHEREAS on July 16, 2019 Niagara Falls City Council will be holding a Closed Meeting as permitted under s. 239(2)(d) and 239(2)(f) of the Act, to discuss labour relations or employee negotiations as well as for advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege; and THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that on July 16, 2019 at 4:00 p.m., Niagara Falls City Council will go into a closed meeting, prior to their regularly scheduled meeting at 5:00 p.m., to consider matters that fall under s. 239(2)(d), labour negotiations, as well a s s. 239(2)(f), advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege related to CN Train operations. AND The Seal of the Corporation be hereto affixed. WILLIAM G. MATSON JAMES M. DIODATI CITY CLERK MAYOR Page 8 of 192 MINUTES City Council Meeting Tuesday, June 25, 2019 Council Chambers 5:00 PM COUNCIL PRESENT: Mayor Jim Diodati, Councillor Wayne Campbell, Councillor Vince Kerrio, Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Councillor Mike Strange, Councillor Wayne Thomson, Councillor Chris Dabrowski, and Councillor Lori Lococo COUNCIL ABSENT: Councillor Carolynn Ioannoni COUNCIL LATE: 1. IN CAMERA SESSION OF COUNCIL - 4:00 PM 1.1. In-Camera Resolution ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Vince Kerrio, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that Council enter into an In -Camera session. Carried Unanimously (Councillor Ioannoni was absent from the vote) 2. CALL TO ORDER O Canada - Performed by: Jaid Atkinson 3. ADOPTION OF MINUTES 3.1. Council Minutes of June 4, 2019 ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Wayne Campbell That the minutes of June 4, 2019 be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously (Councillor Ioannoni was absent from the vote). 4. DISCLOSURES OF PECUNIARY INTEREST Disclosures of pecuniary interest and a brief explanation thereof will be made for the current Council Meeting at this time. Page 1 of 18 Page 9 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 a) Councillor Kerrio indicated a pecuniary interest to Report PBD-2019-39 (Boarding House Study). 5. MAYOR'S REPORTS, ANNOUNCEMENTS a) Mayor Diodati extended condolences on the passing of Ricky Crabbe, son of Cathy Crabbe in the Mayor and CAO's office. Ricky was a former Chippawa volunteer firefighter. Also extended condolences on the passing of Karen Anne Peoples, niece of Dale Morton of the CAO's office. b) Mayor Diodati welcomed our new City Solicitor, Donna Jaques as she has assumed the role of City Solicitor and Director of Legal Services. Donna has held previous solicitor positions in private practice and with the Municipality of Chatham-Kent as well as the City of Guelph. Most recently, she was General Council for Ontario Transportation Commission. c) Mayor Diodati advised of the upcoming Canada Day Event here in Niagara Falls stating the following points of interest: • Join us on Monday, July 1st for our Niagara Falls tradition: the Canada Day Parade. • Parade begins at 11:00AM sharp in downtown Niagara Falls. • Other Canada Day activities include: o 1K and 5K run/ walk at Oakes Park for St. John Ambulance at 9:00AM o Citizenship Ceremony at the Niagara Falls Public Library at 9:15AM o Niagara Falls Concert Band performance 10:15-11:00AM in front of the NF Public Library o After the parade, be sure to make your way to the stage in front of City Hall at 12:30PM for ▪ opening ceremonies ▪ live entertainment ▪ children’s zone ▪ artisan market ▪ Canada Day car-show ▪ extreme music and sports area ▪ food vendors, buskers and more! 6. APPOINTMENTS / PRESENTATIONS 6.1. Humane Society - Top Fundraiser Recognition Mayor Diodati and Council, along with Regional Councillor Peter Page 2 of 18 Page 10 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Nicholson recognized 11 year old Piper Hollingsworth for being the top fundraiser for the Humane Society. 6.2. The Ben Harpur Big Game - Ottawa Senators defenseman, Ben Harpur, spoke to Council about his charity Ball Hockey Tournament being held at the Gale Centre on Friday July 19, 2019. Mayor Diodati recognized Ben by presenting him with a thank you gift from the community. 6.3. Niagara Region Presentation - Transportation Services (Presentation added) Frank Tassone, Associate Director, Transportation Engineering and Carolyn Ryall, Director, Transportation Services Division, from the Region, updated Council on the Region's 5 year forecast in order for Council to be aware of the projects they are working on in the current term of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Vince Kerrio, Seconded by Councillor Victor Pietrangelo that Council receive the presentation as information to Council. Carried Unanimously 6.4. Ohnia:kara Aspiring Global Geopark Project Darren Platakis, Acting Chair - Ohnia:kara Aspiring Global Geopark Steering Committee and Phil Davis, Indigenous Culture Liaison, presented to Council an update from the Aspiring Global Geopark Project. RECOMMENDATION: That the matter be referred to staff. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Victor Pietrangelo that the matter be referred to staff and for Council to receive the presentation for information. Carried Unanimously 6.5. Positive Living Niagara (Presentation added) Jackie Barrett-Greene, Manager of Education, Support and Volunteer Services and Wendy Matthews, Coordinator of Volunteer Services, from Positive Living Niagara gave a brief presentation to Council regarding the "Red Scarf Project," which brings HIV awareness to the community Page 3 of 18 Page 11 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 through a display of scarves along Queen Street in Niagara Falls. Flag-Raising - Positive Living Niagara - requesting a flag-raising on Thursday, November 28th. RECOMMENDATION: That Council approve the request. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Mike Strange, Seconded by Councillor Wayne Campbell that Council approve the request by holding a flag raising ceremony on Thursday, November 28th, 2019 in recognition of Positive Living Niagara and the “Red Scarf Project” which brings HIV awareness to the community. Carried Unanimously 6.6. Bickles Hardware & Supply - Deputation and Proclamation Request Dino Fazio and Rick Tisi, Chair of the Main & Ferry BIA, addressed Council to discuss the upcoming Bickles 100th Anniversary event on Saturday, August 24th, 2019 on Main Street (between Ferry and Peer Streets) from 11 AM - 5 PM. Proclamation Request - The proclamation request is to declare August the "Official Month of Bickles Hardware & Supply." Fee Waiver Request - RECOMMENDATION: That Council approve the request. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Vince Kerrio that Council approve the proclamation request declaring August the "Official Month of Bickles Hardware & Supply" and for Council to waive any City fees associated with the event and to congratulate Mr. Bickle and Mr. Victor DeCaria on 100th Anniversary. Carried Unanimously 6.7. Ontario Waterpower Association (OWA) (Presentation and charter added) Stephanie Landers, Manager of Community Relations and Public Outreach, addressed Council with the intention of Council signing the Ontario Waterpower Champions Charter and to proclaim "Waterpower Page 4 of 18 Page 12 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Day" on June 20, 2019. The presentation outlined the Niagara Falls' communities current waterpower (hydroelctric) assets and the long term sustainable (economic, social and environmental) planning opportunities. RECOMMENDATION: That Council approve the request. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Chris Dabrowski that Council approve the request to proclaim "Waterpower Day" on June 20th and approve signing of the Ontario Waterpower Champions Charter. Carried Unanimously ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that Item 10.4 gets moved up on the agenda. Carried Unanimously ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Vince Kerrio, Seconded by Councillor Victor Pietrangelo that Item 12.1 on the agenda gets moved up on the agenda and to move forward the passing of by-law 2019-76. Carried Unanimously ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Vince Kerrio that by-law 2019-76 gets read a first, second and third time and passed. Carried Unanimously 7. PLANNING MATTERS 7.1. Public Meeting (Report and presentation added) PBD-2019-39 Final MHBC Boarding House Study Additional memo and letter added. The report recommends the following: 1. That Council approve the final MHBC Boarding House Study. Page 5 of 18 Page 13 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 2. That the Official Plan Amendment, Zoning By-law Amendments and Licencing By-law be adopted and passed, respectively, at the July Council meeting. Alex Herlovitch, Director of Planning, Building and Development gave an overview of the background report PBD-2019-39. Dana Anderson, from MHBC Planning Urban Design & Landscape Architecture made a presentation to Council regarding report. • Linda Bissell of 6540 Taylor Road, Manager of Continental Inn, spoke in opposition of the report. • Rajinder Singh of 8675 Montrose Road, Motel Owner spoke in favour of the report. • Art Federow of 4079 Marshall Road, spoke in opposition of the report. • Bernard Peters of 8004 Lundy's Lane, Owner of Carriage House Motel; Former Owner of 2560 Mewburn Road and Continental Inn, spoke in opposition of the report. • Brian Clayton of 5756 Ferry Street, spoke in opposition of the report. • Diane Corkum, Executive Director of Project Share spoke with concerns of affordable housing in the Niagara Area. • Tony Parker, Office Administrator of the Victoria Centre BIA spoke in opposition of the report. • David Jovanovich, Project Administrator for the Lundy's Lane BIA spoke in opposition of the report. The Public Meeting was closed. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Lori Lococo, Seconded by Councillor Wayne Thomson that the motion to defer PBD-2019-39, Final MHBC Boarding House study. Councillor Campbell requested a recorded vote. DEFEATED. With Councillor Kerrio declaring conflict., Opposed Councillor Jim Diodati, Wayne Campbell, Victor Pietrangelo, Mike Strange, and Chris Dabrowski ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that single room occupancy designation continue to go through a zoning by-law application and that Council look at revising the policies in place. Page 6 of 18 Page 14 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Councillor Campbell requested a recorded vote. CARRIED. With Councillor Kerrio declaring conflict., Opposed Councillor Wayne Campbell ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the City advertise for any property owners that are interested in making applications for affordable housing components. Wayne Campbell requested a recorded vote. CARRIED. With Councillor Kerrio declaring conflict. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that staff investigates the use of a community improvement plan (CIP) for affordable housing. Councillor Campbell requested a recorded vote. CARRIED. With Councillor Kerrio declaring conflict. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Lori Lococo that staff contact the Niagara Region, Provincial Government and Federal Government regarding the announcement of the fifty five billion dollar fund for affordable housing. Furthermore, engage MP's and for staff to come with a report to Council. Carried Unanimously With Councillor Kerrio declaring conflict. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Lori Lococo, Seconded by Councillor Wayne Campbell that Council express its appreciation to staff, the service providers, community partners and agencies for their work to support vulnerable and homeless populations in the community; and that staff continue to engage with Niagara Region Community Services and community partners to provide outreach and support Page 7 of 18 Page 15 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 services and report quarterly to Council; and that City calls on the provincial government to reverse current and previous funding cuts for affordable housing, homelessness, mental health and addictions programs; and further, that the City of Niagara Falls delegation will express these concerns and requests to provincial ministers at the upcoming AMO conference and work with the government relations team to demonstrate the need for increased funding. Carried Unanimously With Councillor Kerrio declaring conflict. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Mike Strange, Seconded by Councillor Chris Dabrowski that staff gather information from the Province to review the Landlord and Tenant Act. Carried Unanimously With Councillors Kerrio, Pietrangelo and Campbell declare conflict. 7.2. Public Meeting PBD-2019-43, Amendment to the Lundy's Lane Community Improvement Plan and Improvement Plan Area Boundary Applicant: City of Niagara Falls The report recommends the following: 1. Council approve an amendment to By-law No. 2018-31 to revise the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Area Boundary and an amendment to the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan to add a new multi-unit residential use as an eligible cost under Section 3.2.3 ‘Tax Increment-Based Grant’. 2. The amendments be adopted at the July Council meeting. 3. The amendment to the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan be submitted to the Province for review under Section 28(5) of the Planning Act. Alex Herlovitch, Director of Planning, Building and Development gave an overview of the background report PBD-2019-43. The Public meeting was closed. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Page 8 of 18 Page 16 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Councillor Chris Dabrowski that the report be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously With Councillor Pietrangelo absent from the vote 8. REPORTS / PRESENTATIONS 8.1. F-2019-21 Insurance Renewal Report The report recommends that Council approve the 2019-2020 Comprehensive Insurance Program from Frank Cowan Co. Ltd. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Vince Kerrio that the report be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously 8.2. HR-2019-03 Ontario Living Wage Network Initiative The report recommends that Council receive the following information on the Ontario Living Wage Network initiative as it pertains to the City of Niagara Falls. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Vince Kerrio that Council receive report for information. Carried Unanimously 8.3. MW-2019-16 2019 Playground Improvement Program Supply and Installation of Playground Equipment Page 9 of 18 Page 17 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 The report recommends the following: 1. That Council award the supply and installation of playground equipment at Alpine Park, Fern Park, Glengate Park, Meadowvale Park and Theresa Park to the preferred proponent Henderson Recreational Equipment Ltd. for $199,653.67 + HST. 2. That the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to execute the necessary documents. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Wayne Campbell that the report be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously 8.4. MW-2019-17 Asset Management Policy The report recommends that Council approve and adopt the attached Asset Management Policy. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Chris Dabrowski that Council approve and adopt the Asset Management Policy. Carried Unanimously 8.5. PBD-2019-38 (Report Added) Overview of Proposed Amendments Bill 108 (More Homes, More Choices Act) The report recommends that Council receive the report for information. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Vince Kerrio, Seconded by Councillor Wayne Thomson that Council receive the report for information and that staff look at comments from other municipalities to formulate our own resolution. Page 10 of 18 Page 18 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Carried Unanimously 8.6. PBD-2019-41 (Report Added) Decorative Entrance Features & Walls in New Subdivisions City Policy The report recommends the following: 1. That Council assume responsibility for decorative entrance features in new subdivisions as public assets. 2. That Council establish a policy of requiring new decorative entrances to be located on the road allowance rather than on private property and obtain easements for existing decorative entrances for maintenance purposes. 3. That moving forward, developers be required to provide sufficient securities to replace decorative entrance features in addition to covering the cost to construct them initially. 4. That Council begin the process of seeking easements for existing features and establish a fund for their future maintenance. 5. That Parks Design staff be directed to ensure developers provide entrance features that are high in quality and relatively easy to maintain during the subdivision process. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the report approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously 8.7. R&C-2019-14 Gale Centre Emergency Repair The report recommends that staff be authorized to undertake the removal and replacement of the two Domestic Hot Water Tanks at the Gale Centre. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Vince Kerrio, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the report be approved as recommended. Page 11 of 18 Page 19 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Carried Unanimously 9. CONSENT AGENDA The consent agenda is a set of reports that could be approved in one motion of council. The approval endorses all of the recommendations contained in each of the reports within the set. The single motion will save time. Prior to the motion being taken, a councillor may request that one or more of the reports be moved out of the consent agenda to be considered separately. F-2019-26 Monthly Tax Receivables Report – May The report recommends that Council receive the Monthly Tax Receivables report for information purposes. F-2019-27 2019 Schedule of Fees for Services The report recommends that the Schedule of Fees as presented in the attached schedule, be approved effective July 1, 2019. F-2019-28 Low Income Seniors’ Water and Property Tax Rebate The report recommends for the information of Council. HR-2019-04 Cooling Stations during Heat Advisories The report recommends that Council receive the following information regarding the City’s “cooling stations” during extreme heat advisories. Page 12 of 18 Page 20 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 PBD-2019-40 PLC-2019-003, Request for Removal of Part Lot Control Blocks 294, 297 and 299-301 (inclusive) in Plan 59M-463 Warren Woods Phase 5A Plan of Subdivision Applicant: GP Empire Communities (Niagara) Ltd. The report recommends that Council approve the request and pass the by-law included in tonight’s agenda to designate Blocks 294, 297 and 299-301 (inclusive), Registered Plan 59M-463, as exempt from Part Lot Control for a period of two years. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Chris Dabrowski that the reports are approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously 10. COMMUNICATIONS AND COMMENTS OF THE CITY CLERK 10.1. Street Re-Naming Request Nemanja Jevremovic and Borislav Zivkovic, members of the Serbian Community, requested Council (via letter attached) to rename Bender Street to Nikola Tesla Way. Two Additional Letters added : Street Naming Request - Bender Hill RECOMMENDATION: That the matter to be referred to Staff. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Lori Lococo that the matter be referred to staff so that they may come back with a report including ideas for the Street-naming and to engage the requester throughout the process. Carried Unanimously 10.2. Niagara Region - Niagara Regional Housing Quarterly Report RECOMMENDATION: That Council receive the report for information. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that Council receive the report for information. Page 13 of 18 Page 21 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 Carried Unanimously 10.3. Ash Trees in the Town of Fort Erie and Region of Niagara RECOMMENDATION: For the information of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Thomson, Seconded by Councillor Vince Kerrio that Council receive and file the information. Carried Unanimously 10.4. Issuance of Cannabis Licenses in Residentially Zoned Areas RECOMMENDATION: For the information of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Wayne Campbell, Seconded by Councillor Chris Dabrowski that Council receive and file the correspondence for information. Carried Unanimously 10.5. Noise By-law Exemption - Summer Blues in the Park Requesting Council to make an exemption to the City's Noise By-law asking for it to be changed to 10:30 pm for the Summer Blues in the Park series on Thursday nights (From 2nd Thursday in June until the last Thursday in September, 2019). Tansu Barker, of 6855 Christine Court, a local resident would like to speak to the matter. Reg Holloway, of 6811 Carmella Place also spoke to the matter. RECOMMENDATION: For the Consideration of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Mike Strange, Seconded by Councillor Victor Pietrangelo that the request for a noise by-law exemption be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously Page 14 of 18 Page 22 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Mike Strange, Seconded by Councillor Lori Lococo that staff meet with members of the SCVFA to come up with mitigation measures of sound and invite neighbours to attend. Carried Unanimously 10.6. Noise By-law Exemption - Request from organizers from Summer Daze BBQ Classic Summer Daze BBQ Classic will be held at Fireman's Park on August 24th & 25th, 2019 and organizers are seeking an exemption from Council to the City's Noise By-law for the playing of live music outdoors until 11 pm each night. RECOMMENDATION: For the Consideration of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the request for a noise by-law exemption be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously 10.7. Noise By-law Exemption and Special Occasion Permit Request from Chippawa Volunteer Firefighters Association seeking an exemption from Council to the City's Noise By-law for the playing of live music outdoors during the Annual SPN Slo-Pitch Tournament and Street Dance, which is taking place at the Chippawa Lions Park on Saturday, July 13th, 2019. The request is to ask for an extension to midnight for this event. Also requesting that the City declare the annual event as "municipally significant" in order to assist with obtaining a Special Occasion Permit. RECOMMENDATION: For the Consideration of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the request for a noise by-law exemption be approved and that the City declare the annual event as "municipally significant" as recommended. Carried Unanimously Page 15 of 18 Page 23 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 10.8. Clifton Hill BIA - Requesting approval of the 2019 budget. RECOMMENDATION: That Council approve the Clifton Hill BIA 2019 Budget. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Mike Strange, Seconded by Councillor Victor Pietrangelo that Council approve the Clifton Hill BIA 2019 Budget. Carried Unanimously 10.9. Association of International Horticultural Producers (AIPH) Expo 2025 Correspondence sent offering an opportunity for municipalities to participate in the Expo in 2025. RECOMMENDATION: Refer to Staff for a report. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Vince Kerrio, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the matter be referred to Staff for a report. Carried Unanimously 10.10. Niagara Region - Report PHD 09-2019 respecting Amendment to Outdoor Second-hand Smoking and Vaping By-law RECOMMENDATION: That the Council of the City of Niagara Falls consents to the passage of By-law No.2019-52 of The Regional Municipality of Niagara, being a by-law to amend By-law 112-2013 - A Regional By-law to Protect Children and Vulnerable Persons from Exposure to Outdoor Second-hand Smoke. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Vince Kerrio that the report be approved as recommended. Carried Unanimously 12. RESOLUTIONS (Resolution No.5 added) Page 16 of 18 Page 24 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 12.1. No.4 - Resolution Interim Control by-law (see motion passed under Item 6.7 as it was moved up in the agenda) 12.2. No.5 - Demand for Payment from City of Niagara Falls. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that resolution no.5 - Demand for Payment from City of Niagara Falls be passed. Carried Unanimously 13. BY-LAWS The City Clerk will advise of any additional by-laws or amendments to the by- law listed for Council consideration. 2019- 72 - A by-law to fees and charges for various services, licences and publications for the City of Niagara Falls. 2019- 73 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 79-200, to permit the use of the Lands for detached dwellings (AM-2018-019). 2019- 74 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 79-200, as amended by By-law No. 2003-46, to recognize the existing industrial use on the Lands (AM- 2018-025). 2019- 75 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 79-200, to recognize the existing duplex on a portion of the Lands and permit a detached dwelling on the balance of the Lands (AM-2019-002). 2019- 76 - A by-law to prohibit certain uses of land in the area of the City of Niagara Falls regulated by Zoning By-law No. 79-200, as amended, Willoughby By-law No. 395/66, as amended, and Crowland By-law No. 1538/1958, as amended. 2019- 77 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 89-2000, being a by-law to regulate parking and traffic on City Roads. (Stop Signs at Intersections, Yield Signs at Intersections, Parking Prohibited) Page 17 of 18 Page 25 of 192 City Council June 25, 2019 2019- 78 - A by-law to designate Blocks 294, 297 and 299-301 (inclusive), Registered Plan 59M-463, not be subject to part-lot control (PLC-2019- 003). 2019- 79 - A by-law to authorize the execution of an Assignment and Amending Agreement with Venerino V.P. Panici Architect Inc. and Whiteline Architects Inc., respecting the assignment and amendment of the architectural services agreement for the new fire station project. 2019- 80 - A by-law to adopt, ratify and confirm the actions of City Council at its meeting held on the 25th day of June, 2019. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Victor Pietrangelo, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the by-laws be read a first, second and third time and passed. Carried Unanimously (Councillor Campbell was absent from the vote) 14. NEW BUSINESS 15. ADJOURNMENT a) Adjournment ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Chris Dabrowski, Seconded by Councillor Mike Strange that the meeting be adjourned at 9:55 PM. Carried Unanimously Mayor City Clerk Page 18 of 18 Page 26 of 192 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Municipal Works SUBJECT: MW-2019-18 Former Parks, Recreation and Culture Building Proposed End Use RECOMMENDATION 1. That Council direct staff to initiate the process under Section 31 of the Ontario Heritage Act to repeal By-Law #2010-90 thereby removing the Heritage Designation from the subject property (7565 Lundy’s Lane); and, 2. That the property be incorporated into the design and expansion of the Lundy’s Lane Cemetery; and, 3. That site development details including installation of a central columbarium feature, memorial garden, gateway feature and historical signage (i.e. plaques) and update d cost estimates be presented to Council for consideration as part of the 2020 Capital Budget deliberations. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The former Parks, Recreation and Culture (PR&C) Building sits on a 0.5 acre parcel of land at the corner of Montrose Road and Lundy’s Lane. The building has been vacant since September 2005 after operations were moved to the MacBain Community Centre. During this period City Council has considered a number of options including designation, demolition, divestiture and adaptive re-use of this asset. Over the past 14 years, there has been substantial deterioration of the interior and exterior of the building. The sale of the lands and building has become less attractive due to its condition. The costs to renovate the building and/or modify the structure for an indoor columbarium are prohibitive. The purpose of this report is to seek Council’s authorization to implement an end use plan that includes the removal of the Heritage Designation, demolition of the building Page 27 of 192 2 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 and a strategy to incorporate the property into the current landscape of Lundy’s Lane Cemetery. BACKGROUND BMA Management Consulting Inc. was hired in 2003 to undertake a detailed analysis and provide recommendations on the highest and best use for the building. The three options included; 1. Sale of property to a third party; 2. Alternate cemetery operational uses for the building (visitation center/columbaria); 3. Demolition of the building & development of the lands for cemetery purposes (plots and columbaria) and a beautification component in cooperation with the Lundy’s Lane BIA. In 2010 the building and property were recognized for its ‘cultural heritage significance’ and received Municipal Heritage Designation. With this designation, the building cannot be demolished without Council consent. At its meeting on June 25, 2013 City Council adopted the recommendations set out in the Cemetery Service Delivery Review. Included was the recommendation to demolish the former PR&C building with the intention of expanding the Lundy’s Lane Cemetery. On August 13, 2013, Council passed motions directing staff to investigate the feasibility of an adaptive re-use of the existing building for an indoor columbarium and to defer a decision on the removal of the designation. Report CD-2013-05 (see Attachment 1) provides a more detailed chronology. Cemetery Staff have investigated two options (i.e. Demolish the existing building for development of in-ground plots, outdoor columbaria and enhanced landscape features; or Redevelop existing building for use as an indoor columbarium) as well as associated costs and anticipated revenue opportunities. The findings are summarized below in Analysis/Rationale. To date plans to occupy, and/or sell the building have not come to fruition. The condition of the building, both interior and exterior, has continued to worsen, increasing the costs for renovation/retrofit and presenting a potential safety hazard to the public. In seeking a final resolution regarding the end use of the PR&C building, Cemetery Services continues to recognize the importance of recognizing the historical nature and significance of the property and original structures (i.e. Green’s Corner). As such, staff propose to recognize the cultural significance of the property through inclusion of Page 28 of 192 3 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 materials from the building in the development of a gateway feature, landscaping and signage/memorialization. ANALYSIS/RATIONALE The former Parks, Recreation and Culture building is a designated heritage property under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act because of its cultural, social and associative value. While some of the exterior architectural elements have deteriorated over th e years, these features remain intact and are an important part of the building’s cultural significance. The Ontario Heritage Act requires that Council consult with the Municipal Heritage Committee (MHC) for a recommendation. When consulted, the MHC did no t support de-designation. Should Council proceed with rescinding the designating by-law, it must publish a notice of intent in the newspaper. The public is provided 30 days to comment or appeal to Council’s intended action. An appeal must be sent to the provincial Conservation Review Board (CRB). The CRB will schedule a hearing to receive submissions on the reasons to retain or remove the designation. Following the hearing, the CRB makes a recommendation to City Council which may follow the recommendation or take alternative action. For instance, Council could rescind the designating by-law which may not follow the position of the CRB. Council’s decision is final. It would follow that the PRC building could then be demolished. That being said, the province is currently in the public consultation period for proposed changes to the Ontario Heritage Act. Should these changes come into force, any appeal to de-designation would be sent to the Local Planning Area Tribunal (LPAT) instead of the CRB. LPAT would conduct a hearing to receive comments for or against de- designation. Following the hearing, LPAT would issue its decision. LPAT’s decision is final. So, if LPAT did not support de-designation, the Council would have to accept that decision and could not demolish the building. The building is located at the signalized intersection of Montrose Road (Regional Road 98) and Lundy’s Lane (Regional Road 20). Both of these roadways are under the jurisdiction of Niagara Region. Currently, the only vehicular access to the property is located off of Montrose Road which only permits right-in and right-out movements, due to the presence of a center median island. Additional access points and movements to/from of the property would not be permitted by Niagara Region, due to the amount of traffic, proximity, and configuration at this signalized intersection. The subject intersection is included in the Region’s 10 -year capital program for the reconstruction of Lundy’s Lane. At that time, it can be expected that the interse ction will Page 29 of 192 4 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 be improved and expanded to address future capacity requirements. There is currently a 1.5-2.4 metre road widening reserved along the two road frontages of the property to allow for these future improvements. Lastly, the Region has a Booster Chlorination Station located on the property that would remain if the property was redeveloped or disposed of. To satisfy the Region’s requirements, access would need to maintain to this facility through an easement and/or transfer of portions of the property. Option 1 - Proposed Cemetery Development The City of Niagara Falls remains a very traditional market with respect to end of life choices. There remains a high demand for in- ground burial plots (i.e. singles, doubles, triples, etc.) within our cemeteries, and more specifically at the Lundy’s Lane Cemetery. At the same time, families electing cremation as the preferred method of disposition are seeking creative and beautiful alternatives, such as columbarium features, for their loved one’s final resting place. In reviewing the opportunities for th e land currently occupied by the Old PR&C building and associated parking lot, it is estimated that with the demolition of the building and subsequent cemetery plot development, approximately 275 cemetery lots could be made available. The additional develo pment of outdoor columbaria, including a large columbarium feature (i.e. 400 niches) with central memorial garden, and additional domed units (i.e. 72 niches per columbaria built on an as needed basis), would expand interment service options, currently not available at the Lundy’s Lane Cemetery. In addition, the re-development would also provide attractive landscape features (see Attachments 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6) to the beautification efforts proposed and supported by the Lundy’s Lane BIA and local bereavement industry professionals. Operations/Maintenance costs associated with this option are limited to lot/niche opening and closings (i.e. Fee for Service) and grounds maintenance (i.e. mowing, trimming, etc.) which is already occurring at Lundy’s Lane Cemete ry with existing staff. The additional flower bed/landscape features would be included in the City Wide Beautification contract. The anticipated timeline to complete this project is approximately one year including; the removal of the heritage designation (i.e. 4-6 months - 2019); the demolition (i.e. 1 month – 2019); and the development of in-ground plots, central columbarium feature and memorial garden and gateway feature (i.e. spring 2020). The estimated cost and projected revenue related to this option are presented in the following Financial/Staffing/Legal Implications Section. Page 30 of 192 5 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 Option 2 – Repurpose Existing Building As An Indoor Columbarium At the direction of Council, staff investigated the option to re -purpose the existing building for use as an indoor columbarium. This option would provide a substantial number of niches for cremation inurnments. At a glance, it would appear this option would also provide a significant opportunity for revenue. That being said, th ere are a number of issues and/or concerns that should be considered when evaluating this option. Cemetery Staff met with contractors (Ontario Environmental & Safety Network Ltd. and Scott Construction Niagara Inc.) to tour the building and identify necessary modifications, updates, retrofits and remediation required to develop an indoor columbarium, taking into consideration the heritage act as well as accessibility standards. To renovate the existing building including the removal of asbestos, improvements to the interior and exterior and niche cabinet installations it is estimated that funding in the amount of approximately $1,720,000 - $ 2,046,000 million would be required to completed the initial work required with approximately $15,000 - $20,000 required annually to maintain and operate the facility. The old recreation building is an aging structure. While the initial capital investment would improve the interior and exterior of the building for a time, significant on -going maintenance and over-head costs would be required in order to ensure proper up keep in perpetuity. Annual general maintenance costs would include electrical, heating/cooling, water/wastewater, insurance, security, custodial and general/emergency repairs. On-going improvements would also be required and would adhere to the heritage act and accessibility standards. As previously experienced at Stamford Green Heritage Columbarium, these restrictions could prove to be costly (e.g. Stamford Green roof replacement - Heritage Specific Roof - $90,000, standard roof of similar size - $20,000 - $25,000) which the City of Niagara Falls would be entirely responsible for in perpetuity. The anticipated timeline to complete this project is also approximately one year. The estimated cost and projected revenue related to this option are presented in the following Financial/Staffing/Legal Implications Section. Given the significant capital and lifecycle costs, staff do not recommend Option 2. Page 31 of 192 6 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 FINANCIAL/STAFFING/LEGAL IMPLICATIONS Option 1 - Proposed Cemetery Development – Capital Cost Breakdown Initial Investment Description (Capital) Anticipated Cost Anticipated Revenue Demolition and Abatement of Existing Building $255,000 $0 Grading & Development of 275 In-Ground Lots $25,000 250 Lots x $3,000 = $750,000 400 Niche Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature * $275,000 400 x $2,500 = $1,000,000 Gateway Feature & Corner Garden $75,000 $0 Totals $630,000 $1,750,000 Total (Revenue Less Cost) $1,120,000 *Additional Columbarium would be installed on an as needed basis. Option 1 - Proposed Cemetery Development – Annual Maintenance Cost Breakdown Annual Maintenance Description (Operating) Anticipated Cost Anticipated Revenue Garden Planting & Maintenance (Contractor) $5,500 $0 Total Annual Cost $5,500 *Seasonal Maintenance (i.e. mowing, trimming, etc.) would be completed by existing staff already on site April – November. Page 32 of 192 7 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 Option 2 – Repurpose Existing Building As An Indoor Columbarium – Capital Cost Breakdown Initial Investment Description (Capital) Anticipated Cost Anticipated Revenue Removal/Remediation of Designated Substances* $320,000 - $646,000 $0 Renovation of Existing Interior & Exterior* $1,400,000 $0 400 Niche Units** $ 250,000 400 x $2,500 = $1,000,000 Sub-Totals $1,970,000 – $2,296,000 $1,000,000 Total (Revenue less Cost) $970,000 - $1,296,000 *Based on 2013 estimates. ** Additional Niche Cabinets would be installed on an as needed basis. Option 2 – Repurpose Existing Building As An Indoor Columbarium – Capital Cost Breakdown Annual Maintenance Description (Operating) Anticipated Cost Anticipated Revenue Electricity $800 $0 Water $1,200 $0 Natural Gas $5,000 $0 Fire Monitoring/Security $1,000 $0 Cleaners/Carpets $1500 $0 Garden Planting & Maintenance $3,500 $0 Building Maintenance $2,500 $0 Total Annual Cost $15,500 *Estimates based on cost of existing Lundy’s Lane Cemetery Building Page 33 of 192 8 MW-2019-18 July 16, 2019 CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT The recommendations contained within this report are in keeping with the following strategic commitments; economic vitality, financial stability, and customer service excellence. LIST OF ATTACHMENTS 1. Report CD-2013-05 – 7565 Lundy’s Lane – August 13, 2013 2. Proposed Aerial Illustrating Redevelopment of Recreation Building Property 3. Artist Rendering - Proposed Redevelopment & Layout of Landscape & Columbarium Features 4. Artist Rendering – Proposed Landscape & Corner Gateway Feature 5. Artist Rendering – Proposed Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature – Spring 6. Artist Rendering – Proposed Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature – Fall 7. Memo from OESN - Former Parks & Recreation Building and Site Photos 8. Letter from Morse & Son Recommended by: Erik Nickel, Director of Municipal Works Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer Mark Richardson, Manager of Cemetery Services Page 34 of 192 CD-2013-05 Niagarafalls August 13, 2013 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of the Municipal Council City of Niagara Falls, Ontario SUBMITTED BY: Clerks Department SUBJECT: CD-2013-05 7565 Lundy's Lane RECOMMENDATION That Council direct staff to proceed with the steps to repeal the designating by-law (2010- 90) as per section 31 of the Ontario Heritage Act EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The property known as 7565 Lundy's Lane and related building, has been the subject of numerous reports since 2005. Council's various past motions have included demolition.. designation, rezoning and putting the property for sale on the open market. If Council is intent on demolishing the building for expanded cemetery services, it will be required to repeal the by-law which designated the property as having a cultural heritage value. The first step to repeal is to consider the recommendations of the Municipal Heritage Committee, which are the subject of report PBD-2013-51. If Council decides to continue with repeal of the by-law, the provisions under the Ontario Heritage Act are to be followed. BACKGROUND The property. and more specifically the building at 7565 Lundy's Lane. also known as the former school at Green Corner's and, most recently, the former Parks & Recreation Building, has been the subject of more than a half a dozen staff recommendation reports and close to a dozen motions by the various Councils of the day since 2005. The approved Council motions over the years have included demolishing the building, investigating adaptive re-uses for the building, not demolishing the building, putting the property on the open market, rezoning the property for tourist commercial uses, designating the property under the Ontario Heritage Act, taking the property "off the market" and, most recently, removing the heritage designation to allow for demolition of the building. The history of these various motions is laid out in the first attachment. Some other important background points related to the property: a study requested by the Municipal Heritage Committee was prepared outlining the history, architecture and design of the property and building, which formed the basis of the Statement of Cultural Heritage Value for the designating by-law, as outlined in PBD-2013-51, also a part of tonight's Council agenda. An appeal to the designation was launched by various members of the Lundy's Lane BIA, however, the appeal was withdrawn before a hearing, under the Ontario Heritage Act before the Conservation Review Board, took place. Although the BIA's preference was the original staff recommendation of demolition, which included a beautification gateway, the appeal was withdrawn after assurances that any future use of the property would have to maintain the heritage attributes of the building. Page 35 of 192 August 13, 2013 2 - CD-2013-05 With regard to the proposal by Mr. Felix Pingue, local business person, Council rejected Mr. Pingue's proposal in 2009. A report at the time outlined the three options available to Council: Mr. Pingue's proposal, building demolition and putting the property on the open market. Council approved getting the property appraised, putting it on the open market with a reserve bid with notice of Council's future intent to designate the property. It was indicated at the time that Mr. Pingue could make an offer when the property was listed for sale. The appraised value of the property at the time was $216,000. In fairness to Mr. Pingue, the property was never formally put on the market for him to make an offer, as Council passed a motion in February 2011 directing staff to not include the property with others it was putting on the market at the time (the decommissioned arenas). Despite not "officially" being on the market, some parties have expressed an interest and toured the building, even since Council's recent motion to demolish. The building, however, remains in much the same state as when the Parks, Recreation and Culture department vacated. The property has never been made presentable for the intent of staging it to sell. ANALYSIS/RATIONALE If Council is intent on following through on the motion from June 25`", to demolish the building to develop cemetery plots, the historical designation on the property needs to be repealed. The process to repeal a designating by-law is set out in section 31 of the Ontario Heritage Act (see flowchart attachment). The first step requires Council to consult with the Municipal Heritage Committee MHC),Council's advisory committee on heritage matters. MHC's recommendation is set out in report PBD-2013-55, namely, that the designating by-law not be repealed, as the heritage attributes remain, and that any decision to demolish the building is deferred until further investigation into the adaptive re-use of the building is explored. If Council chooses to reject MHC's recommendation, notice of intent to repeal the by-law would be published in the newspaper and sent to the Ontario Heritage Trust. The thirty 30) day notice period would allow for appeals to the Conservation Review Board (CRB). An appeal(s) could lead to a hearing and report by the CRB. Council would only have to consider the CRB's decision, but it is not bound by it. Regardless, the repeal of the designating by-law could take some time. FINANCIAL/STAFFING/LEGAL IMPLICATIONS If it is Council's intent to proceed with the repeal of the designation by-law, it is to follow the process outlined in the Ontario Heritage Act. CITY'S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT Review policies and service delivery with respect to the changing demographics of Niagara Falls. Page 36 of 192 August 13, 2013 3 - CD-2013-05 LIST OF ATTACHMENTS Chronology of recommendations and motions by Council re: 7565 Lundy's Lane R-2009-14 Repeal of a Designating By-law Flowchart Recommended by: J f J"` / IL-- Dean lorfida, City/Clerk Respectfully submitted: 4tAttAi Ken odd, Chief Administrative Officer DI Page 37 of 192 Date: May 2005 Staff Recommendation: To accommodate expansion to the Lundy's Lane cemetery, the building be demolished. Council Decision: Deferral because of interest expressed by Niagara Falls Tourism. k k # Date: June 2006 Staff Recommendation: Expand Lundy's Lane cemetery, demolish the building and enhance beautification through a gateway feature in conjunction with the Lundy's Lane BIA. Council Decision: Deferral at the request of the Municipal Heritage Committee to investigate the "adaptive re-use of the building". Date: June 2007 Staff Recommendation: Expand Lundy's Lane cemetery, demolish the building but incorporate brick and stone work into the beautification gateway feature in conjunction with the Lundy's Lane BIA. Council Decision: Staff recommendation approved but prior to demolition, a local businessman, Mr. Felix Pingue, made a plea to save the building. The matter was referred to staff and Council passed a motion to not demolish the building in the interim Date: June 2008 Staff Recommendation: That the building not be demolished, that an offer be sought from Mr. Felix Pingue to refurbish the building, at no cost to the City, and that a detailed building end use plan, outlining specific space utilization, be provided Council Decision: Staff recommendation approved. Page 38 of 192 Date: April 2009 Staff Recommendation: A staff report is presented outlining the pros and cons of the Pingue Proposal,the cemetery expansion proposal and putting the property on the open market. Council Decision: That the building be appraised, put on the open market with a reserved bid, with notice of the future intention to designate the building under the Ontario Heritage Act. Date: October 2009 Staff Recommendation: A City initiated zoning by-law amendment is heard to permit the property to be used for tourist commercial and office space uses from open space. Council Decision: Zoning by-law amendment approved. Council reiterates its intent to designate the building under the Ontario Heritage Act. Date: June 2010 Staff Recommendation: That Council pass the by-law designating the property as a building having cultural value or interest. The by-law comes forward after City staff met with the objectors from the Lundy's Lane BIA to review future use opportunities and commercial potential for the building. Subsequently,the objectors withdrew their objection allowing the by-law to come forward Council Decision: The designating by-law is approved. Date: August 2010 Staff Recommendation: 7565 Lundy's Lane be declared surplus and the building be sold subject to a reserved bid of $216,000. Council Decision: Staff recommendation approved. Three councillors opposed. Page 39 of 192 Date: February 2011 Staff Recommendation: Sale of various City lands be conducted on "as is, where is" terms on a staggered basis. Council Decision: Council directs staff not to include 7565 Lundy's Lane in the sale of City properties. No rationale given. Date: June 25, 2013 Staff Recommendation: That the heritage designation be removed from the former Recreation Building and that it be demolished develop 400 cemetery plots with a corner Columbaria / Gateway beautification initiative. Council Decision: Council votes in favour of the recommendation 5-3. Page 40 of 192 April 6,2009 r R-2009-14 ooloalirt NiagaraPalls Councillo-Caroi:nn loannoci Chair anc Ven'be's of the Community Services Comm'ltee City c` Niagara Fails. Ontario Pit er be-s Re: R-2009-14 Recreation Property & Building End Use RECOMMENDATION: fret Council :noose their preference of the three options proposed for tee forme' Recr erior buildirg located at 7535 _undys Lane- BACKGROUND: Ai. vitt. r3434;'441:4 I.: 4:11 313 34;'441:4 I.:-:324: ro Past Reports/Decisions n ":1a.. 2'205, staff firs', prepared a recommendation -eport on the end use of the former Recreation bu Id ng located at 7565 Lundy Lane To accommodate expansion to the Lund/s Lane cemetery, tee report recommended demolition of the budding. Ccunc:• cote-reo a decision _after nterest in the building was expressed Ty'Niagara FalsTaurism. r Jute 20!,96. staff returned w'th a recommendation report. After consultation rnth the Lundy a Lane BIA, staff oor tlnuec to recommend tie expansion of the Lundy's Lane Cemetery, however, with the accommodation of a pedestran gateway which wood enhance oeau:ifloat on. The report was deferred after a request oy the tutuciopa Her:age Committee to investigate the 'adaptive re-use or tee pudding'. r 201. gar 3 recommendations -mainec c carte as:he r2scr-_-n eeiws:;ear oonsulta:icr .vita tee Municipa Heritage Committee,:t was assured that brick and stone work from the buildrnc.vnuld 7e incorporated Into the des gn arc la-dscaco features or the Ceunci;approved the recommencations container to the Jane 25C%report_. I lowever,prior to tee scheb,sled der-oiit:oe of Ire t:u:id ng a ocal busiressmar, '.Ar =elix a.ngue, made a e ea to sate t--e oui'dirg. The maderwas ref=-red to staff and Council passed a motion is not demo ish the oulld rig in the 'nterm. 14 orkie Together[u 3cr'ce Our Community3 ocino.klity services p Partment A K M50 Montmsefl44'Unitt NlagararallsdN,Canada L2N3N3 4os-3567521 www.nlagarafallsca Page 41 of 192 April 6, 2009 2 - R-2009-14 In June 2008. an update report was provided that recommended that the building not be demolished. that an offer be sought from Mr. Felix Pingue to refurbish the building, at no cost to the City, and that a detailed building end use plan, outlining specific space utilization, be provided. In light of budget delioerat ons. it is prudent to seek some final resoiutior to the long- standing issue of end use of the former Recreation building. Overview of Pingue Proposal the building would have some commercial business space for uses such as an insurance business or law firm Pingue Construction would maintain an office for heir adminstrative functions. Community. meeting spaces would be available on the lower floor(basement)and incude a new"cultural room" Heritage space would accommodate public and private art or museum-like collections. nine parking spots would be provided. A rew d-iveway entrance from Lundy's Lane is proposed two ground signs and rent from potential tenants would provide revenue for the operation. despite potential sign anc rent revenue. the building would be operated cn a -break even bas's"with any revenue going into a reserve fund to support potential building- related costs in future years. the City would supoort the annual building operating costs associated with taxation and building/property insurance. the City would maintain ownership of the building with a long-term lease(50 years; entered into with Mr Rogue or a related company. Overview of Cemetery Proposal the removal of the existing building allows for the expansion of the cemetery adjacent Lundy's Lane cemetery', which could provide oetween 257 to 305 additional craves. a pedestrian gateway feature and enhanced corner landscape woad be developed in conjunction with the Lurdys '.Lane BIA. The BIA would financially contribute to the project costs Open Market Proposal Senior staff also discussed the possibility of declaring the property surplus which was an option for property end use In 2003-study by BMA It would only ae sod with the provision of a minimum reserved cid equal to the net revenue estimated under the Cemetery proposal Page 42 of 192 April 6,2009 3• R-2009-14 Pros & Cons of the Three Proposals PINGUE PROPOSAL PROS CONS A ouilei-g that nas had histor cal uses s • The property zoned Open Space. wh.cb ma maned- limits the use of tre building to cemetery. The building 2mains for commun ty use hospital. recreational uses, reiiglous The proponent has stated h s nterl to institution and School_ nvest$260,000 into the Cuilding. A zoning by-iaw amendment for toe intended The Ofr,cial Plan dentiT,es the area as uses would be required General Commerc a: t GC„ it keep ng • Tne proposed driveway access from Lundy s I with toe proposal Lane 's unlikely to be supported by the Parking appears sufficient lc-intendea Region, the road autnor.ty use. Any taxes realized by the new uses is to be absorbed by the municipality_ No revenue for the City. as envisioned n the othe-two options. The property would remain on the City's hst of properties it maintains, but 'rom wh,cn the C ty does not realize revenue. The refurbishment of the build ng for continued use and -e occupancy will require a management play to detail how any hazardous mate•ials will be managed or apatec. including asbestos, lead, and moid The proposal may be viewed as °bonusing" order the Municipal Acr. as a private individual v,tl derve a benefit from the oroocsa.. Page 43 of 192 April 6, 2009 4-R-2009-14 CEMETERY PROPOSAL PROS CONS Expanding the cemetery would meet the • The Former Recreation building w II be current Open Space zoning. demolished. Ar environmental assessment paid for • In light of be fiscal challenges berg faced in by the C ty has been completed 2009, the gateway feaure may be :oo specifically to the demolitor of the expensive and no longer a priority project. building The gateway proposal and enhanced landscaping prov de beautification and g-een space 'n this towns:condor. Partial fording would be provided by the urdy's Lane B A. There is a demand for more cemeteryy plots at _undy's Lane cemetery. 305 graves would represert new maximum net revenues of approximately S'.95,000 to cemetery services. Local funeral homes are in favour of be nitiative. OPEN MARKET PROPOSAL PROS CONS The Official Plar identifies the area • The former Recreation building could be as General Commercial (GC), which demolished depending on the future use. may entice interest in the property. • The property is zoned Open Space and The proeerty is located in a busy would require a zoning by-law commercial area. amendment for commercial uses. An environmental assessment paid • The property may need to be 'up zoned' for by the City has been completed by the City to be truly marketable. specifically to the demolition of the • Putting the property on the market would bu Iding. prevent cemetery exoars'on or Sale of the property would p-ovide beautification efforts. one-time revenue for the Access ssues may preclude certain mupipipa ity. development. Putting the proeerty on the open No appra'sai has been done to date. market would al:eviate any concerns o` 'conusirg" The property would be removed from the City s inventory of buildings requiring maintenance and upKeep. The building could conceivably. be maintained in its current form if a buyer is so inclined. Mr. Pingue could still bid on the property. Page 44 of 192 April 6, 2009 5- R-2009-14 CONCLUSION: The matter of tie end use of the City-owned building at 7565 Lundy s Lane has long been studied, discussed and debated. Staff has outlined what we view as the three available options for the property Obviously, all of the options offer pros and cons and it will oe for Council to weigh the merits and provide direction to staff on how they wish to proceed. Recommended by re rl 145. Denye Morrisse irecto of Parks. Recreation & Culture oproved by Ed Dujlov1c, Executive Director of Community Services 0 74 1,P 03r: Y k 05 -7 s. giatr n,.. Page 45 of 192 6 - April 6, 2009 Council Minutes 6 Niagara Child and Youth Services Foundation-Requesting that the week of May 2-9. 2009 be proclaimed as`Children's Mental Health Week"in the City of NiagaraFalls RECOMMENDATION For the approval of Council ORDERED on the motion of Councillor loannoni seconded by Councillor Thomson seconded that the request be approved. Carried Unanimously Ontario Coaches Week - Requesting that April 18" - 26'", 2009 be proclaimed as Ontario Coaches Week" in the City of Niagara Falls RECOMMENDATION. For the approval of Council. ORDERED on the motion of Councillor loannoni seconded Dy Councillor Thomson that the request be approved. Carried Unanimously Canadian Mental Health Association - Requesting that May 4-10. 2009 be proclaimed as "Mental Health Week' in the City of Niagara Falls and that Council support a flag raising during that week. RECOMMENDATION For the approval of Council ORDERED on the motion of Councillor loannoni, seconded by Councillor Thomson that the request be approved Carried Unanimously REPORTS RATIFICATION OF COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMITTEE MATTERS ORDERED on the motion of Councillor loannoni,seconded by Councillor Maves that the actions taken in Community Services Committee. on April 6 2009 be approved. Carried Unanimously 1 The minutes of the March 23, 2009 meeting be approved. 2 MW-2009-21 -DWQMS Operational Plan with Presentation 11 That City Council endorse the Drinking Water Quality Management System Operational Plan. and 2) That staff be authorized to make the appropriate application to the Ministry of the Environment prior to May 1, 2009 3 BS-2009-01 - House moving concept in partnership with Niagara Regional Housing Niagara Region, Niagara Catholic District School Board, Ed and Ruth Ann Nieuwesteeg and the City of Niagara Falls That the City provide grants equal to land costs, various permit costs and to assist in dealing with Hydro and the Niagara Regional Police 4 R-2009-14- Recreation Property and Building End Use Update That the former Recreation Building be appraised, put on the open market with a reserved bid, with notice of the future intent to designate Page 46 of 192 4 Repeat of Designating Syia;i, Council's Initiative Section 31 of the Ontario Heritage Act) Repeal proposed Council consults with MHC Council Decision. N Proceed with repeal? Bylaw not repealed Notice of Intention to Repeal: 1.Served or property owner 2.Served on OHT 3 Published in newspaper Objections within 30 daysn Objection referred to I Notice of Hearing CR8 for hearing published in newspaper CPR hearing and repent Council Decision: Repeal bylaw? Ccuncil considers CP6 Report Repeal bylaw passed& I Notice of Withdrawal of registered nn cite Nfencan to Repeal: 1 Seed on property outer 2 Served on 01-4T 3.Published ut newspaper Notice of Repeal: 1 Served an onoper y owner 2 Served rx OHT 3.Published in newspaper Bylaw not repealed Property removed from municipal and provincial registers Property removed from Canadian Register Designating Heritage Properties•Appendix: Flowcharts Page 47 of 192 Dean Iorfida From: Marco Pingue <mpingue @cogeco.ca> Sent: Tuesday, July 02, 2013 5:14 PM To:Dean forfida Subject: RE: Demolished Recreation Building Thanks Dean'. I will pass the info onto my Dad. Regards Marco Original Message From: Dean Iorfida [mailto:diorfida @niagarafalls.ca] Sent: Tuesday, July 02, 2013 4:43 PM To: 'Marco Pingue'; Jim Diodati; Alex Herlovitch; Ken Todd Cc: Wayne Gates; ioanonni @niagarafalls.ca; vince @overlookingthefalls.com; Bart Maves Cogeco Account; Joyce Morocco; Victor Pietrangelo; Wayne Thomson Fallview Account; Janice Wing Cogeco Account Subject: RE: Demolished Recreation Building Felix( and Marco): Further to our discussion today part of the requirements to "de-designate" the old Recreation Building will be for Council to formally hear from its Municipal Heritage Committee (MHC). recort from the ,TlHC is slated for the August Council meeting That would be the appropriate meeting for you to address Council and I wlll list you for that agenda (August 13;. In the meantime. will get you the documents you requested before the end of the week. Thanks Dean Dean Iorfida, City Clerk Niagara Fails 905-356-7521, ext. 4271 905-356-9083 ((Fax) From: Marco Pingue [mailto:mpingue @ cogeco.ca] Sent: Monday, July 01, 2013 4:39 PM To: Jim Diodati Cc: Dean Iorfida; Wayne Gates; ioanonni @niagarafalls.ca; vince @overlookingthefalls.com; Bart Maves Cogeco Account; Joyce Morocco; Victor Pietrangelo; Wayne Thomson Fallview Account; Janice Wing Cogeco Account Subject: Demolished Recreation Building t Page 48 of 192 P R . P E D E S T R I A N A C C E S SPR. FLAT MARKERS (50)PR. FLAT MARKERS (68)PR. REGULAR LOTS (103)PR. REGULAR LOTS (57)PR. IRON FENCEPR. DECORATIVE PILLARPR. COLUMBARIUMPR. GATEWAY FEATUREPR. MEMORIAL GARDEN &FLOWERING TREEPR. BENCHESPR. BENCHESPR. BRICK WALLPR. LANDSCAPE BUFFERPR. STORYBOARD FEATURELUNDY'S LANE CEMETERY IMPROVEMENTSPROPOSED REDEVELOPMENT OF RECREATION BUILDING PROPERTY1:150MJK2019/03/190Proposed Columbarium FeatureProposed Gateway FeatureProposed Storyboard FeaturePage 49 of 192 Proposed Redevelopment & Layout of Landscape & Columbarium Features Page 50 of 192 Proposed Landscape & Corner Gateway Feature Page 51 of 192 Proposed Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature - Spring Page 52 of 192 Proposed Columbarium & Memorial Garden Feature - Fall Page 53 of 192 _uox_<_mm_u>x_Amm.xmmxm>:ozmc_E_zmNopm _<_m<mm.BB Q23z_mmm_\m_nm__m $5O,:mm:£32 2_mmm$3:»O2 Sm33 $08wmmum?mi33 mmxmomm?qmoo ”m<m_moammBmm__m.nm >3:$3<m_mo._<_.m:w:_..m:m..88.E<__u 9.1w::%:mO3n_m_ mm_<_m_<_o:2E8_.::Q<_m_.m:m.mozsmq51$m.xmnammzozm:_E_:m 02.810m:<_3:3m:S_m.mm..mn<zmH<<o1_A_.E.Aommz.<<mmmzmmmmg8u«o<Emm: €928.mosaic:mmmmmm3m:n3.Em?maocm3m.?m:m_m<<_.E3Em3.3231$w xmnwmmzozm:__&:m.._.:mmzmm2E<Emm<_m_§_0:>3:5~89 wmnxmqocza Ommz _ <no__m2mQ_3.o3_m:o:_.mmm:::m:mNm3o:m3m.8_._m_m3Noam.mcsm?mznmm a_m2533Bow<<m«m>mcmm3m.E3._<.m3E<magE:mm_m_m3m3m.>:3 mcc?msnmm:m<muwmmnlcmmuqonmmcqmmSam_.EmOnn:um:o:m_Imm_EW3&2>2. _<_oqmmumninmSEmO:$2o2:E23_.mUo:_.Emu>mumm8m._.mmmmag§m8:_.<Eamw Em_umm_m:m.mmamcvm?msnmmxmm:_m:o:m.._.Emmmmmmm3m:.n_%=§8Em3m»m1m_m.8cm3 moonno:aEo:. <mm1<mosaic:mmmmmm3m:GEmaEmmanozqcn?mg<<_E_:Em3.5%.8Qm?mlizmK amm?sm?mamcc?msnmm_.m3m§ma_:moonmosaics._:>u1_~03.Emmmmmmm3m3 no:n_:Qm9amamnmi1%.8czuqo?m?maumaozmms?mzsmEmE:aim8:mNm8_o:m 253229%..>Eo_.:mnoznmzimzoz8>mUmm8m3:8mxnmmm_n_mmS:nm__m<m_m mm:m_.m__<muuzmgmccmmncms?nom:mmcmmaomm_um~m3m:nmn:<:<.n_mm8:nm_m<m_mmam _u_.mmn2_oma3oimzo_<:323_.m.uo:qmm98<8._..%2m:n:m_:<:._mmm:«m3m:G *333:01.383.53988.ob?mQ8EH3._n::mm_m_m3m:$SE3Em c:_E_:mM323m_m:_:nm3nosnmzqmzosm.3::m«mmd>mumR:.==m\nm:Q.S.:3mam mSQ_§o¢E.>mumSE:m\wm:m§.:5nosnms?mzozm3£3w?o.§\m:_no:3m\3m. .£mQ_§o3aEzmmmdb.Noxso8:3m\3w?nm:mnmmEm_o_mnozomzimzosm29__.__ 35mmam.mo8:3m\3m.xmnoaamsgmzozmimam232:2.3u«m<m:.numaozm$03 mimzzmEmU:2%::_mmmE<Eoamn?ma€m3o:m_u3nmm:<mmn:€3m::mmmima Em::mmn_:mNm&o:m3mnm1m_m. 9:9:>mmmmm3m3 Emmmmmmm3m:.n8332.>9:HPNOSEssam?z?nmsn.§£_o;ao:3 muu3x_3m.nm_<mo:ow3312_o:mmcxmnmm.._.:m3819anaimmclmnmm<E_E ommz _ dam_.CZU<.mSzmz_>m>x>E5.02Homw ozdzzomz<_xoz_<_mz4>rm.w>mm._.<zmjzoxxEd.Page 54 of 192 moxzmxw>x_Amm.mmmzm>:ozmc__b_zm85 8:33mmwmmnom33m$_mms:_mm:nomzzmmEm<mcmm:_3:mQm:c<Emnmq3n:G_o:. Emn::.m:»Somsmm<.£m3wm__o<<3mEmama8m:.nm_,Emc:=:§m.3%383.0:Emm _3nmQmQEmmmnozg:00:33::03ms:cmmm3m:?_m<m_.._.:m<<m__m:1mnmmmam &m:_mnm::<m.8_:mo_SE:33m_d<<Ems:3322_onm.n_o:mE92am3mmm.Em 3.3.22_m<m_mSE3Ema:__o::m:mm:3m_.m»m:_n::mm_m_.o<<Eo:Sex.o3: mcsnmnmm. Emn:2m:.nm?gmomEm_3m2o_.mE+mnmm«mn:__,mm«m3o<m_ms:«mu_mnm3m3::m8 ..::mm_m«o<<E.._.o83:23o:_:mcm.83m3mn:<3mm«mn:_«mmmmcm?omm_umnm3m:.n. ._.Em:2<<m__no3uo:::saw"mmnm:Sqmmcmmnom8333ms::m~m«33m:_uom._<m_2: mmwm?omAnE«<mo:_m..Emmom::mm€m3¢<<mmnmm»m:31$?3m3:«<ms:maman Sims:Emoomzsmmno:.8_:m_mm:nos?mi_.m:m_:m52.3.$833. Em38:01mclmnmmno:.$S_:mmmcm?omHmun3xm3mnm_<Sumomy m:o:_:«mo_m3m:o_._3Em33122:32;_.m3m_?32:mwm.nm3m:»2m__::m1o_. m:2mnmmW«mn::m:.._.ono:::nnEmm:1mmmnoimn?n_mm:_:m<<___«mn:.:mmmcmmnom mcm~m3m3mn:<_:mm8cm_:o_::m:SE3mmnoum3.<<o1r>::m3mmm3:..<<<m__ m:1mnmmEm:qmncwm«mum?<<. _ «mn::mmmcmm?ommEm~m3m3uwoommcqmm.8cm _3_u_m3m3m:_.m.:o_mm3<<m__mms:mm:mm.2<<m__m9.3cmmnnmu.Bc_<n_mm:m:23:3 m_m3m:.G.Em_mmmn<3mmcmm?om:2<<m__no3vo::Q<<«m3m_:.>:<m::m:¢:E«m<<0lA SE3EmE:Ezm<<«mn::m.:m3m:mmcm?om<<o_._AmGnocmmsmmmma3no3:_m.?mms mcm.nm3m:..u8_.mQU2018_.m.«:::_:mm_mn3nm_nmc_mm.Emzmim__m_:.._xn:_.mm.m2mE.:m Enncqmm.8<<m__m.man. >nmmmm8m.:.:Q:B_nozsmnzosm8Em2003ms:<<m__mmm:3ocmm2mc_m.U:m8 Emnmq:m3mmmms:ocmmémac:_m3m<<m__m_mm¢:nEE_m:m§mm_.m:o:E8:::Qm: mmmmmm3m3332:2Eammmmmm3m3. >nnmmm8Em3520..2Emw:__:_:m_.mp::mmumwmozm8cm:m:_m:_:Em:mNm3m3 >mcmm8m.rmmm.ma:_<_o:_:.._.Em.:m3_:m«mn_::,m3m:.G3:23mm;Em0:310_<__:_m.:< 2535qm:::m3m:G.nm_.mo:mmimzsmEmc:=E:m3:m.n:m<mm<m__m_u_mm:um«mo:m_ n3.8nz<mmn:€3m3.mmoo:83_:m:o:3n__:_mmms:<<mm.nm3:2. 3magic:8Emamm?sm?mnmccm?mzmmmms::mNm&o:m3mHm1m_m5:_:m.2235: mmmwzmn3Sm322%Fmzm:_mm\n_m&m«nm:_:mm:23‘mzumSumms:$__mAvoozzm SE33+m__m:mm..:mEmm.mm__m:Emmwmwmm..:mm.noimzam.£335»am83:23. xmnm::<3>3:NOEEmE:SmEmmamm3m...__m_m<m.nmn_1%.8umwmozmmznmzsmEm w:_E_:m95.83:m_m:o::mNm_.:mo:.§§1_E$ms:m:_..mm_m_m3m:.G.n:_.«m::<.Em :m3mmm:no::_:o:m<<_E.:Emw:__Emuomm:::mm_E<83%:mEm”EmmEm uo»m::m_3m33m:_mnm_<:33csvqo?mn?mmumwmosm. >«m<.m<<2n::.m35.53c2m_:mqmmm?immwm?m3m:.n<<o1AEmmmEzmmcmczmms35 X$03»Emc:__:_:mEmmmuu3x_3mHm_<$.80Romm:1mn_:m33m1m_.mEo:EEm 3.820.‘noimimcmoo?mnnn_mm:mmms:_,m3m:1:.8nrm3.33:32&2o$.u.~o.ooo m::m::Uum«ccmmm?3mm?yooo.8u3<EmE:mm_mUm.nm3m3mn:<:3ms:«ma?a ommz _ damE293Szm‘z_>m>z>«>5.ozMomw 02.320mz<_moz_<_mz§rWmznmizmjzoxx_.._.U.Page 55 of 192 mox_<_mm_u>x_Gmxmmmm>:ozms_S_zm~95 Essaam83529..E8:951:23mcmnm3m3mn:<_zmm33:3msmwmznmmEm 38:3mslmnmmS:5o_.8:am:.mm2m8_:3mowno3m33m:o:sue:no3u_m:o:om Emu3_.m2manEm..m3«m3m<«mns:.mEm«m3o<m_0*cs=%:m3m~m1m__m. EosiEmcsE_:mcm«mns:mo_8cm§a.s2mEmm8m9.<Smmo3vos:Qm.E:mm_ m_m3m:$o:3819mslmnmm.:Ammv3mEm3.nm1o«msznmnmE?nsm33_3s33%: mas32mm2mwwoboobo‘m.Emboo.ooEosacmnozmamwma. EosaEmUs__n::mUmmcm?ma3mEmm.8mmagms:mm_m_m3m3mc<_.m3o<m_am:.3312 ms3.mnmmsssmnmmcmmnom._.<ummm_um:m3m:nmn:<_:mm.mno3c_mnm_:.nm1o«sm3o_2am2 3..BmobooEosacmnozmamqma. wmmo33m:gm:o:m EmQ2Eosanoszzsm8no33s:_om:mSEm__:;mEm__umvm33m:Gqmmmqqszm §m<m::o:omumaozmmimzzmEm_2_s_%_m. Essacmaoimvam32.338mnnmmmEmcs_E3m.EmQ2Essamsmsqmmamnsmnm ::o«3m:o:«mmm&_:mEm:mNm&m:m<mcmm:mmmn:<m_<mc33s:_8:ma.Em 33«3m:o:Eos_..._no3m_:m__mmumn?m3EmOnnsumzoza:mm_Emmm?mH<>2mas «mns__.m3m:.GEm..m3. EmQ?Essamo:mam_,Emmo3u_mnmam3o<m_omm_.nm_._o_.mslmmmm.3323Z n_mm:_:mmagqmumismmslmnmm._._mm_wo=28Eosam3.mm:o_.mslmnmmcm3395... ?m33mmagE\sn.E$_no3no:m:$3m<EoSam:.83sm3mmm._.o?o_.sm?m_._oS:o: ssm8msxmmm8332SESm.nm«\3o_m.?sqm.>no:::mm:n<95%.3sm.ncmSimsmag magma8no<m«mmmoamnmanow?SEmcmHm3m3mn:<_:mms:oo<m::m2&2.qm3mmmm. _.nGmE3m.nms.8812mmo:no:::mm:n<.2322:EmmUmHm3m3.>3o<m3__3&2 3138201msznmmmqm3o<m_Wmmwomboobo >E.sm.EE_m:m_:mm«Essam<m_smnmEm_3mm_.:<0...Emzoo:Sm:magmm:m no::mm:o:m\m.8c<.Emm$sQsE_m:m_:mm_.Sqmnssam333_3s3.EqmmE<:9 U133mvm..m3m:r9:3mcmHm3m3masuom?mcm.nm3m3. n_omm.Osn :%cs__%:m«mns:mmmno3u_m.nm_3m1o«msqwmnm«m3o<m_HoEm?m33mno3vo:m:.8. Z3§_.a$SEEam:m_<m_m_mEm:<>nm<?m32ammmonwzmsno3uo:m:$.:_m mzzn?m?msm__I<>nmasmmmogm?ms83vo:m:GSE«mns__.mmo3m3«3o;cm:m3m:n ca«mu_mnm3m:.n.Emu3_.m2«mns__.mmmmamm?ommcmHm3m:nmn:<_:mm9.no:Qo_m.8am 83.5882:2Emcs_E_:m3:mnslmzn29$._<_sE3EmmslmnmmEmm233.38 :o:.qmum_Ec_mgm3mmm.>:<m:m3§non_mm:mslmnmmno_$%332S:3Em<mm:< msmwms?mm.EmE.sn..s$__:.nmm_&<wmnssammE«Em«m<m_sm:o:‘zoszunonmnnmgumaozm EosamimwEmUsSmmmm33m&m~m:mm_E_.m_m.nmsm<3u83mScmmxumzmsnma. ommz _ damE293Ezm.z_>m>x>_n>:m.ozwonm oz:/aomz<_xoz_<_mzdFW.m>mm._.<zmaSox_A_.._._u.Page 56 of 192 City of Niagara Falls 0O015.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: I?‘‘S Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 57 of 192 City of Niagara Falls 00015.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: /..$OntarioEnvironmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 58 of 192 City of Niagara Falls OO015.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: If“‘$Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 59 of 192 City of Niagara Falls 00O15.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Nates: Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 60 of 192 City of Niagara Falls 0O015.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 61 of 192 City of Niagara Falls 00O15.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: :"‘‘S Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 62 of 192 City of Niagara Falls OOO15.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: In Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd‘Page 63 of 192 City of Niagara Falls 00015.241 Former Parks and Recreation 2019 Condition Evaluation (Comparison Photos) Notes: I!“Q Ontario Environmental Safety Network Ltd.Page 64 of 192 ry-$r{ MORSE & SON FT'NBRALHOME uCnnodo's Fdrst F*ncrsl E[omz" 59T7 MAIN STREET NIAGARA FALI.S, ON L2G 527 1-905-356-3550 / FACSIMILE l-905-356-99r6 G. ERNEST MORGAN CFSP, DIRECTOR Est. t826 Est. 1959 MORGAN FT'NERALHOME "Toar lleritage F*nerol lIomc" 4I5 REGENT STREET, PO. BOX 453 NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAIG, ON LOS IJO r 905-468-3255 / FACSIMILE t-905-356-9916 AI-AIN A. GIGNAC, DIRECTOR MORSE &SONLIMITED July 10, 2019 Mayor Jim Diodati and Members of Council City of Niagara Falls 4310 Queen Street P. O. Box LO23, Niagara Falls, Ontario L2E 6X5 Mayor Diodati and Councillors: Re: Undesienation an demolition of former Citv of Niasara Falls ion Office Build lnE As per our earlier letters to the Mayor and Council dated May 1-6, 2006, and then again on August 9, 2013, we wish to offer our strong endorsement of the ongoing recommendation offered by both the Cemetery Services staff and by your own consultants, BMA Management Consulting (2003), and Lees & Associates (MW-20L3-L2 Cemetery Service Delivery Review), to "demolish the (former Recreation) building and use the land for columbaria and other interment options." As indicated in their detailed analysis, this option has the least risk and the greatest revenue potential for the City. I would also support the idea originally shared by the members of both the Lundy's Lane B.l.A. and the former Park in the City Committee that the corner of Montrose Road and Lundy's Lane would benefit from the increased greening and beautification. I was very dismayed during the last review of this project that Council did not adopt the recommendation to demolish the building, and instead was led astray by a single member of the community to do something entirely different with the building - a promise and a proposal that has never come to being. What further dismays me, is that due to delaying the demolition, the original cost of S11L,000 is now more than double, exceeding 5250,000. As Canada's oldest funeral home (L826), and certainly Stamford Township area's first funeral home, we have been providing services to families choosing the Lundy's Lane Cemetery for many years, dating back to when it first existed as a Methodist cemetery. With the relative recent acquisition of the former Nagy property along the north boundary of ,t.-i '7r,:iE:.i,Ei{-lll liEl .:ilqit':1---{ ijliIl,li5 J !itl1.i:ri ilFfuru 1" lF*g* \- l': r jilFr 'il?'il . , i!ilir5A,#il=i- ,.1 {'=' . ,r4 ?- c: n 'E . FJ ?aE ,.- Page 65 of 192 Lundy's Lane Cemetery, we were relieved, at least for the short term (10-15 years), of having to continually disappoint City families by having to inform them there was no longer full size grave space available at Lundy's Lane. lt is very important to succeeding generations, that they are able to arrange for final disposition of family members in the same cemetery in which many of their former relatives are interred. By further opening available space within the cemetery, there would be the potential and opportunity to develop cremation interment lots, and the potential of establishing a scattering garden, and the erection of columbaria at Lundy's Lane to assist in meeting the final disposition needs of the increasing number of families selecting cremation (65-7o0/ol as their primary former of disposition. Further, by increasing the number of grave and/or columbarium spaces available for purchase, the City stands to realize inceased funds for both operation and long-term trust benefit (i.e. Perpetual Care & Maintenance Funds). ln closing, I again encourage you to adopt the ongoing recommendation of your Cemetery Services staff and those of the consultants whose expertise were sought to provide clear and impartial direction with respecttothe ideal end use of theformer Recreation Office Building. Respectfu lly subm itted, G. Ernest Presid Morse & n CFSP 2lPage Page 66 of 192 July 10, 2019 Mayor Jim Diodati & Members of City Council City of Niagara Falls 6310 Queen Street Niagara Falls, ON L2E 6X5 Dear Mayor Diodati & Members of City Council, Re: City of Niagara Falls – MW-2019-18, Demolition of Former Parks, Recreation & Cultural Building The Lundy’s Lane BIA has been in discussions with City Staff regarding the viability of saving or re-purposing the former Parks, Recreation & Cultural Building at the corner of Lundy’s Lane and Montrose Road for several years. Ideas have been put forward and attempts by local entrepreneurs to utilize the building have not been able to get off the ground. During this time the former Parks, Recreation & Cultural Building has continued to deteriorate to the point where it is not feasibly salvageable. As a result, the Lundy’s Lane BIA is in support of the demolition of the former Parks, Recreation & Cultural Building for the creation of public space on the corner of Lundy’s Lane and Montrose with remaining land utilized for Lundy’s Lane Cemetery purposes. With this intersection being a major gateway onto Lundy’s Lane and for the City of Niagara Falls, as well as being an integral part of the Lundy’s Lane Streetscape Master Plan, the LLBIA would like to see the following:  That the design development of the former Parks, Recreation & Cultural Building site be done in conjunction with the design of the gateway design of the entire intersection.  That this design process be accelerated and that this becomes part of the Phase 2 Projects of the Lundy’s Lane Streetscape Master Plan.  That the design be in line with that of a major gateway.  That a proper balance of public space and cemetery space be achieved.  That the public space on the corner have an interpretive element depicting the history of the corner, building and settlement of this portion of Lundy’s Lane.  That a significant yet appropriate piece of public art be created for this space.  That the LLBIA be part of the design of this space and that of the intersection.  That the design of the supporting sidewalks and street lighting emanating from this intersection design be continued from the Montrose Road intersection west along Lundy’s Lane to the western boundary of the Lundy’s Lane Streetscape Master Plan. Preserving historical buildings should always be considered and all attempts to save the former Parks, Recreation & Cultural Building have not been practical. The time has come that we need to move on and Page 67 of 192 make a concerted attempt to highlight the history of the building in an interpretive and educational way in the public space that will be created. The Lundy’s Lane BIA, as always, wishes to be part of this endeavour. Best Regards, David Jovanovic Tish DiBellonia Project Administrator, Chair, Lundy’s Lane BIA Lundy’s Lane BIA 905-401-8247 905-371-8579 Page 68 of 192 July 9, 2019 Members of City Council City of Niagara Falls 4310 Queen Street Niagara Falls, Ontario L2E 6X5 Dear Members of City Council: We are writing in support of the proposal to remove the old structure located on the southwest corner of Lundy’s Lane and Montrose Road to facilitate the expansion of Lundy’s Lane Cemetery. Many people wish to be interred in Lundy’s Lane Cemetery and this expansion would allow more of our residents to have their wishes fulfilled. We have no doubt that the development will be done tastefully and would be esthetically pleasing. We have often heard people remark on how beautifully kept our cemeteries are, which is a testament to the management and staff who look after them. We are pleased to offer our support for this project and would be more than pleased to answer any questions you may have. Sincerely, Ed and Ruth-Ann Nieuwesteeg Patterson Funeral Home Page 69 of 192 Upmbz?. Cum<<mrrnmrmmm>._.mo. Q23z_mmm_.m_um=m Qo_<_m}2338: _um:<_m<<nm3m»m2 Ummwm__.mman_<_mam3m. EmmmmEaE_m_m3m_.mmm:Euo_.133ImEm1:m.8:m.Ummzmm::mS_nEmum_E3<oc_.2Emmxumzaoz 9.:53}Samnm3mnm28_:8:uo3nmmno_:3cm1:32am:.:n..mmmmQ2:3239.m3m:o:mag u:1m_E03ozEm_um8m_2_2an::m::<EocazmEm.___%_%§_3_.3m«mEoo_Eocmm. <<:=mEm32:335...Eocmm23m5253.c:_E_:m.Em8383m_:$_::u3um«_<m:Q«mum:Em Emmaea.mm1...8omxmmn8_.:S5..<<m«mnm_<m:c3mS:m.:n:_1mmm<m3~35Em93.3..<oqm no_:3Em::3.2EmEmmaman0185:.Emmxvmsaos.mmm32...omEm2:33»3Emzmm<ammamsnm. :m_umaSEwo3moqEmqmncm?mEaQmimzozovzosm2aBowm5:13mumnmm.ESno_c3cm1:3mmam cmooazam3o_.mBa:63_oou:_m«SEEmE55..::mS_23%._.::_<cm__m<m<o:Sosammmmcnmmmm SE:%2cm9.mxumznoz2_.:_.a<.m_.m:mnm3mnm2._..Emm_.mm:<33.3..mumnmc<3m:<z_mmm_.m _nm__mqmmamznmsEomm23:%mmuuo_3ma8Ba:.3;mmmnnoaaonmzsmmmmm._.<.m<<nm3m"m_.<SE 35%no2.33._. <9.$322?_.Em_.n_w_.:_nm:o:$03EmumG_umn2<moqozm2Emn:<.moammnP_:m_.m_Eo3m.m Emmmmno:3Emmw?m8ammo:9:83m. <53:333%. Io__<xocmmmmc _u::m_.m_Io3mimzmmmq .5/.5 _ _./ mim<wmno:m><m3cm,Z,m©m$mm:m.038:0Kmgmw _ oommw/?mmm? >9.390:O.wm1:nm0050:3~m3m:o:m,mnmzmqmvC??Page 70 of 192 F-2019-31 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Finance SUBJECT: F-2019-31 Adding Provincial Offences Act (POA) Fines to the Tax Roll RECOMMENDATION 1. That Council approve the draft Inter-municipal Tax Collection Agreement with the Region of Niagara to add defaulted Provincial Offences Act (POA) fines to the City’s tax roll; 2. That Council authorize the Director of Finance to execute the Inter-municipal Tax Collection Agreement, with a form and content substantially in accordance with the draft agreement attached and approved by the City Solicitor and the Director of Finance; and, 3. That Council approve a $35 fee to be imposed on the property owners who have defaulted on their Provincial Offences Act fines and it be added to the 2019 Schedule of Rates and Fees EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Region of Niagara has requested that the City of Niagara Falls (the “City”) enter into an agreement with the Region that will improve the collection of Provincial Offences Act (POA) fines following conviction. The agreement provides the City with the ability to collect the POA fines on behalf of the Region through the property tax system. All of the other 11 area municipalities in the Region have approved the agreement. Entering into the agreement is beneficial to all 12 area municipalities including the Region, as all municipalities including the City receive the revenue derived from the POA fines based on the appropriate share assessment. The successful collection of delinquent fines directly results in increased revenue to the City. As the defaulted fine collection process is completed by the Region, this will have minimal impact on City staff and resources. Staff are proposing a $35 fee to be imposed on the property owners who have defaulted on their POA fines to cover the costs of staff time and resources. This fee would be added to the 2019 Schedule of Rates and Fees. Page 71 of 192 2 F-2019-31 July 16, 2019 BACKGROUND The Province of Ontario, as part of it strategy to realign provincial and municipal roles in the delivery of public services, transferred the authority and justice responsibilities to Niagara Region. At present, the Region performs all courts administration and support functions under the POA. The Region and the 12 area municipalities signed an inter- municipal agreement in 2000 outlining the role of the Region to undertake the court administration, support and prosecution services under the POA on behalf of the area municipalities. The City is permitted under section 441.1 of the Municipal Act, 2001 to add any part of a fine for a commission of a provincial offence that is in default under section 69 of the POA, to the tax roll for any property in the local municipality for which all of the owners are responsible for paying the fine and collect it in the same manner as municipal taxes Net revenues generated from the collections of POA fines are shared 50/50 between the Region and the 12 area municipalities. Assessment is used to further allocate funds to the area municipalities. The City has received the following annual amounts over the last five years from POA fines, which includes revenue from other municipalities that added defaulted fines to their tax roll. Further, the funds are included in other revenue within the annual General Purposes Budget: 2018 $ 182,546 2017 $ 86,310 2016 $ 102,136 2015 $ 120,334 2014 $ 197,300 A similar report was originally presented to Council on October 22, 2013 in which the following motion was made: ORDERED on the motion of Councillor Kerrio, seconded by Councillor Morocco that Council not approve the report recommending an agreement with the Region to add Provincial Offences Act fines to the tax roll Carried Unanimously Since 2013, all 11 municipalities have signed the “Inter-municipal Tax Collection Agreement” with the City of Niagara Falls being the only outstanding municipality in the Niagara Region not assisting in the collection of delinquent fines through the use of the tax roll. Page 72 of 192 3 F-2019-31 July 16, 2019 ANALYSIS The Court Services Department at the Region uses many methods to enforce the payment of outstanding fines - Suspending drivers’ licences, sending collection notices, pursuing civil enforcement, and the use of collection agencies. Despite these collection efforts the number of delinquent fines continues to grow. The Region approached the Area Treasurers in 2013 in an effort to utilize another collections tool: adding POA fines to the City’s tax roll. By approving this agreement, the City would provide the Region with an additional means to collect a defaulted fine following the conviction of a defendant. Section 441.1 of the Municipal Act, 2001 grants treasurers the authority to add defaulted POA fines to the tax roll for any property where the owners of the property are responsible for paying the fine and then collect the fine in the same manner as municipal taxes. If the property is owned jointly, the fine cannot be added. Upon a review of the file, Court Services will provide the necessary documentation to add the fine to the owner‘s property tax roll. The City would then add the fine to the tax roll and Court Services would monitor the accounts for payment. If the fine is paid at the City, the City would advise Court Services, the City would keep the fee and any interest and remit the balance of the payment to Court Services. If a fine is paid at Court Services, the fine is reported to the City and the City removes it from the tax roll The funds will be forwarded to Court Services at the Region once collected by the City. As part of the agreement the City shall, within 30 days of adding the defaulted fine to the tax roll, provide a written notice to the defaulted property owner. This method of collecting delinquent fines has been adopted by several municipalities across Ontario and has been very effective. FINANCIAL/STAFFING/LEGAL IMPLICATIONS Once the defaulted fine is added to the property tax roll, the amount operates like a municipal tax and is subject to the City’s penalty bylaw. As a result, the City will charge the property owners with penalties which may provide additional incentive for the payment of the fines. The City will keep any penalty revenue and fees associated with adding the POA fine to the roll. Currently there are defaulted fines totalling $192,526 related to properties in the City that meet the requirements and could be added to the tax roll should Council approve the signing of the agreement with the Region. From this amount the City would collect approximately $37,000 or 19.5% based on the appropriate share assessment. The Region has been very successful since 2014 when it implemented the tax roll initiative. Over $1.2 million has been added to tax rolls across the Region with $861,375 Page 73 of 192 4 F-2019-31 July 16, 2019 having been recovered, which is a 69% recovery rate. Of the number of cases added 76% have been paid in full and closed. The collection of defaulted fines will increase revenues allocated to the Region and the area municipalities including the City of Niagara Falls. LIST OF ATTACHMENTS 1. City of Niagara Falls draft Inter-Municipal Tax Collection Agreement Recommended by: Tiffany Clark, Director of Finance Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer Page 74 of 192 This agreement (“Inter-municipalTax Collection Agreement”)made this day of ,20l3. BETWEEN: THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS Hereinafter referred to as the “Municipality” -and- THE REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA Hereinafter referred to as the “Region" WHEREAS Section 44l.l of the MunicipalAct,200/,S.O.200l,c.25 permits a local municipality to add any part of a ?ne for a commission of a provincial offence that is in default under section 69 of the Provincial OffencesAct,R.S.O.I990,c.P.33 (“Defaulted Fines")to the tax roll for any property in the local municipality for which all of the owners are responsible for paying the ?ne (the “Defaulting Property Owners")and collect it in the same manner as municipal taxes at the request of a municipality that has entered into a transfer agreement under Part X of the ProvincialOffencesAct; AND WHEREAS the Region entered into a transfer agreement on December 2|.2000; AND WHEREAS the Region and the Municipality(collectivelyreferred to as the “Parties")wish to formalize arrangements so that the Municipalitymay add Defaulted Fines to the tax rolls in its municipality at the Region's request and appropriately share any collected revenue; NOW THEREFOREthe Parties agree as follows: Requests l.Subject to applicable law,when the Region wishes to request that the Municipalityadd any Defaulted Fines to the tax roll for any property in the Municipalityowned by the Defaulting Property Owners,it may do so by providing the Municipalitydetails on the ?ne and the property including: a.a copy of the ticket or summons,and b.the address of any property owned by the Defaulting Property 2.When the Municipalityreceivesatequesttoladdto its tax tollahypartof a Defaulted Fine,it shall add the amount to the tax roll of any property in the local municipality for which the Municipalityconfirms that all of the owners are responsible for paying the ?ne. Page 75 of 192 Payments,Fees and Interest 3.The Municipality may add any fee to the tax roll that the Municipalitycharges under its by-law for adding amounts to the tax roll and may charge any interest that the Municipalitycharges under its by- law for amounts collected in the same manner as municipal taxes. The Municipality shall,within 30 days of adding the Defaulted Fine to the tax roll,provide written notice to the Defaulted Property Owners responsible for paying the Defaulted Fine,of the amount added to the tax roll and of any fees and interest that may accrue under the Municipality’sby-law. The Municipality shall review tax rolled accounts quarterly to report and remit to the Region any ?ne amounts paid by Defaulted Property Owners. ,_,_,,-._._._L..m¢-e 6.The Region shall review tax rolled accounts quarterly LU lcpul L -me .....ou...s pa......,..-........... Property Owners which may be removed from the tax roll. 7.The Municipality may retain any of its fees charged for adding the amount to the tax roll and may retain any of its interest charged on the amount. Recovery and Short-fall 8.The Municipality may apply amounts it receives on behalf of Defaulting Property Owners or through a tax sale to outstanding property taxes,?ne amounts and other charges on the tax roll in accordance with applicable legislation and the Municipality'sby-laws and policies. 9.If the Region receives payment for a Defaulted Fine after receiving payment for the Defaulted Fine from the Municipality,the Region shall pay the amount to the Municipality and the Municipalityshall apply the payment to the amount tax rolled. Accounting I0.The Parties shall,during the term of this Agreement and for four years following the termination of this Agreement,maintain detailed and accurate accounts.records,books and data of all ?nancial transactions undertaken by them pursuant to this Agreement,prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles.Such records shall be available for review or audit by any party to this Agreement,during the term of this Agreement and for four years following the termination of this Agreement. Errors and Omissions I I.In the event that either party becomes aware of an error.inaccuracy or omissionin any transaction. report or notice that party shall provide written notice of such correction to the other party or ‘I u,z_,,__..J_...-_._..1-|\n property owners.In no event will a party be liable or responsioie tor any ualnagub luaululls u uni we errors.inaccuracies or omissions of another party. Notice I2.Any notice required in this Agreement shall be in writing and shall be effective if: a.Delivered personally; b.Sent by mail;or c.Sent by facsimile or email. I3.All notices and other communications shall be given to the parties at the following addresses: 2 Page 76 of 192 The Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls 43 I0 Queen Street Niagara Falls,ON L2E6X5 Attention:Todd Harrison Facsimile:905-356-20 l 6 Email:tharrison@niagarafal|s.ca The Regional Municipality of Niagara Provincial Offences Court 3 Cross Street Welland.ON L3B 5X6 Attention:Supervisor,POA Collections Facsimile:905-734-6505 Email:diane.chase@niagararegion.ca I4.Any party may change any particulars of its address for notice by written notice to the other party. Termination IS.This Agreement shall continue as long as the arrangement provided for is permitted by provincial legislation. I6.Either party may terminate its participation in this Agreement for convenience by providing thirty (30) days written notice to the other party. I7.Any amounts that are added to the tax roll for any property pursuant to this Agreement prior to the date of termination shall continue to be owed to the Region after termination of this Agreement.The representations,warranties and covenants of the Parties contained in this Agreement survive the termination of this Agreement.For greater certainty,the rights and obligations under section 5,6,9, I0 and I I shall survive upon termination of this Agreement. General I8.This Agreement shall enure to:the benefit of and be binding upon the Parties hereto;their successors and permitted assigns. I9.This Agreement constitutes the entire Agreement between the Parties and supersedes any prior understandings and agreements between the Parties respecting the subject matter contained herein. There are no representations,warranties,terms,conditions,undertakings or collateral agreements, express,implied or statutory between the Parties other than those expressly set forth in this Agreement. 20.This Agreement is governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the Province of Ontario and the laws of Canada applicable therein and shall be treated in all respects as an Ontario contract. The parties hereby irrevocably and unconditionally attorn to the jurisdiction of the courts of the Province of Ontario and all courts competent to hear appeals therefrom. 3 Page 77 of 192 2|. 22. 23. 24. No party is to be deemed to have waived the exercise of any right that it holds under this Agreement unless such waiver is made in writing.No waiver made with respect to any instance involving the exercise of any such right is to be deemed to be a waiver with respect to any other instance involving the exercise of the right or with respect to any other such right. No change or modi?cation of this Agreement is valid unless it is in writing and signed by each party. In the event that any provision or term of this Agreement is deemed invalid or void,in whole or in part,by any court of competent jurisdiction,the remaining terms and provisions of this Agreement remain in full force and effect. The parties agree that the execution of this Agreement may be facilitated through a facsimile or electronic scanned copy and/or this Agreement may be executed in several counterparts and any such facsimile or electronic scanned copy and any such counterpart shall be deemed to be an original and such facsimile or electronic scanned copies or such counterparts together shall constitute one and the same instrument and shall have the same force and effect as an executed original. IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties have caused this Agreement to be executed on the date set out below. Dated at Niagara Falls,this _day of ,20l3. THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS Per: Name: Title: Name: Title: I/We have authority to bind the Corporation. Dated at Thorold,this .day of ,2013. NIAGARA Name:Debbie Elliott Title:Commissioner of Corporate Services I have authority to bind the Corporation. Page 78 of 192 F-2019-30 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Finance SUBJECT: F-2019-30 Municipal Accounts RECOMMENDATION That Council approve the municipal accounts totaling $16,863,038.46 for the period May 16, 2019 to June 28, 2019. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The accounts have been reviewed by the Director of Finance and the by-law authorizing payment is listed on tonight’s Council agenda. Recommended by: Tiffany Clark, Director of Finance Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer Page 79 of 192 Page 1 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount 1057636 ONTARIO LTD 428179 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 4,309.67 1057642 ONTARIO LTD 427490 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 1185844 ONTARIO INC. O/A RAINBOW PURE WATER 427275 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 480.25 1185844 ONTARIO INC. O/A RAINBOW PURE WATER 427697 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 508.50 1185844 ONTARIO INC. O/A RAINBOW PURE WATER 428180 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 508.50 1186566 ONTARIO INC. o/a TIM HORTONS #1351 427491 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 243.42 1198983 ONTARIO LIMITED 428181 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,854.64 1274505 ONTARIO LTD 428182 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 604.62 1340258 ONTARIO INC 427947 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 929,471.83 1340258 ONTARIO INC 427698 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 10,000.00 1346704 ONTARIO INC 427492 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 300.00 1372744 ONTARIO LIMITED 428183 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 915.33 1448116 ONTARIO LIMITED 428184 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,295.92 1492357 ONTARIO LIMITED 428185 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 9,533.93 1578917 ONTARIO LIMITED O/A WILLIAMS PLUMBING AND HEATING 427276 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 152.55 1578917 ONTARIO LIMITED O/A WILLIAMS PLUMBING AND HEATING 427493 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 115.26 1578917 ONTARIO LIMITED O/A WILLIAMS PLUMBING AND HEATING 428186 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,692.62 1671312 ONTARIO LIMITED 428188 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,983.00 1671318 ONTARIO LTD 428187 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 985.07 1686541 ONTARIO INC 428189 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 587.67 1736104 ONTARIO INC 428190 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 185.03 1776415 ONTARIO LTD O/A PURE WATER NIAGARA 427029 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 550.00 1776415 ONTARIO LTD O/A PURE WATER NIAGARA 427277 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 37.50 1776415 ONTARIO LTD O/A PURE WATER NIAGARA 427494 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 25.00 1776415 ONTARIO LTD O/A PURE WATER NIAGARA 427699 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 18.75 1776415 ONTARIO LTD O/A PURE WATER NIAGARA 427948 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 25.00 1776415 ONTARIO LTD O/A PURE WATER NIAGARA 428191 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 37.50 1809624 ONTARIO INC.427949 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 862.13 1809624 ONTARIO INC.428192 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,456.45 1985416 ONTARIO INC.427030 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 2030688 ONTARIO LTD.427700 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 63.54 2063779 ONTARIO INC 427495 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 2075790 ONTARIO INC 428193 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,575.98 2081655 ONTARIO LTD o/a DYNACLEAN 427950 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,878.11 2088937 ONTARIO INC 428194 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 472.67 2111443 ONTARIO LTD 428195 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 792.94 2156914 ONTARIO INC O/A IDEAL PLUMBING & HEATING 427701 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,900.00 2207848 ONTARIO INC 428196 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 525.65 2249419 ONTARIO INC 427278 29-May-2019 REFUND 60,000.00 2284114 ONTARIO INC 428197 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 690.56 2348441 ONTARIO INC O/A MR QUICK CAR WASH 427031 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 553.70 2348441 ONTARIO INC O/A MR QUICK CAR WASH 428198 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 134.47 2405800 ONTARIO LIMITED 427032 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 2442923 ONTARIO INC 427702 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 269.32 2551285 ONTARIO INC.427951 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 234.67 2578139 ONTARIO INC O/A HALCO PORTABLES 427279 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 621.50 2578139 ONTARIO INC O/A HALCO PORTABLES 427952 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 367.25 2578139 ONTARIO INC O/A HALCO PORTABLES 428199 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 621.50 2615840 ONTARIO INC 428200 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 3,007.07 407 ETR EXPRESS TOLL ROUTE 427280 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 283.32 488745 ONTARIO LIMITED 428201 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,980.34 550857 ONTARIO LTD 428202 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 213.27 7132221 CANADA INC. C/O HAWKTREE SOLUTIONS 427953 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 719.46 A&A EXHAUST SYSTEMS 427281 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 657.69 AAA BIGGAR'S LOCKSMITH & SECURITY 427033 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 131.25 AAA BIGGAR'S LOCKSMITH & SECURITY 427496 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 23.00 AAA BIGGAR'S LOCKSMITH & SECURITY 427954 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,516.61 AAA BIGGAR'S LOCKSMITH & SECURITY 428203 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 208.49 ABCEDE,FELIX 427497 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 ACCEO SOLUTIONS INC.427703 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,859.00 ACCU LOCK AND SECURITY 427704 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 516.98 ACCU LOCK AND SECURITY 427955 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 254.25 ACCU LOCK AND SECURITY 428204 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 327.70 ACCU LOCK AND SECURITY 427282 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 124.30 ACK ARCHITECTS INC 427034 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 ADMOR INDUSTRIAL DOCK & DOOR SYSTEMS INC.427498 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,122.59 ADVANCE TOWING & RECOVERY 427035 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 480.25 ADVANCE TOWING & RECOVERY 427283 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,717.60 ADVANCE TOWING & RECOVERY 427499 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 977.45 ADVANCE TOWING & RECOVERY 427705 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 446.35 ADVANCE TOWING & RECOVERY 427956 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,366.80 ADVANCE TOWING & RECOVERY 428205 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 875.75 AECOM CANADA LTD 427706 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,991.68 AFTERMARKET PARTS COMPANY LLC 427036 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,357.13 AFTERMARKET PARTS COMPANY LLC 427284 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 824.37 AFTERMARKET PARTS COMPANY LLC 427500 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,461.25 AFTERMARKET PARTS COMPANY LLC 427707 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,148.05 AFTERMARKET PARTS COMPANY LLC 427957 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,167.92 AFTERMARKET PARTS COMPANY LLC 428206 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 787.33 AIR CARE SERVICES 427501 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,507.21 AIR CARE SERVICES 427958 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 9,076.46 AIRD & BERLIS LLP 427285 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 100,845.49 AIRD & BERLIS LLP 428207 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 100,818.34 AJ STONE COMPANY LTD 427037 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 822.27 Page 80 of 192 Page 2 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount AJ STONE COMPANY LTD 427286 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 734.50 AJ STONE COMPANY LTD 427502 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,207.97 AJ STONE COMPANY LTD 427959 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 586.05 AJ STONE COMPANY LTD 428208 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,495.84 ALBANESE,LORI 427287 29-May-2019 REFUND 112.98 ALBANESE,LORI 427708 12-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 117.72 ALFIDOME CONSTRUCTION 427288 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 177,736.68 ALFIDOME CONSTRUCTION 427709 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,169.65 ALFIDOME CONSTRUCTION 427038 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 ALISON'S SPORTS AWARDS & PROMOTIONS 427503 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 19.21 ALISON'S SPORTS AWARDS & PROMOTIONS 427710 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 12.37 ALL GREEN IRRIGATION 427711 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 473.81 ALL STAR MECHANICAL 427505 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,256.76 ALLEN'S LANDSCAPE SUPPLY DEPOT INC 427039 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,228.03 ALLEN'S LANDSCAPE SUPPLY DEPOT INC 427289 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 444.42 ALLEN'S LANDSCAPE SUPPLY DEPOT INC 427504 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 162.72 ALLEN'S LANDSCAPE SUPPLY DEPOT INC 428209 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 665.63 ALLIED MEDICAL INSTRUMENTS INC 427040 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 122.51 ALSOP,TINA 427712 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 300.00 ALTIERI BUILDING SUPPLIES LTD 427290 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 151.11 ALTIERI BUILDING SUPPLIES LTD 427506 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 354.31 ALTIERI BUILDING SUPPLIES LTD 428210 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 586.98 AMALGAMATED TRANSIT UNION #1582 00221-0001 21-May-2019 REMITTANCE 4,168.91 AMALGAMATED TRANSIT UNION #1582 00225-0001 17-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 4,358.40 AMCTO 427960 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 587.60 AMG ENVIRONMENTAL INC 427507 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,203.50 AMG ENVIRONMENTAL INC 428211 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,203.50 ANDELIC,ZELJKO 428212 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 197.18 ANDREW THOMPSON & ASSOCIATES LTD.427508 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 6,638.75 ANGERVIL,RENSON& MARCELLE PHILIPPE, ROSE 427041 23-May-2019 REFUND 301.15 ANGLE,BETH 427961 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 163.61 ANNABLE,CAROLYN JOAN 427042 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 ANTHONY'S EXCAVATING CENTRAL INC 428213 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 27,179.33 APPLIED GEOLOGICS INC 428214 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,896.70 AQUASIRENE INC,427713 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 647.50 ARCHER TRUCK SERVICES LTD 427291 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,039.16 ARCHER TRUCK SERVICES LTD 427509 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,302.57 ARCHER TRUCK SERVICES LTD 427714 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 846.32 ARCHER TRUCK SERVICES LTD 427962 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 619.25 ARDEL INVESTMENTS LTD.427510 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 4,426.23 ARIVA 427511 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 97.86 ARTISTA DESIGN & PRINT INC 427043 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,402.33 ARTISTA DESIGN & PRINT INC 427512 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 62.15 ARTISTA DESIGN & PRINT INC 427715 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 33.90 ARTISTA DESIGN & PRINT INC 427963 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 164.98 ARTISTA DESIGN & PRINT INC 428215 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 197.75 ASSOCIATION OF MUNICIPALITIES OF ONTARIO 427292 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 909.65 ATCHISON-PREET,GLORIA 427964 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 ATKINSON,RICK 427716 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 20.00 AUBIN,DANIEL 427293 29-May-2019 REFUND 49.70 AUBIN,DANIEL 427717 12-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 30.24 AUTOTRIM & SIGNS OF NIAGARA 427294 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 165.60 AUTOTRIM & SIGNS OF NIAGARA 427718 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 68.93 AWL GENERAL CONTRACTING 427965 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 BAGLIERI,CAREY 427719 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 357.32 BAIN PRINTING LIMITED 427295 29-May-2019 ADVERTISING 1,898.40 BAIN PRINTING LIMITED 427513 05-Jun-2019 ADVERTISING 1,084.80 BAIN PRINTING LIMITED 428216 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 489.29 BAKER 427296 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 653.06 BAKER 427514 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,819.18 BAKER 427720 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 622.40 BAKER 427967 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,165.56 BAKER 428217 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,195.73 BANDHU LAKHANI CAPEA LLP 428218 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,068.00 BATTLEFIELD EQUIPMENT RENTALS 428219 26-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 7,881.59 BATTLEFIELD EQUIPMENT RENTALS 427044 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,228.03 BATTLEFIELD EQUIPMENT RENTALS 427968 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,330.78 BATTLEFIELD PRESS 427721 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,553.80 BEBE STATION 427723 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 850.00 BELANGER,TANYA 428221 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 150.00 BELL CANADA - PUBLIC ACCESS 427046 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 113.00 BELL CANADA - PUBLIC ACCESS 427970 19-Jun-2019 SERVICES 226.00 BELL MOBILITY INC.427515 05-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 1,412.50 BELL MOBILITY INC.427047 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,412.50 BEN BERG FARM & INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT LTD 427048 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 266.04 BEN BERG FARM & INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT LTD 427297 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 342.64 BEN BERG FARM & INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT LTD 427516 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 682.41 BEN BERG FARM & INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT LTD 427724 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 217.80 BEN BERG FARM & INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT LTD 428222 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 69,996.91 BENNETT,TIMOTHY 427725 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 490.07 BENSON,MARY 427298 29-May-2019 REFUND 466.20 BERARDI,FRANCESCA 427517 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 42.30 BERGER,AARON 427299 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 210.00 BEST CONSULTANTS MARTIN GERSKUP ARCHITECT INC.427726 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 937.90 Page 81 of 192 Page 3 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount BEST CONSULTANTS MARTIN GERSKUP ARCHITECT INC.427971 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 34,993.29 BICKLE MAIN INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY INC 427300 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 257.41 BICKLE MAIN INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY INC 427727 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 153.38 BICKLE MAIN INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY INC 428224 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 75.80 BIRD'S MOVING & STORAGE 427301 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,544.71 BLANCHFIELD,ELIZABETH PEARL 427302 29-May-2019 REFUND 169.50 BLASINSKI,CHRIS 427728 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 115.09 BLENDTEK FINE INGREDIENTS 427049 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,423.85 BLUE HILL 428225 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 700.00 BOB ROBINSON & SON CONSTRUCTION 427051 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,292.54 BOB ROBINSON & SON CONSTRUCTION 427518 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 10,652.40 BOB ROBINSON & SON CONSTRUCTION 428226 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,570.80 BOB ROBINSON & SON CONSTRUCTION 427729 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 16,475.40 BOBCAT OF HAMILTON LTD 427050 23-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 4,294.00 BOLAND,BRAD 427519 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 300.00 BOOT SHOP 427052 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,983.15 BOOT SHOP 427972 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 666.70 BOSSEY,JOHN FREDERICK 427053 23-May-2019 REFUND 113.00 BOUCHER,KATHERINE 427303 29-May-2019 REFUND 27.81 BOUDREAU,ALAIN 427054 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 BOUTILIER,JIM 427520 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 451.99 BOYS & GIRLS CLUB OF NIAGARA 427055 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 16,912.50 BOYS & GIRLS CLUB OF NIAGARA 428227 26-Jun-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 18,562.50 BRAIN TRUST 427056 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 678.00 BRAIN TRUST 427973 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 593.25 BRAMIC CREATIVE BUSINESS PRODUCTS LTD 428228 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,816.06 BRAND BLVD INC 427057 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,281.26 BREAK-A-WAY CONCESSIONS 427974 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 147.81 BRENNAN PAVING LTD.427730 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 91,260.27 BRETTYOUNG 427304 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,564.49 BRETTYOUNG 427975 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 87.01 BRINKS CANADA LTD 427058 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,757.53 BRINKS CANADA LTD 428229 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,774.44 BRINKS CANADA LTD 427521 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 51.66 BROCK FORD 427059 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 457.56 BROCK FORD 427305 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 680.09 BROCK FORD 427522 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 606.81 BROCK FORD 427731 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 599.50 BRODERICK,JOE 427976 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 74.56 BUCKNER'S SOURCE FOR SPORTS 428230 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 113.00 BUILDING INNOVATION 427060 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,559.50 BUILDING INNOVATION 428231 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 9,350.75 BUNZ,DANIEL 427523 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 175.00 BURGESS,DAVE 427306 29-May-2019 REFUND 175.00 BURLEY,RON 427977 19-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 233.18 BUSCH,DAVID 427978 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 BUTLER,ANGUS 427062 23-May-2019 REFUND 175.00 BUTYNIEC,DAVE 427525 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 76.14 BUTYNIEC,STEPHEN 427307 29-May-2019 TRAINING 288.15 BYERS,SARA 427979 19-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 59.40 CABANAW,NORMA 427063 23-May-2019 REFUND 885.43 CALE CANADA 427732 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,782.53 CAMPBELL MONUMENT CO LTD 427526 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 15,481.00 CAMPBELL,WAYNE 427270 27-May-2019 MATERIALS 340.00 CAMPBELL,WAYNE 427733 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 417.87 CAN AM INSTRUMENTS LTD 427735 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,088.64 CANADA MUNICIPAL JOBS INC 427734 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 163.85 CANADA MUNICIPAL JOBS INC 428233 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 163.85 CANADA POST CORPORATION 428240 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 909.65 CANADA POST CORPORATION 00221-0002 21-May-2019 MATERIALS 616.40 CANADA POST CORPORATION 00223-0001 03-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,161.30 CANADA POST CORPORATION 00224-0001 10-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,198.48 CANADA POST CORPORATION 00226-0001 24-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 31,668.62 CANADIAN BEARINGS LTD 427527 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 278.14 CANADIAN DOOR DOCTOR 427066 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 248.60 CANADIAN DOOR DOCTOR 427308 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 782.53 CANADIAN DOOR DOCTOR 427981 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,202.32 CANADIAN HOME INSPECTIONS SERVICES INC.428236 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 39,550.00 CANADIAN LINEN & UNIFORM 427067 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 511.07 CANADIAN LINEN & UNIFORM 427309 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 742.09 CANADIAN LINEN & UNIFORM 427528 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 511.07 CANADIAN LINEN & UNIFORM 427738 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 517.84 CANADIAN LINEN & UNIFORM 427982 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 105.10 CANADIAN LINEN & UNIFORM 428237 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 923.81 CANADIAN LOCATORS INC.427064 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 60,696.36 CANADIAN LOCATORS INC.428234 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 53,965.41 CANADIAN NATIONAL 427068 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,255.00 CANADIAN NATIONAL 428238 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,255.00 CANADIAN NIAGARA HOTELS INC 427529 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY CO 427983 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,023.00 CANADIAN PORTABLE SERVICES 428239 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,671.62 CANADIAN RED CROSS 428241 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 CANADIAN SAFETY EQUIPMENT INC 427310 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 309.90 CANADIAN SAFETY EQUIPMENT INC 427984 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 166.22 Page 82 of 192 Page 4 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount CANADIAN TIRE PROPERTIES INC.427065 23-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 3,209.62 CANADIAN TIRE PROPERTIES INC.427980 19-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 3,209.62 CANAKIS,BIANCA 427736 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 100.00 CANCINO,IRENE& CANCINO, MARY ANN 427737 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 24.58 CANCORE INDUSTRIES INC O/A HAMILTON RADIATOR SERVICE 428235 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,278.89 CANON CANADA INC 427530 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 757.83 CANON CANADA INC 427739 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 217.01 CANTEC SECURITY SERVICES INC 428242 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 389.51 CARDAMONE,ANTHONY 427531 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 CARLETON UNIFORMS INC 427070 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 237.30 CARLETON UNIFORMS INC 427532 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 169.33 CARNEVALE,BROOKE 427069 23-May-2019 TRAINING 216.60 CAROLINE'S CARICATURES 427985 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 300.00 CARSON,DAN 427740 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 CARTER,KATHY 428244 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 300.00 CASTELLAN,DAVID MARIO 427071 23-May-2019 REFUND 500.00 CASTLE MECHANICAL 427072 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 11,912.46 CASTLE MECHANICAL 427311 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 351.53 CASTLE MECHANICAL 427741 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 138.43 CASTLE MECHANICAL 427986 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 663.63 CASTLE MECHANICAL 428245 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 660.39 CASTONGUAY,MARCEL 427999 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 CATALINA EXCAVATING INC 427073 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 198,153.00 CATALINA EXCAVATING INC 427987 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 125,864.13 CATARACT COLLISION CENTRE 427074 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,158.25 CBM N.A. INC 427312 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 817.62 CBM N.A. INC 427988 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,301.01 CBM N.A. INC 428246 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 151.65 CENTENNIAL INFRASTRUCTURE (NIAGARA) INC 427989 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 155,820.24 CENTRAL COMMUNICATIONS 427534 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 745.80 CERVUS EQUIPMENT 427743 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 273.75 CHALMERS,PATRICK 427313 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 210.00 CHAMBERS,TERRY 427537 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 56.49 CHARLES JONES INDUSTRIAL LTD 427075 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,390.30 CHARLES JONES INDUSTRIAL LTD 427314 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,934.33 CHARLES JONES INDUSTRIAL LTD 427538 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,278.84 CHARLES JONES INDUSTRIAL LTD 427744 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 60.57 CHARLES JONES INDUSTRIAL LTD 427993 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,061.98 CHARLES JONES INDUSTRIAL LTD 428247 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,146.14 CHARLES,JASON CURTIS 427990 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 162.99 CHAUSSE,JUSTIN JAMES 427991 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 126.43 CHIPPAWA LIONS PARK 427315 29-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 35,000.00 CHOI,ALLAN 428248 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 75.00 CHURCHHILL NATURAL MEATS 427316 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 100.00 CIARLO,ROBERT 427076 23-May-2019 REFUND 200.00 CIBC ELECTRONIC BANKING OPERATIONS 428249 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 59.06 CIMA CANADA INC 427317 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 46,612.96 CIMA CANADA INC 427745 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,303.09 CIMCO REFRIGERATION 427539 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,338.65 CIRCLE P. PAVING INC.427540 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 86,570.58 CIRCLE P. PAVING INC.428250 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 12,311.36 CITY ELECTRIC SUPPLY 427318 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 625.44 CITY ELECTRIC SUPPLY 427995 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 374.24 CITY OF THOROLD PIPE BAND 427994 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 750.00 CITY VIEW BUS SALES & SERVICE LTD.427541 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 245.64 CLASSIC 59 INVESTMENTS INC 428251 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,007.30 CLEVER DEVICES ULC 427319 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 84,202.27 CLIFTON HILL BIA 428252 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 20,000.00 CLOCKWORK SYSTEMS INC 427542 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 92.66 CLOCKWORK SYSTEMS INC 427746 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 972.93 CLOCKWORK SYSTEMS INC 427996 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 20,738.55 CM LIGHTING MAINTENANCE 428253 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,129.99 C-MAX FIRE SOLUTIONS 427077 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 282.50 C-MAX FIRE SOLUTIONS 427543 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,377.17 C-MAX FIRE SOLUTIONS 427997 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 188.57 CNM INC 428254 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 13,123.13 COGECO CONNEXION INC 427545 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 36.10 COGECO CONNEXION INC.427544 05-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 847.50 COLLIERS NIAGARA MANAGEMENT LTD.428309 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,914.18 COMMERCIAL DIGITAL PRINT INC 427747 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 183.25 COMMISSIONAIRES 427320 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 16,618.11 COMMISSIONAIRES 427547 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 12,599.93 COMMISSIONAIRES 427998 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,564.02 COMMISSIONAIRES 428255 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 14,485.75 COMPLETE PLUMBING 427078 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 17,063.00 COMPLETE PLUMBING 428256 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 9,605.00 COMTECH ENERGY 427321 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,209.04 CONIDI,SARAH 428257 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 249.04 COONEY,CAROL 428258 26-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 487.18 CORTESE,FRANCES 427548 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,600.00 CORTESE,FRANCES 427080 23-May-2019 TRAINING 5,625.00 COTTON INC 427322 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 48,926.19 CRAWFORD & COMPANY (CANADA) INC 427082 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,553.00 CRAWFORD & COMPANY (CANADA) INC 427748 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 4,335.50 Page 83 of 192 Page 5 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount CRAWFORD & COMPANY (CANADA) INC 428001 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 701.50 CRL CAMPBELL CONSTRUCTION & DRAINAGE LTD 427324 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 7,477.63 CRUICKSHANK,CASSANDRA 427749 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 CUMMINS CANADA ULC 427325 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,005.42 CUPE LOCAL 133 00221-0004 21-May-2019 REMITTANCE 9,766.42 CUPE LOCAL 133 00223-0002 03-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 10,182.81 CUPE LOCAL 133 00225-0002 17-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 10,233.42 CUPIRAGGI,ERNIE 428260 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 75.00 CUSTOM IMAGE SALES 427549 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 762.75 CUSTOM LOT CLEARING INC.428002 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 14,238.00 CUSTOM LOT CLEARNING 427326 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 75,936.00 D K TECHNICAL SERVICES INC 427089 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 871.17 D K TECHNICAL SERVICES INC 427338 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,314.27 D'AGOSTINO,JOE 427750 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 150.00 DA-LEE PAVEMENT PRODUCTS LP 428262 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 6,952.33 DALTON,VALERIE 427551 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 DANYAAL ENTERPRISES LTD 428263 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,284.87 DARCH FIRE 427329 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 4,544.41 DARE,TANYA 427330 29-May-2019 REFUND 59.83 DAVIDSON ENVIRONMENTAL 427331 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 155.94 DAVIDSON ENVIRONMENTAL 428264 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 42.04 DAVIDSON ENVIRONMENTAL 427085 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 147.13 DAVIDSON,ANGELA 427332 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 631.80 DE LIMA,STEVEN MARK& NERO, KRISTINA ROSALYN 428006 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 81.36 DEARMAN,MASON 427751 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 100.00 DECAST 428265 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 4,657.18 DEKKEMA,KENNETH& DEKKEMA, LARRY 428004 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 82.14 DELDUCA,GERARDINA 428266 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 200.00 DELL CANADA INC 427333 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 14,712.32 DELL,KELLY 428005 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 293.80 DELL,KELLY 427753 12-Jun-2019 TRAINING 281.37 DELUCA,DINO 427752 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 210.15 DEMAR CONSTRUCTION 427334 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 143,483.77 DEMAR CONSTRUCTION 428267 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 7,502.35 DEMAR CONSTRUCTION 428268 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 80,986.88 DEMOL'S TIRE SALES & SERVICE 428007 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,256.84 DEPENDABLE EMERGENCY VEHICLES 428269 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 271.63 DESIGN ELECTRONICS 427754 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,396.85 DESIGN ELECTRONICS 428008 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 6,283.19 DESIGN ELECTRONICS 428270 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 59,863.46 DHULS'S DESIGN 428009 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 DIAZ,LENA 428271 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 141.25 DICIENZO,DYLAN 428272 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 120.00 DIGITAL POSTAGE ON CALL 428273 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 19,210.00 DILIBERO,VINCENT 427552 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 DILIGENT CANADA 427755 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 29,702.74 DILOLLO,MICHEAL 427336 29-May-2019 REFUND 67.21 DILOLLO,MICHEAL 427756 12-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 42.12 DILONARDO,MARCELLA 428010 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 250.00 DILTS,KEVIN& AUSTIN-DILTS, SARAH ELIZABETH 427087 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 DILTS,KEVIN& AUSTIN-DILTS, SARAH ELIZABETH 427335 29-May-2019 REFUND 263.34 DILWARIA,ANAMIKA 428011 19-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 198.72 DIODATI,JIM 427271 27-May-2019 MATERIALS 340.00 DIODATI,JIM 427088 23-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 1,155.00 DIODATI,JIM 428012 19-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 1,325.00 DIPIETRO,SALVATORE& DIPIETRO, MARY 428274 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 231.13 DISPATCH TALENT INCORPORATED 427757 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,582.00 DONOFRIO,MIKE 428275 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 76.84 DOSS HOMES CONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT CORP.428276 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 3,721.79 DOW,LINDA 427339 29-May-2019 REFUND 137.50 DOWNBEAT PERCUSSION US DRAFT 13-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,300.00 DOWNTOWN BOARD OF MANAGEMENT 428277 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 52,550.00 DREN,KARL 427758 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 406.50 DRFPOA 427553 05-Jun-2019 TRAINING 475.00 DROLLIS SAFETY SUPPLY CO LTD 427091 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 242.84 DROST,GARY 427554 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 129.94 DROST,KEVIN 427090 23-May-2019 REFUND 100.00 DTAH ARCHITECTS LTD.427092 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 8,843.66 DUFF,YVETTE 427760 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 DUFFERIN CONCRETE 427093 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,319.89 DUFFERIN CONCRETE 427759 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 966.15 DUFFERIN CONCRETE 428014 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,437.76 DUFFERIN CONCRETE 428278 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,644.78 DUFFERIN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY 427555 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 190,830.50 DUMONT SECURITY 427556 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,156.75 DUMONT SECURITY 428015 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 141.25 DUNCOMBE,JOSHUA 427761 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 DUNNETT,RODNEY 427340 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 135.00 DYNAMIC DISPLAYS LTD 427341 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,689.50 DYNAMIC DISPLAYS LTD 427762 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,118.75 E S FOX ENTERPRISES INC 428284 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,792.94 E S HUBBELL HIGHWAY AND DRAINANGE PRODUCTS 427097 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 6,492.03 E S HUBBELL HIGHWAY AND DRAINANGE PRODUCTS 427559 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 7,558.62 E3 LABORATORIES 428279 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,441.88 Page 84 of 192 Page 6 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount EASY FINANCIAL 427342 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 63.36 EASY FINANCIAL 427763 12-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 63.36 EASY FINANCIAL 428280 26-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 63.36 EDUCATION FOUNDATION OF NIAGARA 427343 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 250.00 EGERTER,CAROL 427344 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 116.64 ELLIS ENGINEERING INC.427764 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 24,466.26 ELLIS,JULIE 428017 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 215.28 ELREG DISTRIBUTORS LTD 428281 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,384.35 EMBASSY SUITES 427345 29-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 1,423.80 EMCO CORPORATION 428282 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 327.14 EMERALD 427765 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,900.00 EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT & TRAINING INC.427346 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,880.54 ENBRIDGE GAS INC. O/A ENBRIDGE GAS DISTRIBUTION 00221-0005 21-May-2019 UTILITIES 1,895.38 ENBRIDGE GAS INC. O/A ENBRIDGE GAS DISTRIBUTION 00222-0002 27-May-2019 UTILITIES 4,234.17 ENBRIDGE GAS INC. O/A ENBRIDGE GAS DISTRIBUTION 00223-0003 03-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 22,344.90 ENBRIDGE GAS INC. O/A ENBRIDGE GAS DISTRIBUTION 00224-0002 10-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 7,406.18 ENBRIDGE GAS INC. O/A ENBRIDGE GAS DISTRIBUTION 00225-0003 17-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 1,080.71 ENBRIDGE GAS INC. O/A ENBRIDGE GAS DISTRIBUTION 00226-0002 24-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 723.46 ENGHOUSE TRANSPORTATION LIMITED 428018 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 7,500.94 ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR CANADA COMPANY 427094 23-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 6,986.24 ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR CANADA COMPANY 427347 29-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 2,702.88 ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR CANADA COMPANY 427557 05-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 7,739.33 ENTRO COMMUNICATIONS INC 427095 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 7,355.52 E-QUIP RENTALS & REPAIRS INC 428283 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 275.66 E-QUIP RENTALS & REPAIRS INC 427096 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,303.78 E-QUIP RENTALS & REPAIRS INC 427348 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,482.36 E-QUIP RENTALS & REPAIRS INC 427558 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,016.59 E-QUIP RENTALS & REPAIRS INC 427766 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 191.36 E-QUIP RENTALS & REPAIRS INC 428020 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 7,479.34 EQUIPMENT SPECIALIST INC 428019 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,846.41 ESTROPIGAN,GLORIA 427349 29-May-2019 REFUND 2,374.46 EVANS UTILITY & MUNICIPAL PRODUCTS SUPPLY LTD 428021 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 616.36 EVANS UTILITY & MUNICIPAL PRODUCTS SUPPLY LTD 427350 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 44,222.10 EVANS UTILITY & MUNICIPAL PRODUCTS SUPPLY LTD 427767 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 279.52 EVANS UTILITY & MUNICIPAL PRODUCTS SUPPLY LTD 428285 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 33,621.41 EXP SERVICES INC 427098 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 14,257.21 EXP SERVICES INC 427560 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,045.40 EXP SERVICES INC 428022 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 14,322.75 FABBRO,TERESA 427351 29-May-2019 REFUND 3,565.15 FALLS CHEVROLET CADILLAC 428023 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 223.76 FALLS CHEVROLET CADILLAC 427352 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 570.54 FALLS CHEVROLET CADILLAC 427561 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 398.55 FALLS CHEVROLET CADILLAC 427768 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 58.50 FALLS CHEVROLET CADILLAC 428286 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,607.79 FALLS ELECTRIC INC 427353 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 330.53 FALLS ELECTRIC INC 427562 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 129.95 FALLS ELECTRIC INC 428287 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,486.36 FALLSVIEW BIA 428288 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 750,000.00 FALLSWAY SUPPLY 427099 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,470.69 FALLSWAY SUPPLY 427354 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 289.69 FALLSWAY SUPPLY 427563 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,115.74 FALLSWAY SUPPLY 427769 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 644.68 FALLSWAY SUPPLY 428024 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,247.00 FAST,DAVID JOHN 428289 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,089.52 FASTENAL CANADA LTD 427100 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,043.69 FASTENAL CANADA LTD 427355 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,194.67 FASTENAL CANADA LTD 427770 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 98.56 FASTENAL CANADA LTD 428025 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 953.06 FASTENAL CANADA LTD 428290 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 183.47 FCT INSURANCE COMPANY 427356 29-May-2019 REFUND 4,190.31 FENCAST INDUSTRIES LTD 428291 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 324.79 FERGUS,HELEN 427101 23-May-2019 REFUND 257.86 FILION WAKELY THORUP ANGELETTI LLP 428026 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 141.25 FIRE MARSHAL'S PUBLIC FIRE SAFETY COUNCIL 427103 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 691.56 FIRE MONITORING OF CANADA INC 427564 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,936.91 FIRE MONITORING OF CANADA INC 427771 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 599.00 FIREHALL BOOKSTORE 427102 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,381.33 FISH,KATHLEEN 427565 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 FITZPATRICK,BETH 427104 23-May-2019 REFUND 35.00 FIVE STAR ALLIANCE PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LTD 428292 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,216.86 FLAGG,ISAAC 428027 19-Jun-2019 GRANT 2,500.00 FLEXO PRODUCTS LTD 427105 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,370.21 FLEXO PRODUCTS LTD 427357 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 254.07 FLEXO PRODUCTS LTD 427566 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 488.13 FLEXO PRODUCTS LTD 428028 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 270.02 FLEXO PRODUCTS LTD 428293 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,752.26 FOAMCORE MOULDINGS INC.428029 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 102.54 FORCE SECURITY INC.427772 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 485.45 FORCE SECURITY INC.428294 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 265.44 FORD,NANCY ELLEN 427567 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 62.64 FORMICA,MIKE 427773 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 678.00 FORMISANO,ADRIANO 428295 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,387.62 FOSTER,STEVEN 428030 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 FRANCIS,MICHAEL 427774 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 500.00 Page 85 of 192 Page 7 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount FRANK COWAN COMPANY LIMITED 427360 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 720.20 FRANK COWAN COMPANY LIMITED 428296 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 145,831.44 FRANKEN,MARCUS 427359 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 654.27 FRANZE,FRANK 427358 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 49.68 FREROTTE,STEWART 427775 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 300.00 FRETZ,IDA 427568 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 FREW ENERGY LIMITED 427361 29-May-2019 FUEL 28,469.54 FREW ENERGY LIMITED 427569 05-Jun-2019 FUEL 30,913.18 FREW ENERGY LIMITED 427776 12-Jun-2019 FUEL 1,513.13 FREW ENERGY LIMITED 428031 19-Jun-2019 FUEL 33,893.31 FREW ENERGY LIMITED 428297 26-Jun-2019 FUEL 29,886.13 FROGGY'S AUTO GLASS LTD 427106 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 480.25 FROGGY'S AUTO GLASS LTD 428298 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 480.25 FRY,JORDAN 427362 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,875.00 FULHAM,FERNAND 427570 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 FUTUREGENIC INC.428032 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 G. O'CONNOR CONSULTANTS INC 427111 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,390.00 G. O'CONNOR CONSULTANTS INC 427783 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,864.55 G. O'CONNOR CONSULTANTS INC 428302 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 6,780.00 GAHIR,HARINDER 428042 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 GALES GAS BARS LIMITED 427107 23-May-2019 FUEL 62.26 GALES GAS BARS LIMITED 428033 19-Jun-2019 FUEL 106.26 GALLERY WORKS NIAGARA INC 427777 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 271.20 GALLERY WORKS NIAGARA INC 428299 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 508.50 GAO,PENG 427571 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 GAROFALO SEWER CLEANING 428034 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 107.35 GAUBOC CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 427363 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 53,074.69 GAUBOC CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 427108 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,825.00 GAULD NURSERIES LTD 427109 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 6,068.10 GEORGE HOLDINGS INC.428300 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 282.78 GERRIE ELECTRIC WHOLESALE LTD 427364 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 182.25 GERRIE ELECTRIC WHOLESALE LTD 427779 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 662.36 GERRIE ELECTRIC WHOLESALE LTD 428035 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 353.01 GERRIOR,ANDREW 427778 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 120.00 GHD LIMITED 427572 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 6,244.38 GILBERT,MARGARET 427780 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 100.00 GLABB,HEATHER 427573 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 210.00 GLOBAL INDUSTRIAL CANADA 427574 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 827.09 GLOBAL RENTAL CANADA ULC 427575 05-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 5,045.45 GLOBAL RENTAL CANADA ULC 428301 26-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 5,045.45 GLOBALSTAR CANADA 427781 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 180.78 GLORY GLOBAL SOLUTIONS CANADA INC 427365 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 474.60 GM BLUEPLAN ENGINEERING LIMITED 427576 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 15,057.03 GM BLUEPLAN ENGINEERING LIMITED 427782 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 12,836.55 GOODWILL INDUSTRIES OF NIAGARA 427577 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 20,940.44 GORDON JR,WILLIE THOMAS 428304 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 98.87 GORDON,HARVEY 427366 29-May-2019 REFUND 100.00 GORGE HOLDINGS INC 427578 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,006.90 GORRIE,KELLY 428303 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 93.31 GOWLING WLG (CANADA) LLP 427784 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 14,569.09 GRAYBAR CANADA 427367 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,008.52 GRAYBAR CANADA 428036 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,857.45 GRAYBAR CANADA 428305 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 960.69 GREAT LAKES FIRE SERVICES 428037 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,308.00 GREEN KEEP 427579 05-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 751.45 GREEN LION GROUP CORP 427112 23-May-2019 REFUND 500.00 GREEN,JOSHUA 427785 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 GRIFFIN LANDSCAPE 428306 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 11,017.50 GRIMSBY PIPE BAND 428038 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 850.00 GROOVE IDENTIFICATION SOLUTIONS INC 427114 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 128.76 GT FRENCH 427115 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 201.94 GT FRENCH 427368 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 52.22 GT FRENCH 427786 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 590.39 GT FRENCH 428039 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 58.48 GT FRENCH 428307 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 652.80 GUARASCI,JEFF 427581 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 361.26 GUILD ELECTRIC LIMITED 427369 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 35,811.05 GUILD ELECTRIC LIMITED 428040 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 52,645.47 HAHN,AARON 427582 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 HAI NA,CHEN 427787 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 187.37 HALLEX ENGINEERING LTD 427788 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 435.05 HALLEX ENGINEERING LTD 427116 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 HAMILTON FIRE CONTROL CO A DIVISION OF 376534 ONTARIO LTD.428041 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 HAPPY FEET DANCE 427789 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 HARI,DWAYNE 427583 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 HARIS,SAMI-U-RAHMAN 427118 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 HARMAN,SCOTT 427370 29-May-2019 REFUND 150.00 HARPER,RYAN TODD 427117 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 HATCH CORPORATION 427119 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 440.70 HECTRONIC MOBILE SMART CITY US DRAFT 13-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,493.75 HEMSON CONSULTING LTD 427120 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,723.81 HENDERSON,JASON 427790 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,412.50 HERLOVITCH,ALEX 427584 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 70.20 HEWITT,DEBORAH MARIE 427585 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 Page 86 of 192 Page 8 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount HICKS MORLEY HAMILTON STEWART STORIE LLP 427121 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 113.00 HICKS MORLEY HAMILTON STEWART STORIE LLP 428043 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,497.25 HICKS,SKYE 427586 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 100.00 HILARIO PORTO GONCALVES 427791 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,203.50 HILLSIDE HOLDINGS INC 428308 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 861.66 HIT MEN BRASS BAND US DRAFT 13-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 HOOP YOU 427792 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 678.00 HORBAN,TED 428310 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,493.93 HORROCKS,RYLAND 428044 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 HRDOWNLOADS INC 427371 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 11,572.65 HUMMEL PROPERTIES INC 428311 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,474.88 HUNGARIAN CULTURAL CENTRE 427122 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 6,095.22 HYDE,CASEY 427793 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 IANNAZZO,PETER 427372 29-May-2019 REFUND 75.00 IBBA,LISA DIANE 427123 23-May-2019 REFUND 141.25 IBI GROUP PROFESSSIONAL SERVICES (CANADA) INC 427124 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 13,800.86 IBI GROUP PROFESSSIONAL SERVICES (CANADA) INC 427794 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 9,868.26 IBI GROUP PROFESSSIONAL SERVICES (CANADA) INC 428045 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 19,304.87 ICLS INC.428046 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 424.88 IMRAN,SIDRA 427795 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 INDACO MANUFACTURING LIMITED 427125 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 243.02 INFRASTRUCTURE HEALTH AND SAFETY ASSOCIATION 427587 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 683.65 INLAND LIFERAFTS & MARINE LTD 427373 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,934.14 INLAND LIFERAFTS & MARINE LTD 428048 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 54,936.46 INNOTEX INC.427588 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 9,402.78 INNOVATIVE GATE SYSTEMS INC 427589 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 497.20 INNOVATIVE SURFACE SOLUTIONS CANADA 427126 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 5,622.80 INSPIRED MEDIA INC 427127 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 259.90 INTERSTEAM TECHNOLOGIES 427128 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 5,987.87 IOANNONI,CARMINE 427129 23-May-2019 REFUND 65.65 IOANNONI,CAROLYNN 427272 27-May-2019 MATERIALS 340.00 IOANNONI,CAROLYNN 427796 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 749.16 IRWIN,NICK 427797 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 150.00 ISABELLA HOOPS ENTERTAINMENT 427798 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,107.50 J J MACKAY CANADA LTD 427132 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 18.08 J J MACKAY CANADA LTD 428316 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 18.08 J K JOUPPIEN HERITAGE RESOURCE CONSULTANT 427801 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,851.16 J.D. BARNES LIMITED 427591 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,064.77 J.D. BARNES LIMITED 428315 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 4,527.00 JACK DOW AUTO SUPPLIES LIMITED 427130 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 166.32 JACK DOW AUTO SUPPLIES LIMITED 427374 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 539.14 JACK DOW AUTO SUPPLIES LIMITED 427590 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,112.58 JACK DOW AUTO SUPPLIES LIMITED 427799 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 482.83 JACK DOW AUTO SUPPLIES LIMITED 428050 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 255.47 JACK DOW AUTO SUPPLIES LIMITED 428313 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 989.39 JACKET CELLAR 428314 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 791.00 JACKSON,NATHANE 428051 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 20.97 JAGGER SPORTS CO 427800 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,984.28 JAMES,DWAYNE 428052 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 708.00 JAQUES,DONNA 428312 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 3,409.94 JEWISH NIAGARA 427131 23-May-2019 REMITTANCE 6,301.01 JMX 427133 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 JOCELYN ROOF CONSULTANTS 428053 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 9,040.00 JOE JOHNSON EQUIPMENT 427375 29-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 12,712.50 JOE JOHNSON EQUIPMENT 428317 26-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 12,712.50 JOE'S TRANSMISSION SERVICE 427802 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 462.15 JOJACKS CONCRETE RAISING (NIAGARA)427803 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 734.50 JOJACKS CONCRETE RAISING (NIAGARA)427592 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 282.50 JOSE,SARA 427377 29-May-2019 REFUND 50.74 JOSEPH T K ENGINEERING 427593 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 JTS REPAIR LTD.428318 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 556.89 KACZYNSKI,RAY 428054 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 28.25 KAGAN SHASTRI LLP 427594 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,469.00 KAKEKALANICKS INDIGENOUS CONSULTING COMPANY 427134 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 800.00 KAKEKALANICKS INDIGENOUS CONSULTING COMPANY 428055 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 850.00 KAPITANCHUK,JEFFREY ROBERT 428056 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 KAUPP ELECTRIC LTD 427135 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 375.16 KECZAN,MOLLY 427804 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,599.00 KEEFER MANAGEMENT INC 427136 23-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 5,134.65 KEEFER MANAGEMENT INC 428319 26-Jun-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 5,134.65 KEIGHAN,ALLYSON DEBRA 427805 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 433.20 KELLY DIGS LANDSCAPING 427806 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 14,017.52 KELLY DIGS LANDSCAPING 428057 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 21,819.53 KELLY DIGS LANDSCAPING 428320 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 6,331.77 KELLY SERVICES (CANADA) LTD.427595 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 945.05 KELLY SERVICES (CANADA) LTD.427807 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 630.03 KENT,LUANA ADELE& KENT, GORDON KITCHENER 427808 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 19.01 KENWORTH TRUCK CENTRES 427597 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 206.98 KENWORTH TRUCK CENTRES 427809 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 952.34 KENWORTH TRUCK CENTRES 428058 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 29.02 KENWORTH TRUCK CENTRES 428321 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 245.10 KENWORTH TRUCK CENTRES 427137 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,440.25 KERR,ELIZABETH 427138 23-May-2019 REFUND 2,493.05 KERRY T HOWE ENGINEERING LTD 427810 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,202.10 Page 87 of 192 Page 9 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount KERRY T HOWE ENGINEERING LTD 427379 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 5,067.52 KERRY T HOWE ENGINEERING LTD 428322 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,809.14 KLENZOID CANADA INC.428059 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,839.31 KOLDENHOF,TANYA 427811 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 50.00 KONCZ,KAROLY 427812 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 11.58 KOSZTYO,JOHN GEORGE 427139 23-May-2019 REFUND 149.73 KOWALCZYK,EDWARD MICHAEL 428060 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 KRAWCZYK CONSTRUCTION MAINTENANCE INC 428323 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,444.14 KRAWCZYK CONSTRUCTION MAINTENANCE INC 427380 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,457.70 KRAWCZYK CONSTRUCTION MAINTENANCE INC 428061 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,915.35 KROWN 427140 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 723.14 KROWN 427381 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 852.97 KROWN 427598 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 932.25 KROWN 428324 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,720.98 KROWN 428062 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 226.00 KRUPA,JORDAN EDWARD& CHINDEMI, CAMILLA MARIE 428063 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 251.93 KYLE SIPKENS 427906 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 650.00 LA,HY-THANH 427813 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 21.37 LAKESIDE LANDSCAPE INC.427141 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,425.92 LAKESIDE LANDSCAPE INC.428325 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,248.06 LAMB,CHRIS 427142 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 LANE,JAMES 427382 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 211.18 LANGLEY,MICHAEL& STEEVES, KATRINA 428064 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 369.98 LAPP CYCLE MOWER & MARINE 427143 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 25.98 LAW CRUSHED STONE 427814 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,563.42 LAWSON PRODUCTS INC 427144 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,674.77 LAWSON PRODUCTS INC 427383 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,426.16 LAWSON PRODUCTS INC 427599 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,291.41 LAWSON PRODUCTS INC 427815 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,734.97 LAWSON PRODUCTS INC 428065 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,641.65 LAWSON PRODUCTS INC 428326 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 939.54 LAZIC,RADOMIR& LAZIC, EVICA 427816 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 296.39 LEA,MELISSA 427600 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 129.60 LEGACY PARTNERS EXECUTIVE SEARCH 427818 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 8,098.32 LEGACY PARTNERS EXECUTIVE SEARCH 428066 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 6,215.00 LEGROS,ANDREW 427817 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 LEMIEUX,TEENA 427819 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,185.00 LEMON,BLAIR 427145 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 56.50 LENSON,LAURA 427820 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 840.00 LIAO,JEMMA 427821 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 467.12 LICHACH,GARY 427822 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,085.00 LIFESAVING RESOURCES US DRAFT 13-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,390.00 LINCOLN & WELLAND REGIMENTAl ASSOCIATION BAND 428068 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 850.00 LINCOLN APPLIANCE SERVICE CENTRE INC 427823 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 106.22 LINCOLN VALLEY AUTOMOTIVE LTD 427824 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 971.80 LINUS HAND PRODUCTIONS 427825 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 300.00 LIZZOTTI,BRUNO 427385 29-May-2019 GRANT 75.00 LJ BARTON MECHANICAL INC 427602 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 83,323.04 LMS3 DEVELOPMENT INC 428328 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 4,645.46 LOCOCO,LORI 427273 27-May-2019 MATERIALS 340.00 LOCOCO,LORI 427826 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,323.02 LOHO VETZ INC 428069 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 78.78 LOHO VETZ INC 428329 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 5,002.78 LONDON REPTILES 427827 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 734.50 LUBY,LINDSEY 428330 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 41.00 LUNDY'S LANE BIA 428331 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 128,306.50 LUONG,THI HONG TRAM 428070 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 78.31 LUSKA,MICHAEL 427603 05-Jun-2019 GRANT 75.00 M&L SUPPLY FIRE AND SAFETY 428085 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 414.73 M&L SUPPLY FIRE AND SAFETY 428348 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 455.14 MACCARONE,BENJAMIN 427828 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 MACNAUGHTON HERMSEN BRITTON CLARKSON PLANNING LIMITED427604 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,755.07 MAD SCIENCE OF NIAGARA 427829 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 649.75 MALE,ROY 427147 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,334.53 MALIK,NAVEED 427386 29-May-2019 REFUND 200.00 MALIK,RASHID 428332 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 5,000.00 MANCHESTER BY VICTORIAVILLE 428333 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,148.38 MANCUSO CHEMICALS LIMITED 427148 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,267.77 MANCUSO CHEMICALS LIMITED 427387 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 541.71 MANCUSO CHEMICALS LIMITED 427605 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,182.01 MANCUSO CHEMICALS LIMITED 427830 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 618.36 MANCUSO CHEMICALS LIMITED 428071 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 445.41 MANCUSO CHEMICALS LIMITED 428334 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 616.55 MANITOULIN TRANSPORT INC 427831 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 513.92 MANNINGHAM,DEANNA DARLENE 427606 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 MANOLESCU,THEODOR 428335 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 175.00 MANOR CLEANERS 427149 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 301.33 MANOR CLEANERS 428072 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 41.14 MANPOWER 428336 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,179.36 MANSION,NICK 427388 29-May-2019 GRANT 75.00 MAPLE LEAF COLLISION CENTRE 428073 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 101.70 MARALDO,FRANK ANTHONY VINCENT 428074 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 52.00 MARCHIO,NICK 427391 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 67.98 MARK'S COMMERCIAL 427150 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,626.97 Page 88 of 192 Page 10 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount MARK'S COMMERCIAL 427389 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 18,434.75 MARK'S COMMERCIAL 427607 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,149.48 MARK'S COMMERCIAL 428075 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,295.89 MARK'S COMMERCIAL 428337 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,717.18 MARKS SUPPLY INC 427151 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,159.60 MARKS SUPPLY INC 427390 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,851.91 MARKS SUPPLY INC 427608 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 764.29 MARKS SUPPLY INC 427832 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,246.36 MARKS SUPPLY INC 428076 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,580.81 MARKS SUPPLY INC 428338 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,952.67 MARRIOTT,RITA 428077 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 44.79 MARTIN SHEPPARD FRASER LLP 427392 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,998.31 MARTINEZ,RODOLFO 428078 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 MATSON,BILL 427393 29-May-2019 SERVICES 1,124.04 MATSON,BILL 428339 26-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 456.30 MAURICE,STEVE 427609 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 122.58 MAXIMA HOLDINGS CORP.428079 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 MCCAULEY,DON 427833 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 196.56 MCD MECHANICAL 427834 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 10,400.00 MCINTOSH TRADING 428080 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 384.18 MCLELLAN,IRENE LILLIAN 427394 29-May-2019 REFUND 101.70 MCLEOD & SAVOIE AUTO AND TRUCK SERVICE LTD 427152 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 40.68 MCLEOD SQUARE INC.428340 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,379.24 MCQUAY,JANET 428341 26-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 162.00 MERIDIAN CREDIT UNION 427610 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 MESSINA,FRANK 427835 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 190.69 METAL SUPERMARKETS 427153 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 344.56 METRO COLLISION SERVICES INC 427612 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 638.45 METRO FREIGHTLINER HAMILTON 427611 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,082.58 METRO PLUMBING & HEATING 427837 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 33,777.90 METRO PLUMBING & HEATING 428342 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 29,338.72 METROLAND MEDIA GROUP 427154 23-May-2019 ADVERTISING 5,591.89 METROLAND MEDIA GROUP 427836 12-Jun-2019 ADVERTISING 3,608.76 MICHAEL'S CARPET AND FLOORING (NIAGARA) LTD 428081 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,897.49 MIDGLEY,CHARLENE 428082 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 MIELE,PETER& MIELE, FRANK 428343 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,530.36 MIHAYCHUK,BILL 427395 29-May-2019 REFUND 169.50 MILES,ROBIN 427613 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 MILLER RESTORATION 427838 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 565.00 MILLS,JANA 427396 29-May-2019 TRAINING 322.00 MILORD ENTERTAINMENT 428344 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 7,473.36 MINISTER OF FINANCE 427614 05-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 115,806.60 MINISTER OF FINANCE 427615 05-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 6,412.58 MINISTER OF FINANCE 428345 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 382.31 MINISTRY OF ATTORNEY GENERAL 00221-0006 21-May-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 4,433.06 MINISTRY OF ATTORNEY GENERAL 00223-0004 03-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 3,755.98 MINISTRY OF ATTORNEY GENERAL 00225-0004 17-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 3,393.20 MISIK,CHRIS 428346 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 25.00 MISSISSAUGA BUS COACH & TRUCK REPAIRS INC 428083 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 34,320.22 MISSISSAUGA BUS COACH & TRUCK REPAIRS INC 427397 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 523.46 MISSISSAUGA BUS COACH & TRUCK REPAIRS INC 427616 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 5,228.24 MISTER TRANSMISSION 428084 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,476.11 MLDAO 428347 26-Jun-2019 MEMBERSHIP 100.00 MODERN LANDFILL INC 427155 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 609.24 MODERN LANDFILL INC 427398 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 678.00 MODERN LANDFILL INC 427839 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 7,366.52 MODERN LANDFILL INC 428086 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 197.39 MODERN LANDFILL INC 428349 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,362.10 MOHAWK MFG & SUPPLY CO 427156 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 186.64 MOHAWK MFG & SUPPLY CO 427399 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,502.13 MOHAWK MFG & SUPPLY CO 427617 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 333.26 MOHAWK MFG & SUPPLY CO 427840 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 5,596.46 MOHAWK MFG & SUPPLY CO 428087 19-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 4,875.69 MOHAWK MFG & SUPPLY CO 428350 26-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,479.08 MOLDENHAUER,KATHY 427618 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 162.54 MONTGOMERY,KENNETH 427619 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 MORGAN,KYLE 427841 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 MORNEAU SHEPELL LTD 428352 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,452.92 MORSE & SON LIMITED 428351 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,447.55 MORTON,DALE 427400 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 46.44 MORTON,DALE 427620 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 260.28 MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS CANADA INC.427621 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 740.15 MOYA,MAURICIO 427842 12-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 64.26 MSDSONLINE DBA VELOCITYEHS US DRAFT 13-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,099.00 MTE PARALEGAL PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 428353 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 98.17 MTE PARALEGAL PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 427157 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 320.78 MUELLI,STEPHEN PAUL 427622 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 MULLER'S WORKWEAR 427623 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 117.76 MULLER'S WORKWEAR 427843 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 283.47 MULLER'S WORKWEAR 428088 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,620.56 MUNICIPAL WORLD INC 428354 26-Jun-2019 ADVERTISING 484.77 NAGY,HANYA 427158 23-May-2019 PETTY CASH 741.50 NAGY,HANYA 427401 29-May-2019 PETTY CASH 252.20 NAGY,HANYA 427624 05-Jun-2019 PETTY CASH 431.25 Page 89 of 192 Page 11 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount NAGY,HANYA 428089 19-Jun-2019 PETTY CASH 247.10 NAGY,HANYA 428355 26-Jun-2019 PETTY CASH 244.75 NATURE'S EXPRESSION 427844 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 240.67 NEAL,MITCHELL 427402 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 456.20 NELLA CUTLERY (HAMILTON) INC.427159 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 384.20 NELLA CUTLERY (HAMILTON) INC.427403 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 90.40 NELLA CUTLERY (HAMILTON) INC.427625 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 90.40 NELLA CUTLERY (HAMILTON) INC.427845 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 101.70 NEXTERRA SUBSTRUCTURES INC 428357 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 4,023.38 NFMHA ANGE GIAJNORIO TOURNAMENT 427404 29-May-2019 GRANT 1,500.00 NIAGARA 21 ST GROUP INC 428358 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 643.05 NIAGARA ADULT CATARACT HOCKEY TOURNAMENT 427410 29-May-2019 GRANT 2,500.00 NIAGARA BATTERY & TIRE 427160 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,625.96 NIAGARA BATTERY & TIRE 427405 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,235.65 NIAGARA BATTERY & TIRE 428090 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,231.97 NIAGARA BATTERY & TIRE 428359 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,474.84 NIAGARA BLOCK INCORPORATED 427406 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,906.35 NIAGARA BLOCK INCORPORATED 428091 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 828.81 NIAGARA BLOCK INCORPORATED 428360 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 23.39 NIAGARA CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP 427161 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 112.43 NIAGARA CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP 428092 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 541.77 NIAGARA CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP 428361 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 74.58 NIAGARA FALLS ART GALLERY 427162 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 2,334.34 NIAGARA FALLS ART GALLERY 428093 19-Jun-2019 GRANT 2,334.34 NIAGARA FALLS CONCERT BAND 427163 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 3,600.00 NIAGARA FALLS HUMANE SOCIETY 427164 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 43,916.67 NIAGARA FALLS HUMANE SOCIETY 428362 26-Jun-2019 GRANT 43,916.67 NIAGARA FALLS HUMANE SOCIETY 427846 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 340.00 NIAGARA FALLS ILLUMINATION BOARD 427847 12-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 42,985.00 NIAGARA FALLS MINOR HOCKEY ASSOCIATION 428363 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 500.00 NIAGARA FALLS PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOC 00221-0007 21-May-2019 REMITTANCE 16,776.05 NIAGARA FALLS PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOC 00223-0005 03-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 8,686.61 NIAGARA FALLS PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOC 00225-0005 17-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 8,620.30 NIAGARA FALLS SOCCER CLUB INC 427407 29-May-2019 GRANT 125.00 NIAGARA FALLS TOURISM ASSOCIATION 427486 31-May-2019 REMITTANCE 360,000.00 NIAGARA FITNESS SOLUTIONS 427408 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,622.93 NIAGARA FOLK ARTS 428364 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 472.50 NIAGARA FOUNDATION FOR CATHOLIC EDUCATION 427409 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 250.00 NIAGARA HISTORICAL SOCIETY & MUSEUM 428365 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 59.70 NIAGARA MEMORIAL MILITAIRES ALUMNI DRUM CORPS 427848 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,000.00 NIAGARA METER SERVICES INC.427165 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 4,330.50 NIAGARA METER SERVICES INC.427626 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,942.39 NIAGARA METER SERVICES INC.428094 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,129.97 NIAGARA ON THE LAKE HYDRO INC 427166 23-May-2019 UTILITIES 144.77 NIAGARA ON THE LAKE HYDRO INC 427627 05-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 144.77 NIAGARA PARKS COMMISSION 427628 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 21,729.77 NIAGARA PARKS COMMISSION 428095 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 97,150.42 NIAGARA PENINSULA AMATEUR RADIO CLUB 427850 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 NIAGARA PENINSULA ENERGY INC 427167 23-May-2019 UTILITIES 19,884.16 NIAGARA PENINSULA ENERGY INC 427411 29-May-2019 UTILITIES 200,512.28 NIAGARA PENINSULA ENERGY INC 427629 05-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 3,534.60 NIAGARA PENINSULA ENERGY INC 427849 12-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 5,716.77 NIAGARA PENINSULA ENERGY INC 428096 19-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 3,418.68 NIAGARA PENINSULA ENERGY INC 428366 26-Jun-2019 UTILITIES 203,768.89 NIAGARA PINES DEVELOPMENTS LTD 427168 23-May-2019 REFUND 2,500.00 NIAGARA PINES DEVELOPMENTS LTD 428097 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 3,500.00 NIAGARA REGIONAL BROADBAND NETWORK 427169 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 21,163.46 NIAGARA REGIONAL BROADBAND NETWORK 428367 26-Jun-2019 SERVICES 20,955.47 NIAGARA REGIONAL HOUSING 427173 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 NIAGARA REGIONAL POLICE PIPES & DRUMS 428098 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 800.00 NIAGARA RESEARCH AND PLANNING COUNCIL 427851 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 125.00 NIAGARA ROADS SUPERVISORS ASSOCIATION 427852 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 120.00 NIAGARA RUBBER SUPPLY INC 428368 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 339.73 NIAGARA SPRING SERVICE LTD 427412 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,012.50 NIAGARA THIS WEEK 427413 29-May-2019 ADVERTISING 331.09 NIAGARA TINTING 427853 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 79.10 NIAGARA TRAILERS LTD.428099 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 44.09 NICKEL,RICHARD 427170 23-May-2019 REFUND 500.00 NICKEL,RICHARD 427631 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 NICOL,DAVID 428100 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 NIOMA 428101 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 NORJOHN CONTRACTING & PAVING LTD 427854 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 191,432.86 NORJOHN CONTRACTING & PAVING LTD 428369 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 55,851.09 NORRIS,STEVE 428370 26-Jun-2019 SERVICES 766.79 NORTH AMERICAN TRANSIT SUPPLY CORPORATION 427171 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,101.68 NORTH AMERICAN TRANSIT SUPPLY CORPORATION 428102 19-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 78.92 NORTH AMERICAN TRANSIT SUPPLY CORPORATION 428371 26-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 336.58 NORTRAX CANADA INC.427172 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 6,556.78 NRFCA 427632 05-Jun-2019 MEMBERSHIP 400.00 NUTRITE 427174 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 6,900.80 OACFP 427414 29-May-2019 MEMBERSHIP 56.50 O'CONNOR,PAT 427175 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 175.00 OIL FILTRATION SPECIALISTS INC 428103 19-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,545.84 OMERS 00222-0003 27-May-2019 REMITTANCE 713,015.66 Page 90 of 192 Page 12 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount OMERS 00222-0004 27-May-2019 REMITTANCE 39,391.60 ON POINT LANDSCAPING INC 428104 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 69,798.63 ON POINT LANDSCAPING INC 428372 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 18,732.80 ONTARIO ASSOCIATION OF FIRE CHIEFS 427415 29-May-2019 TRAINING 1,615.90 ONTARIO BUILDING OFFICIALS ASSOCIATION 427177 23-May-2019 ADVERTISING 325.26 ONTARIO BUILDING OFFICIALS ASSOCIATION 428105 19-Jun-2019 ADVERTISING 325.26 ONTARIO ONE CALL 427176 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,109.95 ONTARIO ONE CALL 428373 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,109.95 ORKIN CANADA CORPORATION 427179 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 168.37 ORKIN CANADA CORPORATION 428106 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 168.37 OSLER HOSKIN & HARCOURT LLP 428107 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 621.50 OVERLAND CUSTOM COACH (2007) INC.427633 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 123.62 OZA INSPECTIONS LTD 427180 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,056.60 P R W EXCAVATING CONTRACTORS LTD 427199 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,768.50 PANCZUK,JAROSLAW VICTOR 427634 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 101.70 PARADISAEA AERIAL DANCE 427856 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 PARADISE POOLS 427181 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 207.74 PARADISE POOLS 427635 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 142.17 PARADISE POOLS 427855 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 368.10 PARADISE POOLS 428108 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 527.88 PARADISE POOLS 428374 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,625.30 PARKWAY TOWING INC 427182 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 847.50 PARKWAY TOWING INC 427416 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 678.00 PARKWAY TOWING INC 427857 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 678.00 PARTY CONNECTION 427417 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 463.30 PATEL,KALPESHKUMAR 428375 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 113.00 PATEL,RIYA 427858 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,500.00 PATERSON,ANDREW 428109 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 175.00 PC AUTO ELECTRIC 427183 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 370.87 PC AUTO ELECTRIC 427636 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 332.47 PC AUTO ELECTRIC 428110 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 314.82 PC AUTO ELECTRIC 428376 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 257.98 PEC ROOF MAINTENANCE 428377 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 878.13 PEMBERTON,HOLLY 428378 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 363.65 PENGUIN RANDOM HOUSE OF CANADA LTD.428381 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 148.97 PENINSULA CONSTRUCTION INC.427185 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,203.50 PENINSULA HOSE & HYDRAULICS LTD.427184 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,288.33 PENINSULA HOSE & HYDRAULICS LTD.427637 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 601.75 PENINSULA HOSE & HYDRAULICS LTD.427859 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 214.53 PENINSULA HOSE & HYDRAULICS LTD.428379 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 167.62 PENINSULA PEST CONTROL LTD 427638 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,090.45 PENNER BUILDING CENTRE 427186 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 764.81 PENNER BUILDING CENTRE 428111 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,199.44 PENNER BUILDING CENTRE 428380 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 288.56 PERFORMANCE CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM FIAT 427860 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 949.75 PETERS EXCAVATING INC 427861 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 7,566.48 PETERS EXCAVATING INC 428382 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 12,176.88 PETERS EXCAVATING INC 427187 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 9,112.32 PETROVA,RADOSLAV& PETROVA, SVETLANA 428383 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 5,490.71 PIAZZA,JOSEPHINE 427188 23-May-2019 REFUND 124.30 PIC'S MOTOR CLINIC 427862 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,090.50 PIC'S MOTOR CLINIC 428112 19-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 3,717.70 PIETRANGELO,JONATHAN 427418 29-May-2019 TRAINING 429.04 PINDERS SECURITY PRODUCTS 427189 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,358.74 PINERIDGE TREE SERVICE LTD 427190 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 976.32 PINERIDGE TREE SERVICE LTD 427639 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,857.92 PINERIDGE TREE SERVICE LTD 427863 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 3,905.28 PINERIDGE TREE SERVICE LTD 428384 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,713.28 PINERIDGE TREE SERVICE LTD 428113 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 7,665.92 PIPETEK INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES INC 427864 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 140,337.55 PIPETEK INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES INC 428114 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 23,491.88 PIPETEK INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES INC 428385 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 48,347.62 PIROSKO,JASON 427865 12-Jun-2019 TRAINING 353.40 PK HUMMINGBIRD STEEL BAND 428115 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 600.00 PLANT'S CHOICE 428386 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 661.05 PLATO,ALLISON 427866 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 150.00 PLAYSCAPE INSPECTION & CONSULTING SERVICE INC 427191 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 339.00 POLLARD,JOSHUA 427867 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 PORTAGE BAKERY INC.427419 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 164.00 PRAXAIR 427192 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 360.06 PRAXAIR 427868 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 309.13 PRAXAIR 428387 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 74.66 PRECISION CURB CUTTING LTD 427869 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 821.60 PRECISION CURB CUTTING LTD 427193 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,019.17 PREMIER EQUIPMENT LTD 427194 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,411.70 PREMIER EQUIPMENT LTD 427640 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,487.36 PREMIER EQUIPMENT LTD 428116 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 155.10 PREMIER TRUCK GROUP 427195 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 141.44 PREMIER TRUCK GROUP 427420 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 406.55 PREMIER TRUCK GROUP 427870 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 336.24 PREMIER TRUCK GROUP 428117 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 422.43 PREMIER TRUCK GROUP 428388 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 848.54 PREMIER TRUCK GROUP 427641 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 7,850.92 PREVOST 427196 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,698.26 Page 91 of 192 Page 13 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount PREVOST 427421 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,537.65 PREVOST 427642 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 3,229.26 PREVOST 427871 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 5,440.47 PREVOST 428118 19-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 4,143.37 PREVOST 428389 26-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,417.67 PRIMERANO,SAMUAL 427643 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 PRIMO PLUMBING & HEATING 427873 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 900.00 PRINTING HOUSE LTD 427197 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 132.99 PRINTING HOUSE LTD 427872 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 861.07 PRINTING HOUSE LTD 428390 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,105.36 PRO BATTERY SHOPS 427644 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,347.58 PRO BATTERY SHOPS 428119 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 17.23 PRO BATTERY SHOPS 428391 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 124.24 PROJECT SHARE 427198 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 24,866.67 PROJECT SHARE 428392 26-Jun-2019 GRANT 24,866.67 PUCKETT,SAM 427874 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 PUROLATOR INC 427422 29-May-2019 COURIER 54.32 PUROLATOR INC 427645 05-Jun-2019 COURIER 48.63 PUROLATOR INC 427875 12-Jun-2019 COURIER 115.80 PVS CONTRACTORS 428393 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 141.25 PYRAMID TRAFFIC INC 427646 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,689.55 PYRAMID TRAFFIC INC 428394 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 15,656.15 QAYUM,AMAL 427423 29-May-2019 GRANT 1,000.00 QRX TECHNOLOGY GROUP/KERR NORTON 427647 05-Jun-2019 SERVICES 690.09 QRX TECHNOLOGY GROUP/KERR NORTON 427876 12-Jun-2019 SERVICES 776.78 R J BURNSIDE & ASSOCIATES LIMITED 428123 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 220.35 R J SMITH EQUIPMENT INC 427209 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 5,661.30 R J SMITH EQUIPMENT INC 427431 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 949.20 R J SMITH EQUIPMENT INC 427885 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,028.30 R J SMITH EQUIPMENT INC 428124 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,084.90 R J SMITH EQUIPMENT INC 428405 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,167.22 R V ANDERSON ASSOCIATES LIMITED 428127 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 16,003.63 R W HAMILTON LTD.427887 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 334.37 RACINE,LORRAINE 427200 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 40.00 RACO AUTO SUPPLY LTD 427201 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,326.80 RACO AUTO SUPPLY LTD 427424 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 886.24 RACO AUTO SUPPLY LTD 427648 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 171.73 RACO AUTO SUPPLY LTD 427877 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 151.89 RACO AUTO SUPPLY LTD 428395 26-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 853.65 RAIMONDO & ASSOCIATES ARCHITECTS INC 428396 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 67,824.59 RANKIN CONSTRUCTION INC 428120 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 66,925.57 RANKIN CONSTRUCTION INC 428397 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 6,733.94 RAPID RESPONSE EMS 427878 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 308.49 RAPP,DAVID 427425 29-May-2019 GRANT 75.00 RBC 427880 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 981.27 RBC LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY 427879 12-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 2,005.66 REALTAX INC 427202 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,463.40 RECEIVER GENERAL 427426 29-May-2019 REMITTANCE 644,788.46 RECEIVER GENERAL 427881 12-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 736,309.79 RECEIVER GENERAL 428398 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 659,535.99 RECEIVER GENERAL FOR CANADA 427427 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 287.00 RED TRAC INTERNATIONAL A DIVISION OF D&W GROUP INC.427203 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 290.87 RED TRAC INTERNATIONAL A DIVISION OF D&W GROUP INC.428121 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,072.40 RED TRAC INTERNATIONAL A DIVISION OF D&W GROUP INC.428399 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 200.13 REFRIGERATION ENERGY SOLUTIONS LTD 427204 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,182.32 REFRIGERATION ENERGY SOLUTIONS LTD 427883 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,618.33 REFRIGERATION ENERGY SOLUTIONS LTD 428400 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,865.99 REGIONAL FIRE SERVICES INC.427884 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 508.50 REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA 00222-0005 27-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,172,700.49 REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA 00224-0003 10-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 16,136.63 REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA 00221-0008 21-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,758.97 REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA 00223-0006 03-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,051.25 REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA 00225-0006 17-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 5,393.28 REGIONAL MUNICIPALITY OF NIAGARA 00226-0003 24-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,003.75 REGIONAL NIAGARA OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH CLINIC 427205 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 508.50 REGIONAL NIAGARA OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH CLINIC 427649 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 141.25 REGIONAL NIAGARA OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH CLINIC 428401 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 169.50 REID,KEVIN 427428 29-May-2019 GRANT 75.00 RICOH CANADA INC 427206 23-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 7,418.18 RICOH CANADA INC 427650 05-Jun-2019 SERVICES 316.40 RICOH CANADA INC 428122 19-Jun-2019 SERVICES 225.94 RICOH CANADA INC 428402 26-Jun-2019 SERVICES 8,029.51 RIGHT TO KNOW INC 427207 23-May-2019 REFUND 82.00 RIOCAN HOLDINGS INC 427430 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,046.31 RIOCAN HOLDINGS INC 428403 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 100,503.73 RIVER REALTY DEVELOPMENT (1976) INC 427208 23-May-2019 REFUND 2,500.00 RIVER REALTY DEVELOPMENT (1976) INC 427651 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 RIVER REALTY DEVELOPMENT (1976) INC 428404 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,576.78 ROBERTO,PHIL 427432 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 452.33 ROBIDOUX,MACKENZIE 428125 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 ROCHESTER MIDLAND CANADA CORPORATION 427433 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 919.02 ROCHESTER MIDLAND CANADA CORPORATION 428406 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 363.99 ROGERS WIRELESS 427210 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 434.65 ROGERS WIRELESS 428408 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 869.30 Page 92 of 192 Page 14 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount ROGERS WIRELESS INC 427434 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 846.76 ROGERS WIRELESS INC 427886 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,463.26 ROGERS WIRELESS INC 428407 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,659.24 ROMEO,ANTONIO& LEAL, JENNIFER 428409 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 626.36 ROMULUS HOLDINGS INC,427211 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 ROYLANCE,RICK 428126 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,444.00 ROZON,MATTHEW 427652 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 175.00 RUKMANI,FERNANDO 427487 03-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,008.00 RYALL,GEOFF 427435 29-May-2019 GRANT 75.00 S.B. SIMPSON GROUP INC.427654 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 163.85 SACCO CONSTRUCTION LTD 427212 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 114,057.45 SACCO CONSTRUCTION LTD 427653 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 209,198.83 SACCO CONSTRUCTION LTD 428410 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 212,806.10 SACCO,DOLORES 428411 26-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 160.92 SAFE STOR RECORDS MANAGEMENT 427214 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 262.16 SAFE STOR RECORDS MANAGEMENT 428413 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 262.16 SAFETY-KLEEN CANADA INC 427213 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 491.10 SAFETY-KLEEN CANADA INC 427436 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 922.92 SAFETY-KLEEN CANADA INC 428412 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 113.00 SAIDER,NADER 427437 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 100.00 SAINT-GOBAIN CANADA INC 428414 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 2,997.96 SANI GEAR 428415 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,383.17 SANTESSO,LILLIAN 427215 23-May-2019 REFUND 2,656.29 SAPEZINSKAS,CHRIS 427888 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 500.00 SASSAFRAS FARMS 427216 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,105.24 SAUDER,ERIN 427889 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 312.50 SAVOIE,JULIA 427438 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 124.81 SCATTOLON,GIORGIO 427890 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 119.77 SCHMALZ,MONICA 427891 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 250.00 SCORDINO,TERRI LYNN 428129 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 152.52 SCOTIABANK BILL PAYMENT SERVICES 427892 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 114.51 SCOTT BEST SEWER SERVICES 427439 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,954.95 SCOTT BEST SEWER SERVICES 427655 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,870.20 SCOTT BEST SEWER SERVICES 428416 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,166.78 SCOTT CONSTRUCTION NIAGARA INC 428130 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 384.20 SCOZZAFAVA,JOSHUA 428128 19-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 68.58 SEALER WORKS INC.428132 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 9,166.80 SEALER WORKS INC.428417 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 641.84 SEALER WORKS INC.427894 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 7,542.75 SEARCH AND RESCUE NIAGARA 427895 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 SEAWAY FLUID POWER GROUP 427893 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,909.25 SEAWAY FLUID POWER GROUP 428131 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 33.99 SEAWAY FLUID POWER GROUP 427440 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 88.02 SEAWAY FLUID POWER GROUP 427656 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 562.54 SEHDEV,JYOTI SETHI 427896 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 300.00 SEIBEL,EMILY 427897 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 SEIBEL,KEN 427898 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 SEIKA GROVES 427217 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 SEIKA GROVES 427441 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 SENIORS REVIEW 427899 12-Jun-2019 ADVERTISING 452.00 SENKERIK FIRE PROTECTION 427218 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,013.77 SERVICEMASTER CLEAN OF NIAGARA 427219 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 12,642.44 SERVICEMASTER CLEAN OF NIAGARA 427900 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,209.10 SERVICEMASTER CLEAN OF NIAGARA 428418 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 26,011.36 SETACCI,JORDAN 427901 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 452.00 SEWELL'S AUTOMOTIVE SUPPLY 427902 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 79.54 SHEEHAN ARBITRATION MEDIATION SERVICES 427904 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,736.52 SID GRABELL CONTRACTING LTD 428133 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 754.84 SIDOFF,MARUSCIA 428419 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 505.38 SIGNATURE SIGN & IMAGE 427220 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,867.38 SIGNATURE SIGN & IMAGE 428420 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 373.79 SILLS IAN,CHRISTOPHER 428134 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 SIMPLISTIC LINES INC 427221 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 8,442.88 SIMPLISTIC LINES INC 427905 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,221.21 SIMPLISTIC LINES INC 428135 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 590.29 SIMPLISTIC LINES INC 428421 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,562.91 SMITH,CHARLIE 427442 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 271.16 SMITH,RICHARD NELSON 428136 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 SNAP ON TOOLS OF CANADA LTD 427657 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 63.35 SOMERVILLE,MICHAEL 427222 23-May-2019 REFUND 500.00 SPARK INNOVATION EDUCATIONAL CENTER INC 428422 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,500.00 SPARKLE SOLUTIONS 427223 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 542.40 SPARKLE SOLUTIONS 427908 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 441.71 SPEARE SEEDS 427224 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 5,740.40 SPENCER,GERALD 427909 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 150.00 SPIRONELLO,DEAN 427443 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 272.70 ST CATHARINES TRANSIT COMMISSION 427228 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 500.00 ST GEORGE SERBIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH 427229 23-May-2019 REFUND 35,000.00 ST JOHN AMBULANCE 427230 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 49,965.50 ST JOHN AMBULANCE 427231 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 2,741.67 ST JOHN AMBULANCE 428138 19-Jun-2019 GRANT 2,741.67 ST JOHN AMBULANCE 428425 26-Jun-2019 GRANT 49,965.50 ST JOHN AMBULANCE 427447 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 250.00 ST JOHN AMBULANCE 427912 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 Page 93 of 192 Page 15 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount ST. ONGE,EUGENE& ST. ONGE, RHONDA 427661 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 777.86 STAHLE CONSTRUCTION 427658 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 STAMFORD CENTRE VOLUNTEER FIREMEN'S ASSOCIATION 427226 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 20,000.00 STAMFORD HOME HARDWARE 427225 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 23.72 STAMFORD HOME HARDWARE 427910 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.01 STANCO SIGNS INC.427444 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 830.55 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE 427227 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 150.36 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE 427445 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,492.95 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE 427659 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,420.35 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE 427911 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,213.15 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE 428137 19-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 722.68 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE 428423 26-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,474.58 STEPHENSON'S RENTAL SERVICES 427660 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 657.95 STICCA,JAMES 427446 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 174.16 STOKES INTERNATIONAL 427914 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 982.36 STONES,HEATHER 428139 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 637.14 STONIER,DEREK 427913 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 500.00 STORAGE NIAGARA 427662 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 278.07 STORAGE NIAGARA 428140 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 644.10 STORAGE NIAGARA 428426 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 751.45 STRANGE,MIKE 427274 27-May-2019 MATERIALS 340.00 STRANGE,MIKE 427915 12-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 1,006.56 STRANGES,LOU 427663 05-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 94.50 STRANGES,MARY 427232 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 20.00 SUN LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY OF CANADA 00221-0009 21-May-2019 REMITTANCE 978.40 SUN LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY OF CANADA 00223-0007 03-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 454,398.32 SUN LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY OF CANADA 00226-0004 24-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 451,560.02 SUN LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY OF CANADA - BILLING AND COLLECTIONS - GROUP FINANCE427917 12-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 1,688.80 SUN,MICHAEL 427449 29-May-2019 REFUND 5.00 SUN,XIAO FEI 428142 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 124.10 SUNCOR ENERGY PRODUCTS PARTNERSHIP 427233 23-May-2019 FUEL 54,598.06 SUNCOR ENERGY PRODUCTS PARTNERSHIP 427448 29-May-2019 FUEL 54,579.95 SUNCOR ENERGY PRODUCTS PARTNERSHIP 427664 05-Jun-2019 FUEL 54,789.33 SUNCOR ENERGY PRODUCTS PARTNERSHIP 427916 12-Jun-2019 FUEL 63,788.82 SUNCOR ENERGY PRODUCTS PARTNERSHIP 428141 19-Jun-2019 FUEL 53,036.37 SUNCOR ENERGY PRODUCTS PARTNERSHIP 428427 26-Jun-2019 FUEL 49,841.04 SUNQUEST 427918 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,510.92 SUNSHINE BUILDING MAINTENANCE INC 428428 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 7,220.70 SUPERIOR FOOD SERVICE 427450 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 506.76 SUPERIOR PROPANE 428143 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 777.11 SUPERIOR VAULT COMPANY LIMITED 427451 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 565.00 SUTHERLAND,TERRANCE JAMES 428144 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 SWEC,PAUL 427452 29-May-2019 GRANT 75.00 SWINDLEY,MATTHEW 427234 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 SYBERTECH WASTE REDUCTION LTD.428145 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 17,233.28 T & T DRY CLEANERS & TAILORS 427248 23-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 90.40 T & T DRY CLEANERS & TAILORS 428442 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 45.20 T SMITH ENGINEERING INC 427247 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 TALK WIRELESS INC 428429 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,340.18 TALK WIRELESS INC 427235 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,573.86 TALK WIRELESS INC 427665 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 434.07 TALK WIRELESS INC 428146 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 834.05 TALK WIRELESS INC 427919 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,718.73 TARTEN EQUIPMENT LIMITED 428430 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 501.34 TASTE BUDS CAFE & EATERY 427236 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 69.14 TAXITAB 428431 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 1,664.58 TAYLOR,PAIGE& PARSONS-TAYLOR, DARRYL 427920 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 181.32 TAYLOR,STEVEN JOHN 427668 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 TAYLORS WATER SERVICE 427667 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 75.00 TD CANADA TRUST 427237 23-May-2019 REFUND 11.39 TD CANADA TRUST 427669 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 816.61 TD CANADA TRUST 427921 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 736.00 TECHNICAL STANDARDS & SAFETY AUTHORITY 427453 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 105.00 TECHNICAL STANDARDS & SAFETY AUTHORITY 428432 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 514.15 TELUS COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY 428147 19-Jun-2019 SERVICES 519.80 TENAQUIP LIMITED 427670 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,465.05 TENAQUIP LIMITED 428148 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 869.44 TENDER WISHES FOUNDATION 427671 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 TERRIO,RALPH 427672 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 THE BURKE GROUP 428232 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 56.50 THE CANADA TRUST COMPANY 428243 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 3,538.83 THE ILLUSIONIST: LUCAS,WILSON 428047 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,124.35 THERAPY TAILS ONTARIO 427454 29-May-2019 GRANT 100.00 THERMO KING EASTERN CANADA 427673 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 969.58 THISTLEWAITE YARDWORKS 427455 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 463.30 THOMAS,SAMUEL 427674 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 10,500.00 THOMAS,SAMUEL 427923 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,200.00 THOMAS,SAMUEL 428434 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 500.00 THOMPSON AHERN & CO LIMITED 427238 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 174.51 THOMPSON AHERN & CO LIMITED 427922 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 136.86 THOMPSON,JEFF 427456 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 240.60 THOROWEST PLAZA LTD 427458 29-May-2019 REFUND 2,100.00 THOROWEST PLAZA LTD 428433 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 6,303.36 THORPE,ROBIN 427457 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 200.00 Page 94 of 192 Page 16 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount THYSSENKRUPP ELEVATOR (CANADA) LIMITED 427675 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 513.49 THYSSENKRUPP ELEVATOR (CANADA) LIMITED 428149 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 549.89 TIDD,DEREK 427240 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 1,500.00 TIKKY,MARIANNE 427459 29-May-2019 PETTY CASH 286.78 TIM HORTON'S STORE 1922 428150 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 102.04 TMR RENOVATIONS AND CONSTRUCTION 427676 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 TNT WORK & RESCUE 427242 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 9,114.38 TODD MORGAN HOLDING CORPO 428436 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,049.57 TOOLBOX 427243 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,011.23 TOOLBOX 427461 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 155.28 TOP HAT MARCHING ORCHESTRA 428152 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,000.00 TOP NOTCH PROMOTIONAL PRODUCTS INC 427925 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 410.33 TOPLIFFE,JEANETTE 427678 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 316.28 TORONTO STAMP INC 428153 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 80.46 TOTAL LAND CARE SERVICES 428154 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 33,871.75 TOTAL LAND CARE SERVICES 428437 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 18,108.25 TOWN OF THOROLD 428438 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 267.50 TRADE A DOLLAR INC 428439 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,295.41 TRANSAXLE PARTS (HAMILTON) INC.427244 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 2,929.53 TRANSAXLE PARTS (HAMILTON) INC.427462 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,887.01 TRANSAXLE PARTS (HAMILTON) INC.427679 05-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 1,634.04 TRANSAXLE PARTS (HAMILTON) INC.427926 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 15,126.18 TRANSAXLE PARTS (HAMILTON) INC.428440 26-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 3,038.58 TRAPASSO,JUDY 428441 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 459.23 TRAPEZE SOFTWARE ULC 427245 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 117,425.08 TRAVIS,SHAYLIN 428155 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 50.00 TREMBLAY,SUSAN 427463 29-May-2019 REFUND 129.20 TREMBLAY,TALYA 428156 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 160.00 TROMBLEY,SEAN 427927 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,000.00 TROY LIFE & FIRE SAFETY LTD 427246 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,325.54 TRUGREEN 428157 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 305.10 TRUGREEN 427464 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 351.43 TUDINI,SELENE 427465 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 84.17 TULIPAN,GARY 427680 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 61.87 TURF CARE PRODUCTS CANADA LIMITED 427249 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 238.69 TURF CARE PRODUCTS CANADA LIMITED 427928 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 533.63 TURF CARE PRODUCTS CANADA LIMITED 428158 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 246.02 TURF CARE PRODUCTS CANADA LIMITED 428443 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 709.55 TURNER FLEISCHER ARCHITECTS INC 427250 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 TWARDAWSKY,NICK 427929 12-Jun-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 108.00 TYPHON GROUP LTD 428444 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,117.84 ULINE CANADA CORPORATION 427251 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,497.33 UNCONQUERED SUN SOLAR TECHNOLOGIES INC.428159 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 UNISYNC GROUP LTD 427681 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 136.58 UNITED ROTARY BRUSH CORPORATION OF CANADA 427930 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,218.76 UNITED WAY NIAGARA 427466 29-May-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 1,389.50 UNITED WAY NIAGARA 428445 26-Jun-2019 PAYROLL REMITTANCE 931.00 URBAN & ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT INC 428446 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 12,558.54 URGE TO PURGE 427467 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 593.25 URGE TO PURGE 428160 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 17,855.92 URGE TO PURGE 428447 26-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,842.10 UTC FIRE & SECURITY CANADA 427683 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,647.85 V GIBBONS CONTRACTING LTD 427471 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 4,366.04 V GIBBONS CONTRACTING LTD 427932 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 74,297.58 V GIBBONS CONTRACTING LTD 428166 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,550.87 VACCARO,GINO 428161 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 120.88 VACCARO,LOIS MARIE 427468 29-May-2019 REFUND 101.70 VALEO,SAM 427469 29-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 501.12 VAN DE LAAR,DAVE 428449 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 146.89 VAN HOUTTE COFFEE SERVICES INC 427470 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 334.98 VAN KLEEF,PHILLIP 428163 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 500.00 VANCOR SUPPLY 428448 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 430.08 VANESCH,AL 428162 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 VARCOE,DANIEL HERBERT& VARCOE, JUDY 428164 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 230.00 VATTOVAZ,THOMAS JOSEPH 428165 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 29.05 VECCHIO ORNAMENTAL IRON LIMITED 428450 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 350.48 VICTORIA CENTRE BIA 428451 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 118,750.00 VILLENEUVE,CHRIS 428452 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 150.00 VITTIE,JANET 427252 23-May-2019 TRAVEL/MILEAGE 407.16 W.E. ENTERPRISES LIMITED 428169 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 190.95 WAJAX POWER SYSTEMS 427253 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,294.00 WAJAX POWER SYSTEMS 428453 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 7,631.78 WAJAX POWER SYSTEMS 427472 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 51.48 WAJAX POWER SYSTEMS 427933 12-Jun-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 125.00 WALDICK,NEIL 428168 19-Jun-2019 MEMBERSHIP 56.50 WALKER AGGREGATES INC 427254 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 4,459.79 WALKER AGGREGATES INC 427685 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,278.11 WALKER AGGREGATES INC 427934 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,865.89 WALKER AGGREGATES INC 428167 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,807.59 WALKER AGGREGATES INC 428454 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,618.00 WALKER COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CORP 427684 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 WARRINER,DONALD ALEXANDER 427686 05-Jun-2019 REFUND 750.00 WATER CONCEPTS 427255 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 777.73 WATTS,JASON& WATTS, VALERIE 427935 12-Jun-2019 REFUND 49.62 Page 95 of 192 Page 17 of 17 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS MUNICIPAL ACCOUNTS VENDOR NAME Cheque No.Cheque Date Purpose Amount WEESTREEM 427256 23-May-2019 SERVICES 762.75 WEESTREEM 427687 05-Jun-2019 SERVICES 508.50 WEESTREEM 428456 26-Jun-2019 SERVICES 762.75 WEINMANN LIMITED 427473 29-May-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 15,499.36 WEINMANN LIMITED 427688 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 5,755.17 WEINMANN LIMITED 427936 12-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 36,446.72 WELDDARE METAL WORKS LTD 428457 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 361.60 WENDY LEARD SCHOOL OF DANCE 427937 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 400.00 WESCO DISTRIBUTION CANADA INC 427474 29-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 446.87 WESTECH HEALTH CARE LTD.427689 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,170.35 WET & HUMID NO MORE LTD 427257 23-May-2019 REFUND 1,500.00 WHEELER,SUE 428170 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 99.26 WHITE,BECKY 427938 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 315.00 WICKS,PHILIP 428459 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 85.00 WIENS,BRAD 427477 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 175.00 WILLOUGHBY VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT 427478 29-May-2019 LEASES AND RENTS 7,414.21 WOLSELEY CANADA INC.427479 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 1,810.54 WOLSELEY CANADA INC.427940 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,160.80 WOLSELEY CANADA INC.428171 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 10,499.93 WOLSELEY CANADA INC.427259 23-May-2019 STORES/INVENTORY 321.85 WOMEN'S PLACE OF SOUTH NIAGARA INC 427260 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 1,612.50 WOMEN'S PLACE OF SOUTH NIAGARA INC 428172 19-Jun-2019 GRANT 1,612.50 WONG,MIU LIN 428173 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 55.15 WOOD ENVIRONMENT & INFRASTRUCTURE SOLUTIONS 427261 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 497.20 WOOD ENVIRONMENT & INFRASTRUCTURE SOLUTIONS 428174 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,948.74 WOODS,IAN 427691 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 62.12 WORK AUTHORITY 427262 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 150.00 WORK AUTHORITY 427941 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 2,138.12 WSIB 427481 29-May-2019 REMITTANCE 36,951.35 WSIB 427692 05-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 20,475.11 WSIB 427693 05-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 887.81 WSIB 427942 12-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 3,643.41 WSIB 428460 26-Jun-2019 REMITTANCE 38,337.82 XCG CONSULTING LIMITED 428175 19-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 30,104.21 XCG CONSULTING LIMITED 427943 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 36,040.87 XPLORNET COMMUNICATIONS INC 427263 23-May-2019 SERVICES 101.69 XPLORNET COMMUNICATIONS INC 427944 12-Jun-2019 SERVICES 101.69 XU,YUNPENG 428176 19-Jun-2019 REFUND 1,250.00 YAN,ZE HONG 428462 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 5,656.23 YANNIX CANADA INC 428461 26-Jun-2019 REFUND 6,995.94 YELLOW PAGES 427482 29-May-2019 ADVERTISING 530.49 YMCA OF NIAGARA 427264 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 3,643.77 YMCA OF NIAGARA 427483 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 260.05 YMCA OF NIAGARA 427694 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 1,143.39 YMCA OF NIAGARA 427945 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 4,165.21 YMCA OF NIAGARA 428463 26-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 6,389.41 YOUNG SOD FARMS LTD 427946 12-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 72.77 YOUNG,CRYSTAL 427265 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 YWCA 427266 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 4,277.75 YWCA 428177 19-Jun-2019 GRANT 4,277.75 ZAMBONI COMPANY LTD 427267 23-May-2019 MATERIALS 473.36 ZAMBONI COMPANY LTD 427484 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 2,779.68 ZAMBONI COMPANY LTD 427695 05-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 3,134.73 ZAMBONI COMPANY LTD 428178 19-Jun-2019 MATERIALS 194.07 ZAVITZ,SHERMAN 427268 23-May-2019 FEE FOR SERVICE 1,500.00 ZELUS MATERIAL HANDLING 427696 05-Jun-2019 CONTRACT SERVICES 2,768.50 ZHANG,YUN 427485 29-May-2019 MATERIALS 100.00 ZITANO,NICOLA 427269 23-May-2019 REFUND 750.00 Total 16,863,038.46 Page 96 of 192 MW-2019-19 July 16th, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Municipal Works SUBJECT: MW-2019-19 Cast Iron Tactile Walking Surface Indicators (TWSI’s) RECOMMENDATION 1. That Council direct Staff to perform a multi-year pilot of product alternatives and stain removal methodologies; and 2. That Council direct Staff to consult with representatives of the Canadian National Institute for the Blind (CNIB) and the Mayor’s Accessibility Advisory Committee; and 3. That Council direct Staff to report back on the results of the pilot and consultation by the end of 2020. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The current standard for Tactile Walking Surface Indicator plates at concrete sidewalk depressions within the City of Niagara Falls, the Niagara Region and the Province is grey cast iron with a natural finish. Studies have shown that in terms of installation, durability, cost, maintenance and detectability (intactness of domes), cast iron plates performed better than plastic/composite polymers. Cast iron tactile plates have longer warranties than other products and are expected to perform effectively for the life of the concrete sidewalk. A natural cast iron surface oxidizes when exposed to the elements and although the resulting patina finish on tactile warning plates provides an enhanced colour contrast for visually impaired pedestrians, the rust will stain a portion of the surrounding concrete. Although not permanent the majority of the orange rust staining will occur in the ea rly days after installation, adversely impacting the aesthetic of the new construction. There are alternatives to minimize/eliminated concrete staining without sacrificing the durability and life expectancy of a cast iron p roduct. A powder coating on the surface of cast iron tactile warning plates will provide an initial coloured and finished look to new concrete sidewalks. As the colour wears away over an approximate three year period the exposed cast iron will oxidize to a final patina finish without the flush of rust staining common with the natural cast iron finish. Alternatively, the staining can be scrubbed away with an approved cleanser and strong bristled broom. Page 97 of 192 2 MW-2019-19 July 16th, 2019 A municipal pilot project to confirm the effectiveness of techniques to minimize/eliminated concrete staining as well as to test the durability of composite alternatives, coupled with important feedback from both the Canadian National Institute for the Blind (CNIB) and the Mayor’s Accessibility Advisory Committee would provide valuable context for consideration of any change to the current TWSI standards. BACKGROUND City Construction Standards: The Ontario Municipal/Provincial Standards (OPS) are the primary material and construction specifications used by over 400 municipalities across the province. In addition to these, the City of Niagara Falls, like the majority of local municipalities within the Niagara Region, have also adopted the Niagara Peninsula Standard Contract Document (NPSCD) for linear capital construction projects including roads and underground servicing. Originally developed in the late 1990s, the NPSCD was created with the input from key stakeholders including representation from the lower tier municipalities, Heavy Construction Association, Consulting Engineers of Ontario - Niagara Chapter and the Niagara Region. The document includes standard supplementary construction specifications that augment and/or modify the OPS to suit the Niagara area and assists in providing consistency throughout the region while offering a stable bidding platform for local contractors. A committee of stakeholders continue to meet regularly to consider annual revisions to the NPSCD. Tactile Walking Surface Indicator Construction Standards: Tactile Walking Surface Indicators (TWSI’s) are devices with defined sets of embossed patterns that alert pedestrians with visual impairments of approaching streets and hazardous surfaces or grade changes. In addition to being tactile, TWSIs are also designed to stand out using color contrast against the surrounding pavement. In 2014, an NPSCD subcommittee was formed to review alternative products for TWSI’s, understanding that effective January 1st, 2016, the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA), under Part IV.1 of Reg 191/11 would require mandatory tactile walking surface indicators on all new and repaired depressed curb sidewalks within Ontario. At that time, the City of Toronto had just completed a pilot project to test different tactile plate materials for installation at depressed curb sidewalks and had published a summary of the results in a paper titled, “Testing Different Materials for Tactile Walking Surface Indicators – Pilot Project Evaluation Report (March 28th, 2014)”. The NPSCD subcommittee reviewed this document as part of the overall tactile warning plate review and concluded that in terms of installation, durability, cost, maintenance and detectability (intactness of domes), cast iron plates performed better than plastic/composite polymers, clay brick pavers and concrete pavers. As a result, the members of the NPSCD Page 98 of 192 3 MW-2019-19 July 16th, 2019 committee added a Class 35B grey cast iron tactile warning surface construction specification to the standard document. In November 2015, revisions to the Ontario Municipal/Provincial Standards, specifically ‘OPSS 351 – Construction Specification for Concrete Sidewalk’ was also revised to reflect AODA requirements by adding “grey cast iron tactile walking surface indicator plates” as the approved tactile warning surface standard. ANALYSIS/RATIONALE Resiliency Studies have demonstrated that compared to plastic/composite alternatives, cast iron tactile warning plates at curb depressions are more resistant to the effects of weather and the physical stresses caused by impact, snow removal and traffic. Accordingly, cast iron tactile plates come with a 10-year warranty and are expected to last the lifetime of the concrete while plastic/composite products only have five year warranties and regularly require replacement long before the concrete sidewalk. Staining The natural state cast iron from the TWSIs specified in the NPSCD and OPS forms an iron oxide scale that darkens to what is known as a permanent patina due to oxidation and exposure to moisture. Once formed, this colour will stay, providing effective visual contrast for its entire service life. Unfortunately an orange coloured scale (rust) frequently stains the surrounding concrete. Approximately 90% of the staining will occur within the first few weeks after installation and can last upwards of a year before wearing away from the concrete. Although not harmful to the concrete, this staining can reduce the aesthetic appeal of newly constructed sidewalk. There are however, techniques available to minimize/eliminate rust staining without compromising on the durability and performance of cast iron tactile plates. For example, the City of London installs powder coated cast iron TWSIs. The painted surfaces wear off over a period of approximately three years during which time the oxidizing process slowly occurs on the exposed surfaces. The end product is a full patina finish without the initial flush of rust to the surrounding concrete. Alternatively, concrete staining can be scrubbed away with an approved cleaner and a strong bristled broom. Testing A pilot project would serve to confirm the effectiveness of techniques to minimize/eliminate rust staining, including both powder coated plates and cleaning of recently stained concrete. Additionally, a sampling of composite tactile plates could be tested at high traffic areas on sidewalk snow plow routes to test durability as it relates specifically to the City of Niagara Falls weather conditions and maintenance operations. Page 99 of 192 4 MW-2019-19 July 16th, 2019 It is important that any pilot project to test tactile warning plates b e extended as a minimum across all four seasons and be monitored regularly throughout . Moreover, feedback from both the Canadian National Institute for the Blind (CNIB) and the Mayor’s Accessibility Advisory Committee would provide valuable context for future consideration of a change to the City’s TWSI standards. FINANCIAL/STAFFING/LEGAL IMPLICATIONS The supply of a standard 2 foot square grey cast iron, natural finish tactile warning plate is approximately $80.00. The inclusion of a powder coated finish would be an additional $14.00- $18.00 per plate. A concrete stain cleaning provision within the City’s construction specifications would be negligible increase in cost to a contract. By comparison the same sized plastic/composite plate (Access Tile) is approximately $64.00 and a more robust version (Armor-Tile) is $96.00. Both of these products come with a five-year warranty and do not have the same life expectancy of cast iron. CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT This project and recommendation are in keeping with Council’s Strategic priorities for Infrastructure Sustainability. LIST OF ATTACHMENTS 1. Testing Different Materials for Tactile Walking Surface Indicators – Pilot Project Evaluation Report (March 28th, 2014)” Recommended by: Erik Nickel, Director of Municipal Works Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer Sherri-Marie Millar, P.Eng. Page 100 of 192 Report Title: Testing Different Materials for Tactile Walking Surface Indicators – Pilot Project Evaluation Report Prepared by Pedestrian Projects, Transportation Services, City of Toronto on March 28, 2014 1.0 Introduction The City of Toronto is developing a new standard for pedestrian intersection crossings at curb depressions to comply with the Design of Public Spaces Standards , which is Part IV.1 of Ontario Regulation 191/11, Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005. One of the new legislative requirements is the requirement for raised tactile walking surface indicators at the bottom of curb ramps and depressed curbs to assist visually-impaired pedestrians with detecting hazards such as the edge of the roadway. This report provides an overview of a pilot project conducted by the City of Toronto from November 2012 to December 2013 to test different tactile walking surface indicator materials, and summarizes the evaluation of the performance of the various materials in terms of installation, durability (physical condition), and cost. 1.1 Background On December 12, 2012, The Province of Ontario passed Ontario Regulation 413/12 to amend Ontario Regulation 191/11, Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 (AODA) to include Part IV.1, Design of Public Space Standards (Accessibility Standards for the Built Environment). The amendment to the regulation came into force January 1, 2013 and applies to public spaces that are newly constructed or redeveloped after January 1, 2016 by municipalities among other obligated organizations . 1.1.1 AODA Design of Public Spaces Standards – Sections 80.26 on Curb Ramps and 80.27 on Depressed Curbs includes raised tactile profiles The Design of Public Spaces Standards (Accessibility Standards for the Built Environment) outlines standards for curb ramps and depressed curbs at pedestrian crossings in section 80.26(1) and 80.27(1) respectively. A curb ramp must align with the direction of travel and have a minim um clear width of 1,200mm, exclusive of flared sides. The maximum running slope of curb ramps is 1:8 (where elevation is less than 75mm) and 1:10 (where 75mm or greater). The cross slope cannot exceed 1:50. The flared sides of the curb ramp must have a maximum slope of 1:10. A depressed curb must have a maximum running slope of 1:20 and be aligned in the direction of travel. Both curb ramps and depressed curbs with pedestrian crossings must have tactile walking surface indicators that have raised tactile pr ofiles, have high tonal contrast with the adjacent surface, are located at the bottom of the curb ramp (and extend the full width of the curb ramp) or the bottom portion of the depressed curb that is flush with the roadway, are set back between 150mm and 2 00mm from the curb edge and are a minimum of 610mm in depth. MW-2019-19 Attachment 1 – Testing Different Materials for Tactile Walking Surface Indicators – Pilot Project Evaluation Report (March 28th, 2014) Page 101 of 192 1.1.2 Canadian Standards Association (CSA) Standard B651-12 – Tactile Walking Surface Indicators The Canadian Standards Association Standard B651-12, titled "Accessible Design for the Built Environment" outlines standard dimensions of tactile walking surface indicators in sections 4.3.5.2 and 4.3.5.3. A tactile walking surface shall be installed in a manner that avoids interference from an irregular walking surface; and does not create a tripping hazard; have its base surface level with the surrounding surface, or not more than 3mm above or below it; be slip resistant; and be colour contrasted with the surrounding surface. A tactile walking surface indicator shall be composed of truncated dom es with a height of 5mm ±1mm; with the top diameter between 12 and 15mm and the base diameter 10mm ±1mm greater than the top diameter; arranged in a square grid; and with a centre to centre distance of adjacent domes between 55 and 61mm for domes with a 12mm top diameter or between 57 and 63mm for domes with a 15mm top diameter. Systematic research has shown that a top diameter of 12mm is optimal for detection and discrimination underfoot. A tactile walking surface indicator shall be in a colour that contrasts at least 70% with the surrounding surface; or if yellow, contrasts at least 40% with the surrounding surface. 1.2 Pilot Project to Evaluate Materials for Tactile Walking Surface Indicators The City of Toronto began a pilot project to evaluate four dif ferent tactile walking surface indicator products by installing the different selected products at the four corners of the intersection of Shuter Street and Victoria Street within the D owntown . The location was selected for this evaluation because of the intersection 's location within a high pedestrian traffic area next to St Michael's Hospital which has enabled observations of diverse pedestrians with various needs and conditions . It maximized the ability to observe pedestrians individually and in groups, of different ages, and pedestrians using different assistive devices, such as wheelchairs, motorized scooters, canes, crutches , small carts with wheels, wheeled luggage, and strollers. Construction of the pedestrian crossings with the tactile walking surf ace indicators was completed on November 8, 2012. 2.0 Product Overview Four different tactile walking surface materials were tested: plastic/composite polymers, clay brick pavers, concrete pavers, and cast iron plates. 2.1 Tactile Walking Surface Indicator Pr oducts Various products were selected for use in the pilot project based on several factors. Access tiles were selected because they have previously been used in the City for different outdoor applications. The Unilock pavers were selected because the city currently uses Unilock pavers for various outdoor applications. The Unilock ADA paver is larger than the typical paving stone used and the Endicott product was selected because it is available in a smaller size that is consistent with what is already being used within the City. A cast iron product was also used in the pilot as it was assumed to have good durability and is already being used in different municipalities in Ontario and Quebec. Page 102 of 192 2.1.A Access Tile Access Tile supplied by Engineered Plastics Inc. was installed at the northwest corner of Shuter Street and Victoria Street. The corner has two curb depressions, one in each direction of travel. Two straight sections of Access Tiles were installed. The tactile walking surface indicators for the north south crossing used R eplaceable Cast in Place tiles in a Brick Red colour and the east west crossing used Surface Applied tiles in an Onyx Black c olour. Access Tiles are made of engineered composite polymers and come in various rectangular sizes as well as in a 10' radius. Installation of the Replaceable Cast in Place tiles requires the tiles to be set into concrete. The anchors are set in the concrete and the panels can be r emoved and replaced if required. The Surface Applied tiles are applied onto an existing surface with adhesive and newly poured concrete is not required for installation. 2.1.B Endicott Handicap Detectable Warning Paver Endicott Handicap Detectable Warning Paver supplied by Thames Valley Brick & Tile was installed at the southwest corner of Shuter Street and Victoria Street. The corner has a continuous curb depression for both directions of travel. A continuous curved section of Handicap Detectable Warning Pavers was installed along the curb depr ession using Mang anese Ironspot coloured pavers . The pavers are made of clay and come in 4"×8" sized units. Installation of the Handicap Detectable Warning Pavers requires the fitting of the pavers into the required area. 2.1.C Unilock ADA Paver Unilock ADA Pavers were installed at the southeast corner of Shuter Street and Victoria Street. The corner has a continuous curb depression for both directions of travel. A continuous curved section of ADA Pavers was installed along the curb depression using Char coal coloured pavers. Unilock ADA Pavers are made of concrete and come in 12"×12" sized units. Installation of ADA Pavers requires fitting of the pavers into the required area. Note: at the time of the pilot project, no radial products were available, but since then, the supplier has a variety of radii options (e.g. 4.5m, 6m, 7.5m and 9m radii). 2.1.D Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plates supplied by Crozier Enterprises was installed at the northeast corner of Shu ter Street and Victoria Street. The corner has a continuous curb depression for both directions of travel. Two curved sections of Detectable Warning Plates were installed using unpainted plates , one section for each direction of travel. Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plates are made of cast iron and come in various rectangular (12"x12", 24"x24", 24"x30", and 24"x36") sizes as well as in 9'5", 15', 20', 25', and 35' radii. Installation of the Detectable Warning Plates requires the plates to be connected together and set into concrete. 2.2 Installation Installation of tactile walking surface indicators generally requires the reconstruction of the sidewalk where the product is to be placed. This involves the removal of the existing sidewalk followed by forming, pouring, and finishing of the new sidewalk. The installation of tactile walking surface indicators should be accommodated during new Page 103 of 192 sidewalk construction or reconstruction. To install tactile walking surface indicators a void space must be provided in the concrete for pavers or the product must be placed into fresh poured concrete for cast in place applications. 2.3.A Access Tile The installation of s urface applied Access Tiles requires a finished sidewalk. The surface where the tile will be placed is scoured with a grinder and the dust is removed with a leaf blower. The provided adhesive is applied to the back of the tile as directed and pressed onto the concrete surface aft er the tile and concrete surface have been cleaned with acetone. Following this holes are drilled through the tile at specified locations into the concrete and upon cleaning of the hole, the supplied fastener is hammered to set it into the tile. The perimeter of the tile is cleaned to remove any escaped adhesive and a perimeter sealant is applied after masking tape has been placed around the perimeter. The installation of cast in place Access Tiles requires a newly poured concrete surface. The tiles are placed onto the poured concrete and tamped. A concrete free recess is created around the perimeter of the tile and the concrete is finished. 2.2.B Endicott Handicap Detectable Warning Paver The installation of Handicap Detectable Warning Pavers requires a s pace within the sidewalk to place the pavers. A form is created for the pavers to be placed before the concrete is poured for the sidewalk. The sidewalk is finished and after the forms are removed, the pavers are placed in the required configurati on within the space provided. Pavers may require cutting to fit in the space provided. 2.2.C Unilock ADA Paver The installation of ADA Pavers requires a space within the sidewalk to place the pavers. A form is created for the pavers to be placed before the concrete is poured for the sidewalk. The sidewalk is finished and after the forms are removed, the pavers are placed in the required configurati on within the space provided. Pavers may require cutting to fit in the space provided. 2.2.D Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate The installation of cast iron detectable warning plates requires a newly poured concrete surface. If required, multiple plates are connected together. The supplied lifting springs are used to lift and set the plates into position. After the lifting springs are removed the concrete is finished around the plate. 2.3 Physical Condition Evaluation The physical condition was evaluated on December 4, 2013 approximately 13 months after installation. The evaluation was undertaken one year f ollowing installation to see how each product was affected by a cycle of f our seasons. It was important to make sure at least one winter season had passed to evaluate how the products held up against sidewalk snow plowing operations. Durability of the product is an important component as these products will have to hold up to many years of snow plowing operations. Page 104 of 192 2.3.A Access Tile The following are two close up photographs of the tactile walking surface indicators: one soon after installation, and and the other about one year later. Cast in place Access Tiles showed minimal damage to the plates. The surface applied Access Tiles showed significantly more damage to the plates with sections around the edges torn off. The textured surface on the tops of the truncated domes for both applications was almost completely worn off leaving the tops of the truncated domes completely smooth. 2.3.B Endicott Handicap Detectable Warning Paver The following are two close up photographs of the tactile walking surface indicators: one soon after installation, and and the other about one year later. Endicott pavers had several of the truncated domes damaged. Damage consisted of truncated domes being completely torn off and with significant portions of the truncated domes chipped away. Many of the truncated domes did appear to be in good condition. The pavers also showed signs of differential settling in some areas. 2.3.C Unilock ADA Paver The following are two close up photographs of the tactile walking surface indicators: one soon after installation, and and the other about one year later. Page 105 of 192 Unilock pavers had almost all of the truncated domes damaged. Damage consisted of truncated domes being completely torn off and with significant portions of the truncated domes being chipped away. There were no visible truncated domes that remained in good condition. The gaps between the pavers provided voids for litter such as cigarette butts to collect. 2.3.D Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate The following are two close up photographs of the tactile walking surface indicators: one soon after installation, and and the other about one year later. Neenah Foundry plates showed minimal damage. All the plates and truncated domes were completely intact. There were a couple truncated domes with some of the bumps of the textured surface removed. The concrete curb also showed signs of rust staining that was expected in the first year and is expected to fade over time as the cast iron turns into a naturally dark patina. 2.4 Conformity to Standards Tactile walking surface indicator products must conform to CSA Standard B651-12 and installations with the products must be able to conform to the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 as noted in this report under section 1.1.1. Table 2.4.1 below outlines the truncated dome dimensions. Top (mm) Base (mm) Spacing (mm) Height (mm) CSA Standard 12-15 22-25 55-63 5±1 Page 106 of 192 Access Tile 11.4 22.9 59.7 5.1 Endicott Detectable Warning Paver 19.1 22.9 50.8 5.1 Unilock ADA Paver 17.9 27.9 61.0 5.1 Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate 12.7 22.9 50.8 5.1 2.4.A Access Tile The truncated dome dimension for the top of the dome is 11.4mm which is 0.6mm less than the required 12-15mm. All other dimensions of the domes meet the required CSA standards. T he surface applied Access Tiles are not able to meet the CSA standards for dif ference in elevation between the base surface of the tile and the surrounding surface. The surface applied Access Tiles are adhered onto the surface of the existing concrete and cannot be set into the concrete to adjust the elevation of the tile. The difference in elevation from the base surface of the tile and the bottom of the tile is 4.6mm which is 1.6mm greater that the required 3mm maximum on the curb side and 4.6mm greater than the required 0-3mm. Installations of Access Tiles are only able to conform to standards when cast in place tiles are installed at curb depressions along straight sections of curbs. Access Tiles are available in rectangular sections and in 10' radius sections making it difficult to maintain the required 150-200mm offset from the edge of curb. 2.4.B Endicott Handicap Detectable Warning Paver The truncated dome dimension for the top of the dome is 19.1mm which is 4.1mm greater than he required 12-15mm. The dimension for the spacing of domes is 50.8mm which is 4.2mm less than the required 55-63mm. All other dimensions of the dome meet the required CSA standards. The spacing of domes will also be affected when the pavers are installed along curved sections because the pavers are rectangular and pavers cannot be installed parallel to each other if they are to be placed in a curved section. 2.4.C Unilock ADA Paver The truncated dome dimension for the top of the dome is 17.9mm which is 2.9mm greater than the required 12-15mm. The dimension for the base is 27.9mm which is 2.9mm greater than the required 22-25mm. All other dimensions of the dome meet the required CSA standards. The spacing of domes will also be affected when the pavers are installed along curved sections because the pavers are rectangular and pavers cannot be installed parallel to each other if they are to be placed in a curved section. The Unilock ADA Paver is larger in size than typical pavers resulting in greater variations in spacing when installed along a curve. 2.4.D Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate The trunc ated dome dimension for the spacing of the domes is 50.8mm which is 4.2mm less than the required 55-63. All other dimensions of the dome meet the required CSA standards. Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plates should be able to fit a wide Page 107 of 192 range of radii because they are available in 9'5", 15', 20', 25', and 35' sections which can be combined to fit different radius curves while maintaining the required 150- 200mm offset from the edge of curb. The spacing of domes will also be affected when using radial plates because the dome spacing cannot be consistent throughout the entire plate due to the curve. 2.5 Cost Evaluation The cost of installation was evaluated for new construction and retrofit scenarios. The cost for new construction includes just the additional cost of installing tactile walking surface indicators at the time of sidewalk construction. This figure does not include the cost of constructing a curb and sidewalk since the tactile walking surface indicators are being installed at th e time of sidewalk construction. A retrofit scenario would be the upgrading of a pedestrian crossing for the purpose of installing tactile walking surface indicators. The cost for retrofit scenarios is an estimate of the cost to install tactile walking surface indicators on existing pedestrian crossings and includes the cost of reconstructing the curb and sidewalk if necessary. The intersection corner layout used for the cost evaluation was created to replicate an intersection in the Downtown so it could be used to estimate quantities for road reconstruction scenarios and retrofit scenarios. Retrofit scenarios are most likely to occur in areas with high pedestrian volumes such as within Toronto's D owntown . In the D owntown, sidewalks are generally adjacent to the curb without a boulevard and are constructed monolithic with the curb and sidewalk being formed together during construction. Sidewalk widths are often 3-4m wide and curb radii are often around 6m. For the estimation of costs used for t he cost evaluation, a right angled intersection with 3.5m sidewalks and 6m curb radii was used. Depressed curb locations were determined using a 3m wide painted crossing path that is offset 1m from the travelled lane. Depressed curbs were placed for the wi dth of all pedestrian crossing pavement markings with curb transitions being 1m long. For reconstruction of the sidewalk it was assumed that the entire radius section of the sidewalk would be replaced. For the intersection corner layout used, a linear 15' (4.57m) of 2' (610mm) deep tactile walking surface indicators placed in a continuous section would be required along with 23m² of 150mm thick, monolithic curb and concrete sidewalk at a cost of approximately $2576 will be required for retrofit scenarios where the sidewalk must be reconstructed. Page 108 of 192 Figure 2.5.1 below shows a diagram of a street c orner used for cost estimate The unit prices used were the average unit prices for 2013 contracts. Labour for the installation of tactile walking surface indicators was about 2 person-hours for all products included in the pilot project. The associated cost of labour estimated at $48 per hour for 2 person-hours results in a total labour cost of $96. Variations in labour required for installation were negligible and an equal amount of labour for each installation is assumed. Therefore the variations in cost are a function of material costs and the requirement for sidewalk reconstruction in retrofit scenar ios. The table below lists (by product) the number of units, total costs, cost per unit and cost per square metre. Units Total cost Cost per unit Cost per m² Access Tile 5 $647.50 $129.50 $231.25 Endicott Detectable Warning Paver 135 $796.50 $5.90 $284.46 Unilock ADA Paver 30 $407.40 $13.58 $145.50 Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate 5 $741.65 $148.33 $264.88 2.5.A Access Tile The installation cost for the intersection corner layout used consists of $647.50 in materials and approximately $96 in labour for a total additional cost of construction per intersection corner of approximately $743.50. R etrofit scenarios using surface applied Access Tiles are the most cost effective because they do not require the reconstruction of the sidewalk to install. Therefore the installation cost of Access Tiles is the same as in road reconstruction scenarios. Retrofit scenarios using cast in place Access Tiles requires reconstruction of the sidewalk and the total cost is approximately $3319.50 per intersection corner. Page 109 of 192 2.5.B Endicott Handicap Detectable Warning Paver The installation cost for the intersection corner layout used consists of $796.50 in materials and approximately $96 in labour for the total additional cost of construction per intersection corner of approximately $892.50. Retrofit scenarios require the reconstruction of the sidewalk and the total cost is approximately $3468.50 per intersection corner. 2.5.C Unilock ADA Paver The installation cost for the intersection corner layout used consists of $407.40 in materials and approximately $96 in labour for the total additional cost of construction per intersection corner of approximately $503.40. Retrofit scenarios require the reconstruction of the sidewalk and the total cost is approximately $3079.40 per intersection corner. 2.5.D Neenah Foundry Detectable Warning Plate The installation cost for the intersection corner layout used consists of $741.65 in materials and approximately $96 in labour for the total additional cost of construction per intersection corner of approximately $837.65. Retrofit scenarios require the reconstruction of the sidewalk and the total cost is approximately $3413.65 per intersection corner. 3.0 Summary of Assessment In conclusion, cast iron is the material that has performed best overall based on durability after winter maintenance, and effectiveness in terms of the detectability of the domes (i.e., the surface of the domes remaining intact for detection). Installation and costs were all within a relatively similar range. T he durability of the cast iron, however, sets it apart in terms of reducing the costs of maintenance and replacement due to the need to replace the tactile indicators less frequently. The cast iron can be sourced from recycled scrap metal, and has the potential to be reused (i.e., plates could be cleaned and reused, or recycled). All of the materials had truncated domes which are used internationally and nationally. The cast iron product also most closely met the CSA standard than did the clay brick and concrete pavers. Overall, the feedback has been positive from various users including members of the City of Toronto's Disability Issues Committee that visited the site on December 7, 2012 to test the four corners and different materials. There were conflicting preferences in comments from the public for the different materials. Some felt the cast iron was more detectable under foot, and others liked the Access Tile and the pavers . There were some comments about the plastic/composite polymers being more slippery underfoot in rainy and snowy conditions and looking worse from dirt and stains (e.g., gum). There were many comments about the poor condition of the domes on the clay brick pavers and the concrete pavers which had chipped domes and missing domes , and had some differential settling of the pavers (unevenness over time). Opinions differed again regarding aesthetics – some liked the tonal contrast of the Access Tile (red), however others (urban designers and landscape architects) like the patina of the cast iron (once the rust fades), as they felt the appearance does not clash Page 110 of 192 with but enhances streetscapes. The domes are notably more intact over the course of the year for the cast iron material. 3.1 Recommendations Based on durability, cost, maintenance, and detectability (intactness of domes) over time, the cast iron material has performed the best among the four materials tested in this pilot project from November 2012 to December 2013. It is recommended that the City of Toronto use cast iron for its tactile walking surface installations. As the city and other jurisdictions have greater experience with the use and installation of tactile walking s urface indicators, there may be new developments and new products that will be available for consideration. 3.2 Additional Resources Some additional resources are provided below that considers various materials for tactile walking surface indicators. Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 Weblink: http://www.e- laws.gov.on.ca/html/statutes/english/elaws_statutes_05a11_e.htm Built Environment Weblink:http://www.mcss.gov.on.ca/en/mcss/programs/accessibility/built_environment/i ndex.aspx Design of Public Spaces Standards – Part IV.I of Ontario Regulation 191/11 Weblink: http://www.e-laws.gov.on.ca/html/regs/english/elaws_regs_110191_e.htm#BK92 Canadian Standards Association , 2012 (May). Final B651-12 Accessible Design for the Built Environment. Weblink: http://shop.csa.ca/en/canada/accessibility/b651- 12/invt/27021232012 Canadian National Institute for the Blind, 2009. Clear Our Path Guide. Weblink: www.cnib.ca/ Federal Highway Administration, 1999. Designing Sidewalks and Trails for Access. Weblink:http://www.fhwa.d ot.gov/environment/bicycle_pedestrian/publications/sidewalks /contents.cfm Federal Highway Administration and Westat (Jenness, J and Singer, J) 2006. Visual Detection of Detectable Warning Materials by Pedestrians with Visual Impairments. International Association of Traffic and Safety Sciences (2008). Guidebook for the Proper Installation of Tactile Ground Surface Indicators (Braille Blocks): Common Installation Errors. Weblink: http://iatss.or.jp/pdf/tenjie.pdf Page 111 of 192 International Standards Organization - ISO 23599 "Assistive Products for Blind and Vision-Impaired Persons - Tactile Walking Surface Indicators" - March 2012 Weblink:http://www.iso.org/iso/catalogue_detail?csnumber=55867 Montana Department of Transportation 2007. Detectable Warning Devices (Truncated Domes) for use by the Visually Impaired. National Cooperative Highway Research Program, Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, and Texas Transportation Institute. Estakhri, C and Smith, R. 2005. Detectable Warning Products: Installation, Maintenance, and Durability Considerations. National Cooperative Highway Research Program, Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, 2010. Report 670: Recommended Procedures for Testing and Evaluating Detectable Warning Systems. Vermont Agency of Transportation, Bicycle and Pedestrian Program, Local Transportation Facilities , 2006. Report on Spring 2006 Evaluation of Detectable Warning products installed 2003- 2005. Page 112 of 192 PBD-2019-45 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Planning, Building & Development SUBJECT: PBD-2019-45 GTY-2019-003, Gateway Community Improvement Plan and Municipal Employment Incentive Program Application 4749 Buttrey Street Niagara Energy Products RECOMMENDATION 1. That Council approve the Niagara Gateway CIP Tax Increment Based Grant program and Municipal Employment Incentive Program Application for 4749 Buttrey Street subject to the Owner satisfying the program requirements. 2. That Council approve the use of the Capital/Operating reserve to offset the approximate planning and building permit fees of $14,900. 3. That the Niagara Region be advised of the decision of City Council. 4. That the Mayor and Clerk be authorized to sign and execute the Tri -party grant agreement and Municipal Employment Incentive Program Agreement. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Economic Gateway CIP and Municipal Employment Incentive Plan applications can be supported as: - the lands are designated as Employment in the City’s Official Plan and are located within the Strategic Location for Investment under the Gateway Community Improvement Plan; - it meets the minimum point eligibility requirements for both programs; and - the development will bring a combination of investment and new employment to the City and Region. BACKGROUND Niagara Energy Products is a heavy manufacturer serving nuclear markets, oil and gas, and general heavy fabrication with the manufacturing of nuclear waste containers. A new bay is proposed on the southwest corner of the property, along the Victoria Avenue frontage, to house a new boring mill. The new machinery will reduce the reliance on the provision of components from outside providers giving Niagara Energy Products greater capability to meet its increasing demand. The new bay will also open up existing space for the expansion of welding, painting and assembly capacities. Page 113 of 192 2 PBD-2019-45 July 16, 2019 The expansion will support the retention of the company’s current 85 jobs and support future hires. In the short term it is estimated that 1 -5 new jobs are to be created. An application for the tax increment based incentive under the Niagara Gateway Community Improvement Plan has been submitted by Niagara Energy Products. Also submitted is an application under the City’s Municipal Employment Incentive Program for a rebate of site plan control application fees and building permit fees which is available for those applications that have met the eligibility requirements under the Gateway CIP. ANALYSIS/RATIONALE The Niagara Gateway Economic Zone Community Improvement Plan (Gateway CIP) was initiated by the Niagara Region to achieve the goals of the Province’s Growth Plan to: revitalize, diversify and strengthen the economy in Niagara by promoting development of employment lands in the Gateway Economic Zone. The Region’s Gateway CIP was adopted in 2013 and the City approved a corresponding CIP soon after. Development, construction, or rehabilitation projects that result in an increase in assessment value and property taxes for employment uses are eligible for the tax increment based grant (TIBG) under the Gateway CIP. Eligibility The subject lands are designated for employment uses in the Official Plan and are zoned Light Industrial (LI). The new bay expansion complies with Planning documents and a site plan control agreement was entered into with the City in June 2018. Gateway Tax Increment Based Grant (TIBG) Eligibility under the Gateway Grant program is based on a point formula attributed to construction value, full time employment created or retained and smart growth design criteria. The total of these points correspond to the level of the tax increment based grant offered. Based on a review of the application applicant submitted the development could attain:  1 point for a construction value of $1,080,000;  10 points for a total of 85-90 full time jobs created or retained; and  0 points for design criteria; for a total of 11 points or a rebate of 55% of the increased tax assessment. The final number cannot be determined until final confirmation of the actual jobs created, tax assessment increase, and any other relevant program requirements. The subject lands are located within a Strategic Locations for Investment within the Gateway CIP Project Area and are therefore eligible for a TIBG term of 10 years for both the Regional and City portion of the tax increment. It is noted that the education tax is not included within the grant. Page 114 of 192 3 PBD-2019-45 July 16, 2019 Municipal Employment Incentive Program (MEIP) The City’s Municipal Employment Incentive Program (MEIP) offers further incentives to those applicants who have been deemed eligible under the Gateway TIBG. These include:  a waiver to the Site Plan Control Application Fee; and  a Building/Occupancy Permit Rebate (a rebate of 100% of the building permit fee to a maximum of $50,000, subject to the availability of funding). The applicant has entered in a site plan control agreement with the City. The estimated building permit fee is $10,900 and would be rebated only after final inspection and clearance by the Building Division. The following is a breakdown of all of the financial incentives estimated for this project which totals $140,299.00. TIBG $125,399.00 a 55% rebate of the estimated tax increment calculated at $12,539.90 per year over a 10 year term. The breakdown of tax rebate per year is $6,338.63 from the City and $6,201.32 from the Region. $4,000.00 Site Plan Control Application Fee waiver $10,900.00 Building Permit Fee Rebate. Process As a joint program between the City and the Niagara Region, the approval of City Council is required prior to Regional review for the Gateway TIBG. If approved; the applicant must enter into a Tri–Party Agreement with the City and Region outlining the term s and conditions of the funding. This agreement would be authorized and signed by the Mayor and Clerk and forwarded to the Region for signature. An agreement will also be entered into between the City and the applicant for the terms and conditions of the MEIP. The payment of grants commence upon verification of the program requirements and reassessment of the property MPAC (Municipal Property Assessment Corporation). Applicants are given 365 days from the issuance of an occupancy permit within which to contact the City regarding the achievement of the eligibility points outlined in their submission. FINANCIAL/STAFFING/LEGAL IMPLICATIONS The Tax Increment Based Grant (TIBG) is provided when the construction is completed and The Municipal Property Assessment Corporation has added the additional taxable assessment to the roll. This will impact a future taxation year and will be accounted for at that time. Based on the preliminary review of the development, along with an estimated post-project assessment, it is estimated that the applicant may receive a total grant of both Municipal and Regional taxes of approximately $12,539.95 per year over 10 years ($125,399.00). The Municipal portion of the grant at the end of the term is estimated to be $63,386.00. Page 115 of 192 4 PBD-2019-45 July 16, 2019 The property owner has a series of incentives available on this project. It is anticipated that there will be approximately $14,900.00 of applicable planning and building permit fees that will be offset with a transfer of capital/operating reserves. The transfer of building permit fee is a requirement of the building legislation. CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT The City's Community Improvement Plans contribute to the Economic Growth and Prosperity Priority of the City by providing incentives for private sector reinvestment and employment for the City. LIST OF ATTACHMENTS  Appendix 1 – Location Map and Proposed Elevation  Appendix 2 – Site Plan Recommended by: Alex Herlovitch, Director of Planning, Building & Development Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer F.Berardi:gd Attach. S:\PDR\2019\PBD-2019-45, GTY-2019-003, Niagara Energy Products, 4749 Buttrey Street.docx Page 116 of 192 5 PBD-2019-45 July 16, 2019 APPENDIX 1 Location Map and Elevation Plan Page 117 of 192 6 PBD-2019-45 July 16, 2019 APPENDIX 2 Site Plan Page 118 of 192 R&C-2019-15 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Recreation & Culture SUBJECT: R&C-2019-15 Niagara Falls Review Agreement Extension RECOMMENDATION That Council authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to act on behalf of the City to execute the Niagara Falls Review Agreement Extension to coordinate Advertising Services at City arenas, Gale Centre and Chippawa Arena. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY City Council, Report R&C-2017-19 approved the renewal of the Gale Centre license agreement with the Niagara Falls Review for advertising services for a 2 year term. The Licensee wishes to extend the license for a further one year. BACKGROUND In August, 2015 the City granted the Licensee an exclusive license to use certain space on various surfaces at the Gale Centre and Chippawa Arena for the display of advertising signs for a term of two years from August 1, 2015. The City renewed the license for a further 2 years commencing on August 1, 2017, and ending July 31, 2019. The Licensee wishes to extend the license for a further one year. The Niagara Falls Review pays a set fee each year plus a percentage of annual sales. ANALYSIS/RATIONALE The Gale Centre, four pad arena opened June, 2010. The Advertising Services agreement provides revenue for the arena at no additional labour expense. Page 119 of 192 2 R&C-2019-15 July 16, 2019 FINANCIAL/STAFFING/LEGAL IMPLICATIONS The Niagara Falls Review Advertising Agreement provides an annual revenue of approximately $50,000 to the Gale Centre operations budget. CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT Financial Stability, Committed to be financially responsible to the residents of Niagara Falls by practicing prudent fiscal management of existing resources. The non -tax revenue assists in reducing the Gale Centre operating budget. Recommended by: Kathy Moldenhauer, Director of Recreation and Culture Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer Page 120 of 192 TS-2019-22 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council City of Niagara Falls, Ontario SUBMITTED BY: Transportation Services Department SUBJECT: TS-2019-22 Inter-municipal Transit Coordinating Committee Update: Establishment of Common Fare Structure RECOMMENDATION That Council approve a common Region wide fare structure and strategy, effective January 1, 2021 as provided herein. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Niagara Transit Service Delivery and Governance Strategy, 2017 identified the shortfalls of the current overall fare system(s), and recommended that a harmonization of a common fare structure and fare payment technology platform must be undertaken by the Region of Niagara and transit providers as a key enabler to meeting the goal of providing a connective and integrated transit system in Niagara. Discussion by the Intermunicipal Transit Working Group (IMTWG) regarding a common fare strategy has been underway since 2018. A preferred strategy that balances customer focus, cost and impact to riders and all systems is being recommended now to the governing bodies of all transit systems within Niagara. The common fare strategy is to be implemented on January 1, 2021 with the support of a to-be-determined preferred fare-payment technology. BACKGROUND Systems across Niagara currently have a number of their own rates and criteria for transit fares and fare media products that are distinct to their systems. To continue to work towards the objective of bringing consistency and transferability between all systems to fruition, the IMTWG has identified a 2-phase approach to implementing a common fare strategy. The initial harmonization of the fare structures will be supported by the initiation of the technology required to enable seamless travel. The IMTWG are working toward the objective of bringing consistency across the existing systems regarding fare media (i.e. monthly passes, 10-ride cards, etc.). This also means systems would define their fare media and rider segments using the same categories (i.e. adult (18-64), senior (65+), student (12-18), child (12-under) etc.). Page 121 of 192 2 TS-2019-22 July 16, 2019 Aligning the fare charged in each category would result in consistency among the local systems. There is also the consideration that local Councils may still elect to allow for unique municipal exemptions; however there exists a significant opportunity to enable most fare media products and associated fare structure to be fully aligned. This alignment and associated operational and financial impacts are being advanced by the IMTWG to calculate the impact of these policy decisions on the respective local transit authorities. Ultimately these decisions to adopt align and deploy ay fare structure or product changes all require the full consent of the respective local Councils or transit authorities to implement. Regarding fare payment technology, the IMTWG has been working within the parameters of the Investing in Canada Infrastructure Program (ICIP) to align requests. Although not precisely defined at this time, the premise is that all systems would acquire and adopt the same fare payment technology using these external ICIP funding sources to assist in the harmonization of a preferred integrated are payment option. This could include mobile ticketing, on-board fare payment technology, smartcard fare payment, and /or other related hardware and software supports for next generation fare payment. This would accelerate the improved rider experience of a common fare payment technology and assist with the seamless movement of riders across Niagara. Additionally, the IMTWG is engaging with PRESTO (the fare payment solution used by Metrolinx) to learn more about the capital, operational and process requirements of that program. These changes will require support from all the local councils and successful ICIP applications across transit systems. Assuming all the necessary approvals and funding are achieved the proposed harmonized fare structure and fare payment technology solution could be ready for deployment in 2021. This ambitious timeframe would include requisite Council/Commission approvals, public notification, selection, acquisition and installation of preferred fare payment technology and deployment. This would represent a significant achievement in the operational integration of transit systems in Niagara. ANALYSIS/RATIONALE Changes from the current Niagara Falls Transit Services fare structure are outlined below in Table 1 and are as follows:  Cash Fares (Senior & Student (13-19 in High school) and Child (6-12)) – To be increased from $2.75 and $1.75 respectively to a single cash are of $3.00.  Day Passes – To be increased from $7.00 to $8.00.  Adult Monthly Pass – To be increased from $80.00 to $90.00  Semester Pass – To be increased from $260.00 to $275.00. Page 122 of 192 3 TS-2019-22 July 16, 2019 10-Ride passes would be further discounted offsetting increases to increased cash fares for riders. The cost of purchasing discounted monthly pass fare products for Seniors/ VIPs and Students would remain the same. While the proposed common fare structure considers all the major fare categories there are other fare policies that still must be agreed upon and there is understanding among the group that there may be municipalities that have concession fare options that are outside of the common fare structure. Outstanding discussion items include:  Transfer Policy(ies)  Children 12 & ride free  Veteran’s Pass  Family Pass (St Catharines Transit fare promotion) Once consensus is reached on these items, they will be brought to Council for review and approval. Table 1 FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS To demonstrate impacts to fare revenues, Table 2 has been provided below with 2017 fare product sales numbers to show expected results. Even though there are losses in the 10-Ride fare product category to get to an integrated product across all systems, these losses are negated in the overall increase. Niagara Falls St. Catharines Welland Average Fare January 1, 2021 Price Percentage Change of Proposed Price Over Average Cash Fare - Adult 3.00$ 3.00$ 3.00$ 3.00$ 3.00$ 0% Cash Fare - Senior 2.75$ 3.00$ 3.00$ 2.92$ 3.00$ 3% Cash Fare - Student 2.75$ 2.50$ 3.00$ 2.75$ 3.00$ 9% Cash Fare - Child 1.75$ 2.50$ 1.50$ 1.92$ 3.00$ Day Pass 7.00$ 8.00$ n/a 7.50$ 8.00$ 7% 10 Ride - Adult 28.00$ 26.00$ 25.00$ 26.33$ 27.00$ 3% 10 Ride - Senior 25.00$ 20.00$ 21.00$ 22.00$ 22.50$ 2% 10 Ride - Student 25.00$ 22.50$ 22.00$ 23.17$ 22.50$ -3% Monthly Pass - Adult 80.00$ 92.00$ 85.00$ 85.67$ 90.00$ 5% Monthly Pass - Senior 65.00$ 57.00$ 65.00$ 62.33$ 65.00$ 4% Monthly Pass - Student 65.00$ 62.00$ 75.00$ 67.33$ 65.00$ -3% Community Living / ODSP 65.00$ 72.00$ 76.00$ 71.00$ 65.00$ -8% Family Pass n/a 8.00$ n/a Semester Pass 260.00$ 290.00$ n/a 275.00$ 275.00$ 0% 1.5%Average Increase Across All Fare Categories Page 123 of 192 4 TS-2019-22 July 16, 2019 From a budgetary point of view the fares structure changes result in a net gain for the City. There has not been a Niagara Falls Transit Services fare increase since July 1, 2017. This increase would become effective January 1, 2021 and represents a combined increase of 1.5% over all transit systems. Table 2 Niagara Falls Proposed Price 2017 Sales (# of passes or ridecards or trips, not $) Gain/(Loss) Cash Fare - Adult $ 3.00 $ 3.00 164,365 None Cash Fare - Senior $ 2.75 $ 3.00 31,501 $ 7,875.25 Cash Fare - Student $ 2.75 $ 3.00 17,531 $ 4,382.75 Day Pass $ 7.00 $ 8.00 2,678 $ 2,678.00 10 Ride - Adult $ 28.00 $ 27.00 19,175 -$ 19,175.00 10 Ride - Senior $ 25.00 $ 22.50 6,656 -$ 16,640.00 10 Ride - Student $ 25.00 $ 22.50 2,308 -$ 5,770.00 Monthly Pass - Adult $ 80.00 $ 90.00 6,887 $ 68,870.00 Monthly Pass - Senior $ 65.00 $ 65.00 2,193 None Monthly Pass - Student $ 65.00 $ 65.00 1,709 None Semester Pass $ 260.00 $ 275.00 106 $ 1,590.00 Total $ 43,811.00 CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT This adheres to the City’s strategic commitment related to Convenient, Accessible and Sustainable Transportation to strengthen public transit linkages between the municipalities to assist in the movement of people for employment and education opportunities. Recommended by: Karl Dren, Director of Transportation Services Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer CES Page 124 of 192 TS-2019-23 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Transportation Services Department SUBJECT: TS-2019-23 WEGO Advertising Contract Renewal - Adfuel Media Inc. RECOMMENDATION 1. That the current Agreement with Adfuel Media Inc. (formerly REV Publishing Inc.) be renewed for two years and, 2. That the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to execute the necessary agreement. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Adfuel Media Inc. (formerly REV Publishing Inc.) is the current agency utilizing the WEGO system to generate revenues for the City by selling advertisements within the WEGO fleet on the infotainment monitors, as well as the interior cards displayed above the seating area. In addition to these forms of revenue sources for the City, Adfuel Media Inc. distributes several magazines within the hospitality sector, which all feature WEGO transportation advertisements that inform and encourage the reader to utilize the system while enjoying their stay. The City benefits from this relationship both financially, as well as through increased exposure to the visitors through the publications. Adfuel Media have expressed interest in renewing the current Agreement for 2 years. Staff are supportive of this initiative. BACKGROUND The WEGO system relies on its stakeholder partners to assist in marketing the system and the substantial in-kind compensation provided by the relationship with Adfuel Media Inc. is of significant value. Adfuel’s in-room magazines, including; On The Boulevard Magazine, Today Magazine and the Save-A-Buck Coupon Booklet provide the WEGO system a substantial opportunity to further broadcast its many transportation advantages to all visitors. With additional products to sell its clients, Adfuel can better package media buys, including our Infotainment monitors, which provide a unique medium to promote Niagara Falls businesses and events via video productions shown to the customers on the buses. Page 125 of 192 2 TS-2019-23 July 16, 2019 ANALYSIS/RATIONALE The initial RFP only generated one proponent; therefore it is recommended that the City renew the contract to the mutual benefit of both parties. Adfuel Media Inc. have demonstrated a level of expertise with the Niagara Falls marketplace and the exceptional marketing opportunity through in-kind publication advertisements is of great value to the continued promotion of the WEGO system. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Estimated revenue generated will be approximately $15,400 per year, plus value added compensation in excess of $125,000, in kind, advertising the WEGO Transportation system through various advertising avenues. CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT This initiative is supported by Council’s Strategic Priorities, which include a safe, accessible, convenient, integrated and fiscally responsible transportation system. Recommended by: Karl Dren, Director of Transportation Services Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer Page 126 of 192 PBD-2019-44 July 16, 2019 REPORT TO: Mayor James M. Diodati and Members of Municipal Council SUBMITTED BY: Planning, Building & Development SUBJECT: PBD-2019-44 AM-2019-013, City Initiated Zoning By-law Amendment Derelict Dwellings in the City’s Tourist Core RECOMMENDATIONS 1. That Council approve the City initiated amendment to Zoning By-law No. 79-200 to apply a site specific Tourist Commercial (TC) zone to the lands for two years that permits the zoning of a property to be changed to Deferred Tourist Commercial (DTC) if any dwelling located on it is demolished and landscaped open space is established on the property; and 2. That Council pass the related amending by-law appearing in tonight’s agenda. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The presence of abandoned or deteriorated dwellings in a portion of the City’s tourist core has been a concern of Council due to the negative impacts they have on surrounding uses. In 2017, Council passed By-law No. 2017-62, which applied a site specific Tourist Commercial (TC-1047) zone to a portion of the lands in the City’s tourist core that enabled the zoning of a property to be changed to Deferred Tourist Commercial (DTC) provided any dwelling on it had been removed and landscaped open space has been established on the property. By-law 2017-62 expired on June 13, 2017. While the by-law was in effect three derelict dwellings were demolished and replaced with landscaped open space. These properties have since been reassessed as vacant residential land. Staff recommend that by-law regulations be established for another two years to allow properties to be rezoned and reassessed with the removal of derelict dwellings and the establishment of landscaped open space for the following reasons:  Numerous dwellings remain in the tourist core that are either abandoned or deteriorated which creates an undesirable impression for tourists;  The proposed zoning complies with Official Plan policies which encourage the removal of non-conforming uses that have an impact on the general amenity of the surrounding area; and Page 127 of 192 2 PBD-2019-44 July 16, 2019  It is hoped that the DTC zoning and resulting reassessment will be an incentive to the owners of properties containing derelict dwellings to remove them and thereby create a more favourable and attractive environment in the tourist core. BACKGROUND In 1967, the City adopted an Official Plan (Amendment No. 28) for the section of Niagara Falls north of the Welland River. Amendment No. 28 anticipated a significant expansion of tourist attractions in the City. To accommodate the antici pated tourist uses, a large area in the vicinity of the Central Tourist District, consisiting of residential and industrial uses, was designated Tourist Commercial. This designation was carried through to the current Official Plan, approved in 1993. In conformity with this designation, By-law No. 79-200, passed in 1979, zoned most of this land Tourist Commercial (TC). The development of tourist commercial uses has been slower than originally anticipated, and a number of dwellings remain in the area to this day. The Tourist Commercial zoning has been a disincentive to demolishing the dwellings because the properties would be assessed as vacant commercial land if the dwellings were removed. As a result, some of the dwellings have been abandoned and boarded up, or have experienced a significant level of deterioration. These deteriorated dwellings have a negative impact on surrounding complying uses and create an unfavourable impression of the area for visitors. In 2017, Council passed Zoning By-law No.2017-62 which applied a site specific Tourist Commercial (TC) zone to the lands shown on Schedule 1. Th is site specific TC zone enabled the zoning of a property to be automatically changed to Deferred Tourist Commercial (DTC) upon the removal of the dwelling exisitng on the property on the date of the passage of the amending by-law and replacing it with landscaped open space. This site specific TC zone was in effect for 2 years and expired on June 13, 2019. While the zoning was in effect 3 derelict dwellings were removed and replaced with landscaped open space. The affected properties have been reassessed as vacant residential land and now improve the appearance of the area. Proposal The City is proposing to restablish the regulations of By-law No. 2017-62 for the lands illustrated on Schedule 1 for another two years. The regulations will enable the zoning of any property in the area to be automatically changed to Deferred Tourist Commercial (DTC) upon the removal of the dwelling existing on the property and the establishment of landscaped open space. Like By-law No. 2017-62, the site specific TC zone is proposed to be in effect for two years. The removal of the dwelling and changing the zoning of the property to DTC will result in the property being reasses sed as vacant residential land rather than commercial. The proposed zoning is intended to provide an incentive to property owners to remove derelict dwellings and thereby improve the appearance of the tourist core. Page 128 of 192 3 PBD-2019-44 July 16, 2019 Site Conditions and Surrounding Land Uses A significant portion of the tourist core located north of Ferry Street, between the hydro corridor and Victoria Street, is occupied by dwellings. Most of these dwellings appear to be in good repair and much of the area is a fairly stable residential neighbourhood. Nevertheless, a number of properties, shown on Schedule 1 and located along Stanley Avenue, north of Spring Street, on the north side of Kitchener Street at Buchanan Avenue and on Magdalan Street between McGrail Avenue and Lewis Avenue, are occupied by dwellings having a significant level of disrepair or abandonment. The portion of the tourist core located south of Ferry Street was once a substantial residential community, similar to the area north of Ferry Street. However several large scale tourist commercial developments have reduced this community to small clusters of dwellings, particularly along Robinson Street, Peer Street at Allendale Avenue, Fallsview Avenue and Main Street at Allendale Avenue. Within this area, 7 dwellings have recently been removed, 3 as a result of the passing of By-law No. 2017-62 and 4 to accommodate a parking lot expansion. While some of the remaining dwellings appear to be in good repair, others have deteriorated. As this area is frequented by tourists, these deteriorated dwellings may have an impact on visitors’ perception of the City. Circulation Comments Information about the requested Zoning By-law amendments was circulated to City divisions, the Region, agencies, and the public (through the newspaper and individual circulation to owners of the affected properties) for comments. The following summarizes the comments received to date:  Regional Municipality of Niagara  No objections from a Regional or Provincial perspective.  Municipal Works, Parks Design, Transportation Services, Enbridge  No objections. Neighbourhood Open House A neighbourhood open house was held on June 17, 2019. No affected owners attended to hear about the proposed extension of the zoning provisions or to provide comments. ANALYSIS 1. Official Plan The subject lands are designated Tourist Commercial in the City’s Official Plan and are part of the Central Tourist District. The lands are intended to be developed for a variety of tourist serving uses. The area north of Ferry Street is part of the Clifton Hill Tourist Subdistrict; the policies recognize the substantial amount of housing west of Victoria Street and notes discretion is to be exercised Page 129 of 192 4 PBD-2019-44 July 16, 2019 in phasing tourist development in this area to minimize impacts on existing land uses. The dwellings in the subject area are legal non-conforming and are intended to be replaced with conforming tourist serving uses over time. The Official Plan states that where a legal non-conforming uses seriously affect the general amenity of the surrounding area, consideration will be given to removing the use, particularly where public health is affected. The proposed by-law to facilitate the removal of derelict dwellings in the tourist core conforms to the Official Plan as follows: - the proposed by-law complies with the intent of the Legal Non -Conforming Use policies in seeking the removal of uses that have an impact on surrounding, conforming uses; - the removal of derelict dwellings will improve the amenity and attractiveness of the area; and - removal of the dwellings may assist in the assembly of lands for complying tourist serving redevelopment in the future. 2. Zoning By-law Schedule 1 illustrates the lands subject to the proposed by-law. The lands are zoned Tourist Commercial (TC) in accordance with Zoning By-law No. 79-200. The Schedule specifically identifies a number of properties north of Ferry Street with deteriorated dwellings on them. As the dwellings south of Ferry Street are scattered among tourist developments, the Schedule has identified blocks where dwellings are located. Although this Schedule includes lands with tourist commercial uses on them, the provisions of the proposed by-law will have no effect on properties which do not have a dwelling located on them. The proposed by-law will place the lands under a site specific TC zone for a period of two years. If there is a dwelling on a property and the dwelling is removed and the property is landscaped or grassed, the property will be automatically rezoned Deferred Tourist Commercial (DTC). The DTC zone limits the use of a property to an existing lawful use and accessory uses, including a home occupation, and a single detached dwelling. The proposed by-law is appropriate for the following reasons: - The properties on which 3 dwellings were demolished and replaced with landscaped were reassessed as vacant residential, and the owner now pays less property tax. Therefore it is anticipated that the zoning change to DTC will enable the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC) to continue to reassess the lands as vacant residential once dwellings are removed. The lower assessment should provide an incentive to owners to remove derelict dwellings; Page 130 of 192 5 PBD-2019-44 July 16, 2019 - Some of the dwellings in the subject area are being maintained. The zoning maintains the option for owners to repair or renovate derelict dwellings if they do not wish to demolish them. If a dwelling is repaired or maintained and not demolished, the TC zoning will remain; - To assist in providing an attractive appearance, the by-law will require landscaped open space to be established on the property once the dwelling is removed. If the property is used for a commercial use such as a parking lot the TC zoning will remain; and - The two year extension provides additional time for owners to decide whether to repair derelict dwellings or demolish them. If a property is rezoned DTC and the owner wants to use the property for commercial purposes, the owner will need to submit a zoning by-law amendment to rezone the property back to TC. With this approach the City is working with the owners of derelict dwellings to demolish them. However, if the owners do not take advantage of the proposed zoning by removing the dwelling within the two year window, it will be necessary to enforce the Property Standards By-law to have the dwellings repaired or demolished. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Where dwellings are demolished and the properties are reassessed as vacant residential, the City will collect lower taxes than if the properties were assessed as vacant commercial. CITY’S STRATEGIC COMMITMENT Although the proposal does not specifically relate to any of the City’s Strategic Initiatives, the removal of derelict dwellings will improve the appearance of the tourist core and help provide a positive impression of the City for visitors. LIST OF ATTACHMENTS  Schedule 1 – Location Map Recommended by: Alex Herlovitch, Director of Planning, Building & Development Respectfully submitted: Ken Todd, Chief Administrative Officer A.Bryce:cr Attach. S:\PDR\2019\PBD-2019-43, AM-2019-013, Zoning By-law Amendment, Derelict Dwellings in the Tourist Core.docx Page 131 of 192 6 PBD-2019-44 July 16, 2019 SCHEDULE 1 Page 132 of 192 Rtt Community ServicesN Re Legislative Services June 18,2019 File#120203 Sent via email: Regional Councillor's Group Email Niagara Regional Councillors Support of Auditor General's Recommendations - Niagara Peninsula Gonservation Authority The Municipal Council of the Town of Fort Erie at its meeting of June 17,2019 passed the following resolution: Whereas the Auditor General of Ontario's Special Audit of the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority made 24 recommendations, the third of which recommended that members of the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority (NPCA) Board of Directors collectively have the skills, experience and training necessary to oversee the NPCA's activities effectively, and Whereas the Town of Fort Erie recommended Leah Feor as their Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority representative, an individualwith an extensive background in accounting, business ethics and environmental sustainability, who was appointed to the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority Board of Directors by Regional Council on May 16,2019, and Whereas voters on October 22,2018 expressed a strong desire for transparent and accountable governance within the Regional Municipality of Niagara and its local area municipalities; Now therefore be it resolved, That: Council directs staff to prepare a report outlining policies for the recruitment and recommendation of individuals for appointment to the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority Board of Directors, and further That: the Town of Fort Erie requests that The Regional Municipality of Niagara provide recommendations with respect to specific qualifications and/or skills to the Town of Fort Erie to be considered for incorporation into our own recruitment policy, and further Our Focus: Your Future Web-site: www.forterie.ca t2 Mailing Address: The Corporation of the Town of Fort Erie 1 Municipal Centre Drive, Fort Erie ON L2A 256 Office Hours 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Phone: (905) 871-1600 FAX: (905) 871-4022 Page 133 of 192 Niagara Regional Councillors Page two That: The Town of Fort Erie requests other Local Area Municipalities within the Regional Municipality of Niagara, as well as the City of Hamilton and Haldimand County, to create similar policies that address the unique needs of their municipality if they have not already done so, and further That: The Town of Fort Erie requests that Niagara Regional Council create policies that respect and support decisions made by local area municipalities regarding their recommendations for appointments to the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority Board of Directors, and further That: This resolution be circulated to Niagara Regional Council, LocalArea Municipalities within The Regional Municipality of Niagara, the City of Hamilton, and Haldimand County. Thank you for your attentio this very important issue ,"rW Carol Schofie Dipl.M.A I Manager, Legislative Services/Clerk cschofi eld@forterie.ca c.c Local Area Municipalities Sent via email Ann-Marie Norio, Regional Clerk Sent via email: ann-marie.norio@niagararegion.ca Rose Caterini, City Clerk, City of Hamilton Senf via email: clerk@hamilton.ca Evelyn Eichenbaum, Clerk, Haldimand County Sent via email: eeichenbaum@haldimandcounty.on.ca Page 134 of 192 June 19, 2019 Sent via email Re: Resolution - Free Menstrual Products at City Facilities At its meeting held on June 10, 2019, St. Catharines City Council approved the following motion: WHEREAS people who menstruate need adequate and appropriate access to menstrual products so that they can experience their full health potential, maintain dignity and participate fully in community; and WHEREAS according to Plan Canada International study, one-third of Canadian women under the age of 25 struggled to afford menstrual products; and WHEREAS the inability to afford menstrual products is a health equity issue; and WHEREAS there is a need for low or no cost menstrual products; and WHEREAS menstruating is a natural bodily function, and access to menstrual products is as necessary as access to toilet paper; and WHEREAS universal access to menstrual products contributes to the normalization of menstruation and enhanced access in a dignified way; and WHEREAS other Canadian cities, including London and Sarnia are already piloting and/or assessing the feasibility of menstrual product access programs; and WHEREAS recreation centres and libraries service a large population, diverse in age and socioeconomic status; and WHEREAS public-facing City of St. Catharines facilities can be accessed by all members of the community at no cost; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the City of St. Catharines work towards providing free menstrual products (pads and tampons) in all public-facing municipally-run facilities in the following ways: …/2 Page 135 of 192 1. That staff report back to Council outlining options and costs for a pilot project that would offer menstrual products in select recreation centres and library locations; 2. That the evaluation of the pilot project also include qualitative data from people using the products; 3. That the results of the pilot project inform the feasibility of expanding the provision of free menstrual products in all public-facing municipal buildings; 4. That if passed, the Clerk's Office notify all school boards and municipalities in Ontario of the City of St. Catharines' initiative and encourage them to do the same. This resolution, passed by our Council on June 10, 2019, is being forwarded to you for your consideration and support. Please consider forwarding this to your local school board. If you have any questions, please contact the Office of the City Clerk at extension 1524. Bonnie Nistico-Dunk, City Clerk Legal and Clerks Services, Office of the City Clerk :em Page 136 of 192 1 Heather Ruzylo To:Heather Ruzylo Subject: Communication Item: By-law variance and noise - Night of Art From: Clark Bernat <cbernat@niagarafalls.ca> Sent: Thursday, June 20, 2019 5:56 PM To: Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca> Cc: Maria Artiga < > Subject: By-law variance and noise Bill, hoping to get the following onto the July 16 Council meeting agenda. Need the noise and by-law waived for the Night of Art again this year. Let me know if you need anything else. Thanks. Whereas Niagara Falls Night of Art is an annual event where various art forms come together on one night to showcase the best of Niagara artistic talent on September 19th, 2019 and Whereas this is the eighth year that the Niagara Falls Museums has hosted this event Whereas the event is expected to attract 600-1000 audience members from across Southern Ontario and Western New York Whereas this event will support and promote the artistic talents of residents of Niagara Falls and the Niagara Region and Whereas to obtain a Special Occasion Liquor License from the Alcohol & Gaming Commission of Ontario (AGCO), the event requires a resolution of Council recognizing it as a public event of municipal significance. Therefore be it resolved that Niagara Falls City Council grants the Niagara Falls History Museum relief to the City’s Noise By-law to allow entertainment until 11:00 pm Clark Bernat | Culture & Museums Manager | Recreation & Culture | City of Niagara Falls 5810 Ferry Street | Niagara Falls, ON L2G 1S9 | (905) 356-7521 ext 5906 | Fax 905-358-0920 | cbernat@niagarafalls.ca Follow the Museums, Culture & Farmers’ Market on social media And sign up for our newsletters at https://niagarafalls.ca/newsletters/default.aspx Page 137 of 192 1 Heather Ruzylo To:Heather Ruzylo Subject:RE: Jul 16th: Communication item: Bridgewater Street Parking-Chippawa From: Paul Brown <pbrown@niagarafalls.ca> Sent: Friday, June 21, 2019 2:24 PM To: Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca>; Mathew Bilodeau <mbilodeau@niagarafalls.ca>; John Grubich <jgrubich@niagarafalls.ca> Subject: RE: Bridgewater Street Parking-Chippawa These individuals have met with us earlier this week and (on the direction of the mayor) circulated a petition to allow the use of the boulevard. It was recommended that the letter be addressed to the Clerks office in care of City Council and the Mayor. Paul Brown | Manager of Parking Services | Transportation Services | City of Niagara Falls 7150 Montrose Road, Unit 1 | Niagara Falls, ON L2H 3N3 | (905) 356-7521 ext 5203 | Fax 905-356-7404 | pbrown@niagarafalls.ca From: Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca> Sent: June 21, 2019 2:20 PM To: Mathew Bilodeau <mbilodeau@niagarafalls.ca>; Paul Brown <pbrown@niagarafalls.ca>; John Grubich <jgrubich@niagarafalls.ca> Subject: FW: Bridgewater Street Parking-Chippawa Gentlemen, I forwarded the hard copy of the letter/petition/pictures that I received today to John. The attached is the same, minus the pictures. This was not addressed to Council and there is no ask that it go to Council, so at this time I think it should just be addressed from a staff level. Bill Matson | City Clerk | Director of Clerks Services | City of Niagara Falls 4310 Queen Street | Niagara Falls, ON L2E 6X5 | (905) 356-7521 ext 4342 | Fax 905-356-9083 | billmatson@niagarafalls.ca From: McKinley, Mary Ann < > Sent: Friday, June 21, 2019 11:19 AM To: Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca> Subject: Bridgewater Street Parking-Chippawa CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of Niagara Falls email system. Use caution when clicking links or opening attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Mr. Bill Matson: Page 138 of 192 2 I have enclosed a letter regarding our concerns about the parking on Bridgewater Street in Chippawa. We met with Mr. Paul Brown and Mr. Mathew Bilodeau regarding this issue. I have also enclosed a petition stating that the majority of residence would like to park on the boulevard/gravel areas of the road. I will drop off a package for you at city hall which includes the pictures. Thank you for your consideration Mary-Ann Mckinley Karl Burger Rob Booth Samantha Booth Please consider the environment before printing this email. This email, including any attachments, is the property of the Niagara Catholic District School Board. This information is intended only for the use of the individual to whom, or entity to which, it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under the Municipal Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you received this transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately and then permanently delete this message. Page 139 of 192 EzmNo:_.Ba _<_«.._<_m.nmo: _Q2Qmln z._mmm3$59.2Im $3Otmm:mimmn z?mmqw3.50:319 _.mmas Ummz._<_«.E:_<_m~moE_<<m:5wmmamzmowm«amm<<m»m1m?mm$:uvo29mcmm2":6uo:_m<m&\m$<m_m1mm.ongmson:«am 2,.mwammémnmwm?mmvn:.6um<<m31Emuz?omm2umzasmumam:mnngamsnm2:::5Q2om zmmmmqm3%3-53.. W. :5SunazmloénoaumamaaoBmimwQ2m?mmamznEm:m<m>_.<<><mumawmg1:3Ema8mzmcwm .mm..m.2cm0.33m:<m_.mmmEm:mmvmgmmimzm0:armmnwmm?95.8somam<<m=$. <<m«mm.:5nsmzmmEm:sawSéommgEgo:cmSm¢_m.m:m«3.03:5Q23z?mma,mw=m3:8_<_m<w..~89mm”m:n_mm<<m.nm..mqmmn_3uo:m33:53cvgm?_m204:mnmmmm2mag55:5o:_<mag8$32.no:nm3m.m3m«mm:o<<mZn_mmmen:mm>3c:_m:nm‘voznmmammwm?cnxmSosa:3cmmEm..Bmm» "Edam:2wmzazmsawamamza8Sm>mu:m:.<<_3m_.Bazemzmznm29.3nmcmm33:9m%m.2wmcmm mmm:o<<EocmsmEssa:m<m.8momacaa<mEn_mmnmcmimm_._o<<Q1333m3Em=m3am3mgozom. W.«rm<m§n_mmmam323. M.3magic:3.?.mmmzn.32...m1o_mm<<m.nmwmama.8?rmnc_-n_m-mmnsm<mEn_mmany:3m__<m_.:n_mmmm:,_um_+o_.3mu_.oum_.wuoi?cqzmo:5nqmmdmmm3532<oE3mo3_,mm_n_,m<maSmman.E3._:mm:.O::n_3_Emm_1m<m_m1mm..:;mammmmmé8:83amnmcmmumamm?zmzmmamon:5mama95nosomEm<<m=G. M3.3%m?zmanR:5wagon.1movzmmaw1amm<<m~nm_,Snznmzsm523E12o.m<$ammo.Eam.B._.2.9.5wmmzz3.92m«<o_:3m9"ma?a.w<m=o<s:mumon_m.8um}omEmm?mmw<2:m:m:_.mm _ wmmamz?m_mumwcmm?m.8mm:"m_<mao<Em<<mnm_+B:.nmamm. . <<m:m<mm:n_o.n.mn_mamnionEaEnE_.mm3%m:o<<?rmamios.33mag:92<mEn_mm3%Swami. _ magmmqsnm<mEn.mwam;335>mu:m:onEm_§__m§a.8m__o<<3:.<m§n_mmmamcmumm?mzmao mmmm_<cmm:583. , 15%<0:3..<o:_\nosmmmmaz\..._<,o.:_.m.2:_<.. \\§..\....\..\\lh.lI1... \. _<_m«+5:_<_n§_w_< .31mcqmmq. ,waswoo;/;_ mm3m3:mmoon: nno2....3::W..O<< _<_«._<_m.3m<<wzonmmc Page 140 of 192 Z§mm:.m.~u:=m . . L . o>2>.v> _<_m<w.M08 . Dmmam1anm<<m..m~mxmm«mmimzn mm”w._%_2§§m.:o2I_3vo:m:.n_um_.E:m.cuaam 0:520322QmzmaaosAOUQsmmmc?ozmmaEm9.22zmmmmam_um=m8mimqmm5.3.8 madam:5umzazmmagm?owmmm9"<mEo_mw.¢m=m«w_omz?mammza2.558onEmQmmmma mqmm.mmmn_<_mma_3%mm9.._::m._.no.5.m:<<mEo_w93mmUmqxma0:3,».3::_o:um_ _oo:_m<m_dmznto?mammmmwmmU?ozmim.8@5513»0.29O_u®EomzmmUmlasmzoxm? man3m<cmmcgmo?.88<s:m._u1<m.mom:um?o:m:o_mm<<m.§.mqmmn_u3<EmaEm:m: mEu=omEmU<._m<<mmammazmqma8.9:Em<mEo_m:mm3cmm:._:m_<o:Emmmusmzmcnmom.H_ .... m._.:_w5.:mzmimm:Emamimmagocwm?m8m9nm_<m3o<3m<<m.mm_+8:.nmqmm. _:<0::m<mmwnmo.om_.§:oao3Em=.:o_.:m<mmmmsmvaumzasm33:5.<0:om:mm:9: umzaam0032.2oaomma89$magmamx?mzmwosmmom_o¢2<mm::630:69.98ms...mag 98v.3;_<_o:Qm<8352.OimamQEmmm:o_.:wEmmmmom:$5wmm;mam.mmmasmmq 53umqazmoo::o_o3.om«w<<_=amwuoza8oo3_o_m3.nmmagm3o8m3m3<5:Ummvvzma :a<m«mm=<_man:2Hmnmm?mg8wvmoao<mEo_mm. :<o::m<mm:<ncmmmosmoo:om33mEaEmma:Emmmm..mm_2%.8ooimo?Em::Qm_.m6:ma. <oSm4.2? oo.19:w8<<:__<_m:mmmaowUmizmmmwsomm .‘M...._._.m:muo_Am:o:mmnsnmm <<o1=:mHommuvma8m2<m05oo==:::5~ma3:ma8m.§,m?m .E_,:En:@ammm_.mam__m.nm _“_,__Page 141 of 192 Administration Office of the Regional Clerk 1815 Sir Isaac Brock Way, PO Box 1042, Thorold, ON L2V 4T7 Telephone: 905-685-4225 Toll-free: 1-800-263-7215 Fax: 905-687-4977 www.niagararegion.ca June 25, 2019 CL 11-2019, June 20, 2019 PEDC 6-2019, June 12, 2019 PDS 21-2019, June 12, 2019 DISTRIBUTION LIST SENT ELECTRONICALLY 2018 End of Year Growth Report PDS 21-2019 Regional Council, at its meeting held on June 20, 2019, passed the following recommendation of its Planning and Economic Development Committee: That Report PDS 21-2019, dated June 12, 2019, respecting 2018 End Of Year Growth Report, BE RECEIVED and CIRCULATED to the Local Area Municipalities, Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority, Niagara Home Builders Association, Niagara Industrial Association, local Chambers of Commerce and School Boards. A copy of PDS 21-2019 is enclosed for your reference. Yours truly, Ann-Marie Norio Regional Clerk :jg CLK-C 2019-115 Distribution List Local Area Municipalities Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority Niagara Home Builders Association Niagara Industrial Association Local Chambers of Commerce Local School Boards G. Bowie, Planner N. Oakes, Executive Assistant to the Commissioner, Planning & Development Services R. Mostacci, Commissioner, Planning and Development Services Page 142 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 1 Subject: 2018 End Of Year Growth Report Report to: Planning and Economic Development Services Committee Report date: Wednesday, June 12, 2019 Recommendations 1. That Report PDS 21-2019 BE RECEIVED for information; and 2. That a copy of Report PDS 21-2019 BE CIRCULATED to the Local Area Municipalities, Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority, Niagara Home Builders Association, Niagara Industrial Association, local Chambers of Commerce and School Boards. Key Facts  The purpose of this report is to inform Planning and Economic Development Services Committee and Council about 2018 growth and development trends in Niagara Region.  Population growth in 2018 was greater than any year in the previous decade. In 2018, Niagara’s population increased by approximately 7,000 people (1.49% growth rate) to 472,448 people.  Data relating to Housing Starts, Completions and Building Permits show a shift towards higher density housing from single detached dwelling types.  The average sale price for all homes in Niagara increased by 3.4%, significantly lower than the unusually high 21% combined increase over 2016 and 2017.  For a second consecutive year, the total value of building permits issued in Niagara Region exceeded $1 Billion. Financial Considerations There are no direct financial implications associated with this report. Metrics in this report inform Niagara’s financial strategies. Increased residential, commercial and industrial development in Niagara, combined with increasing property assessments, has a direct impact on revenues collected by the Region. Page 143 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 2 ______________________________________________________________________ Analysis Annual Growth Report Overview Since 2017, Planning and Development Services has released Mid-Year and End-of- Year reports focused on growth and development trends in Niagara. The Growth Report represents an opportunity to update Regional Council on growth and development trends across Niagara’s communities. This report highlights trends between 2017 and 2018 related to growth in population, housing and building permits. While previous versions of the semi-annual growth report have discussed development applications and economic development trends, recent reports to Planning and Economic Development Services Committee covered both topics in detail (identified in Other Pertinent Reports as the end of this report.). Population and Housing Annual Population Estimates Niagara Region’s population has been increasing steadily since 2009 and reached an estimated population of 472,448 people as of July 1st 2018. This represents an increase of nearly 7,000 more people than 2017 and an annual growth rate of 1.49%. The Region’s annual population growth rate has increased consistently in recent years, starting at 0.02% in 2009 and reaching 1.24% in 2016, followed by 1.36% in 2017 and 1.49% in 2018. In general, the Region’s growth rate has been rising since 2014 and is required to do so until 2041 to achieve Provincial planning forecasts. Figure 1 shows the annual population estimate and associated growth rate between 2009 and 2018. Page 144 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 3 ______________________________________________________________________ Figure 1: Estimated Population and Growth Rate (2009-2018) Source: Statistics Canada, Annual Demographic Estimates: Subprovincial Areas Components of Population Growth and Demographic Trends Niagara’s population growth is driven entirely by international and intraprovincial migration. Niagara’s natural population change was a decrease of 577 people (meaning 577 more people died than were born in Niagara). The Region grew by 4,163 people from international migration and 3,567 people from intraprovincial migration. Without the benefit of international and intraprovincial migration, Niagara would be in population decline. The majority of intraprovincial migrants moving into Niagara are between the ages of 45 to 69, increasing Niagara’s median age and compounding a naturally-aging demographic. On the other hand, an even greater number of non -permanent residents in the 15 to 24 year old range are coming to Niagara. These non-permanent residents are likely attending post-secondary education institutions (Brock University and Niagara College) and leaving Niagara after completion. Figure 2 shows the age breakdown of net non-permanent residents and net intraprovincial migrants. 0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 1.40 1.60 420,000 425,000 430,000 435,000 440,000 445,000 450,000 455,000 460,000 465,000 470,000 475,000 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Growth Rate (%)PopulationYear Estimated Population and Growth Rate Population Growth Rate Page 145 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 4 ______________________________________________________________________ Figure 2: Immigration to Niagara Region by Age Cohort 2017/2018 Source: Statistics Canada. Components of population change by census division, 2016 boundaries The St. Catharines-Niagara Census Metropolitan Area (CMA), which includes most of Niagara,1 has the third highest median age (45.6) and third highest share of persons aged 65 and older amongst all CMAs in Canada (22.1%). In addition, St. Catharines- Niagara CMA has the third lowest share of persons aged 15 to 64 years of age (63.9%) – also known as the working age population. In addition, the St. Catharines-Niagara CMA had the greatest increase in median age over the past decade for Ontario (+3 years) and has increased by +1.5 years since the 2016 Census. Considering the majority of permanent intraprovincial migrants moving 1 The St. Catharines-Niagara CMA excludes Grimsby and West Lincoln. When looking at the entire Niagara Census Division (which includes all 12 local municipalities), the average age falls outside of the top 10 oldest Census Divisions in Canada. Based on the 2016 Census, the Census Division had an average age of 43.8 where as the St. Catharines – Niagara CMA had an average of 44.1. -200 0 200 400 600 800 1000 <0 0 to 4 5 to 9 10 to 14 15 to 19 20 to 24 25 to 29 30 to 34 35 to 39 40 to 44 45 to 49 50 to 54 55 to 59 60 to 64 65 to 69 70 to 74 75 to 79 80 to 84 85 to 89 90 + Number of ImmigrantsAge CohortImmigration By Age Cohort 2017/2018 Net Non-Permanent Resident Net Intraprovincial Migrant Page 146 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 5 ______________________________________________________________________ into Niagara are above 45 years of age, it is anticipated that the average age will continue to increase due to natural demographic change and migration trends. Housing Developments 2,332 dwelling units began construction in 2018 (figure 3). While this was a 4% decline compared to the 2,440 dwellings started in 2017, it is still well above the average starts between 2006 and 2015, which were less than 1,500 per year. Housing completions increased 29% to over 2,800 completed units (figure 4). This is the highest number of unit completions in over 15 years and is driven largely by medium and high density development (908 townhomes and 533 apartment units). Building permit issuance for residential units also increased 5% between 2018 and 2017 (figure 5). Again, the trend here has been a shift towards higher density development rather than single detached dwellings. Nearly 3,000 dwelling unit building permits were issued in 2018. This will result in sustained starts and completions through 2019 and beyond as higher density housing (especially apartment units) take more time to complete than lower density housing types. Figure 3: Housing Starts by Municipality (2017/2018) Source: CMHC Housing Now Report 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 Niagara Starts by Municipality -2017 and 2018 2017 Starts (All Dwelling Types)2018 Starts (All Dwelling Types) Page 147 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 6 ______________________________________________________________________ Figure 4: Housing Completions by Municipality (2017/2018) Source: CMHC Housing Now Report Figure 5: Housing Units Issued Via Building Permit by Municipality (2017/2018) Source: Niagara Region Planning and Economic Development Building Permits 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 Niagara Completions by Municipality -2017 and 2018 2017 Completions (All Dwelling Types)2018 Completions (All Dwelling Types) 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 Niagara Residential Building Permits by Municipality -2017 and 2018 2017 Building Permit Units (All Dwelling Types)2018 Building Permit Units (All Dwelling Types) Page 148 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 7 ______________________________________________________________________ Housing Diversity A notable change between 2017 and 2018 is the increase in higher density housing types. Housing starts, completions and building permits all had less than 50% share of single detached dwellings. Whereas in 2017, and for most years previously, single detached dwellings made up over 50% in those categories. The largest shift in 2018 was towards apartment units. Figure 6 highlights the one-year shift towards higher density development for Housing Starts, Housing Completions and Building Permits. Figure 6: Proportion of Housing Units by Development Stage (2017/2018) Source: CMHC Housing Now and Niagara Region Planning and Economic Development Build ing Permits Figure 7 highlights a twelve-year trend in housing completions, showing how the gap between percent of single detached households and other housing types has narrowed over time and switched in 2018. By the end of 2018, the number of high-rise units in development reached a 25-year high. As land across the Region continues to develop and housing prices continue to increase, the share of higher density development in the coming years is likely to increase. 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 2017 2018 2017 2018 2017 2018 Housing Starts Housing Completions Building Permits Single Detached Semi Detached Row/Townhouse Apartment Page 149 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 8 ______________________________________________________________________ Figure 7: Housing Completions by Housing Type (2007-2019) Source: CMHC Housing Now (2007-2018) Housing Market The average sale price for a home in Niagara continued to grow in 2018, increasing 3.4% to an average cost of $418,751. While this increase is less than the 17% increase in 2016, or the 21% increase in 2017, the increase still has a significant impact on housing affordability in Niagara, especially first-time homebuyers who are looking to enter the housing market. The two municipalities with the highest average sale price in 2017, Niagara-on-the-Lake and Grimsby, experienced a decline in average price between 2017 and 2018. The three municipalities with the lowest average sale price in 2017 (Welland, Fort Erie and Port Colborne/Wainfleet2) experienced the highest average price increase. Figure 8 highlights the average sale price and percentage change for each municipality between 2017 and 2018. 2 The Niagara Reality Association reports on Port Colborne and Wainfleet together, therefore they are listed as one in the report and in Figure 8. 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Year Housing Completions By Housing Type: Single-Detached and Other Single-Detached Households Other Housing Types Page 150 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 9 ______________________________________________________________________ Figure 8: Average Sale Price and % Change by Municipality (2017/2018) Source: Niagara Reality Associate and Reality Association of Hamilton-Burlington The number of home sales in Niagara decreased by 11% between 2017 and 2018. CMHC notes that this is likely due to the new mortgage rules as well as a cooling housing market. CMHC forecasts that sales should remain consistent in 2019 and 20203. Building Permit Values Building Permit Values Building permit values for residential and non-residential uses remained above $1 Billion for consecutive years. While building permit value for Industrial (-7.3%), Institutional (-48%) and Residential (-3.3%) all saw declines between 2017 and 2018, Commercial building permits increased 13.1%. The cumulative year-over-year decrease was -4%. Overall, $1.1 Billion worth of permits were issued in 2018.4 3 CMHC Housing Market Outlook: Central Ontario, Fall 2018. 4 This figured is calculated by taking the Statistics Canada CMA Building Permit data and adding municipally - collected data for West Lincoln and Grimsby. -10.0 -8.0 -6.0 -4.0 -2.0 0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0 10.0 12.0 $0 $100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000 $600,000 $700,000 $800,000 $900,000 % Change in Sale PriceAverage Sale Price Municipality Average Household Sale Price: 2017 and 2018 2017 2018 %Change Page 151 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 10 ______________________________________________________________________ Figure 9 highlights the changes in building permit values for residential and non - residential uses). Figure 9: Building Permit Values (2017/2018) Source: Statistics Canada, Niagara Region Planning and Economic Development Building Permits Highest Value Building Permits Issued in 2018: Below is a table showing the 10 highest non-residential building permits issued in 2018. There was a good mix between industrial, commercial and institutional/government. Developments at Innio in Welland (200 Buchner Road, formerly GE) continue to top industrial investments for the Region. Municipality Location Permit Value ($) Development Type Welland 200 Buchner Road 30,000,000 Industrial Niagara Falls 6366 Stanley Avenue 16,000,000 Commercial Port Colborne 1555 Elm Street 15,000,000 Industrial Fort Erie 2818 House Road 12,500,000 Industrial Welland 670 Tanguay Avenue 11,000,000 Institutional/Government St. Catharines 221 Glendale Avenue 10,000,000 Commercial St. Catharines 89 Meadowvale Drive 8,650,500 Commercial Fort Erie 2818 House Road 8,000,000 Commercial Niagara Falls 6650 Niagara River Parkway 8,000,000 Commercial St. Catharines 59 Church Street 8,000,000 Institutional/Government West Lincoln 177 West Street 8,000,000 Institutional/Government Source: Niagara Region Planning and Economic Development Building Permits 0 200,000,000 400,000,000 600,000,000 800,000,000 1,000,000,000 Commercial Industrial Institutional Residential Total Value ($) Building Permit Values 2018 2017 Page 152 of 192 PDS 21-2019 June 12, 2019 Page 11 ______________________________________________________________________ Alternatives Reviewed The End of Year Growth Monitoring report is meant to highlight trends in growth and development across Niagara based on the most current and complete data available. No alternatives were considered. Relationship to Council Strategic Priorities This report was prepared to show how development, and proactive planning for development, is leading towards stronger economic prosperity in our communities across the Niagara Region. Other Pertinent Reports  PDS 9-2017: Niagara Region Annual Growth Monitoring Report  PDS 25-2018: Niagara Region End of Year 2017 Growth Monitoring Report  PDS 3-2019: Development Applications Monitoring Report – 2018 Year End  ED 5-2019: Niagara Economic Update ________________________________ Prepared by: Greg Bowie Planner Planning and Development Services ________________________________ Recommended by: Rino Mostacci, MCIP, RPP Commissioner Planning and Development Services ________________________________ Submitted by: Ron Tripp, P.Eng. Acting Chief Administrative Officer This report was prepared in consultation with Isaiah Banach, Manager of Long Range Planning, Blake Landry, Ec.D. Manager, Economic Research & Analysis and reviewed by Brian Dick, MCIP, RPP, Senior Planner, Long Range Planning. Page 153 of 192 1 Heather Ruzylo To:Bill Matson Subject:RE: Mud Run Event Letter From: Phil Van Kleef < > Sent: Thursday, July 4, 2019 6:32 PM To: Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca> Subject: Re: Mud Run Event Letter Hi Bill, Its Phil from Campark Resorts. At this time I will just request a letter stating the event Zombie Mud Run Canada and the money we raise and donate to Crohns and Colitis Foundation Canada this Saturday September 7 2019 is of municipal significance. In case you need more information. We offer all registrants an extra life line for $10 which 100% of these proceeds go directly to Chrohns and Colitis research in Toronto. My wife had Ulcerative Colitis her whole life which is why we do this charity. Thank you for your support, the event is gaining in popularity and growth. Best regards, Phil Van Kleef Campark Resorts Page 154 of 192 1 Heather Ruzylo Subject:FW: Proclamation Request: Brother-Sister community Day 2019 Attachments:IMG_20190524_204020_978.jpg From: Daniel Masih < > Sent: Friday, June 28, 2019 11:45 AM To: Cathy Crabbe <ccrabbe@niagarafalls.ca>; Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca>; daniel dd. masih < > Cc: Bill Matson <billmatson@niagarafalls.ca> Subject: Re: Proclamation Request: Brother-Sister community Day 2019 CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of Niagara Falls email system. Use caution when clicking links or opening attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Thank you team Niagara for your ongoing support . I , Daniel Masih request the date of the proclamation be changed to August 15 2019 We request the same wording as the past few years. As what we try to do on this day is to bring as many people to niagara falls on the given day to enjoy fireworks and illumination while celebrating the brotherhood and sisterhood in society and the sibling relationship as well. Please enjoy the illumination picture last year. Colours were blue and pink. This year we are using Orange representing brotherhood White representing peace Green representing hope. On Jun 28, 2019 9:52 AM, "Cathy Crabbe" <ccrabbe@niagarafalls.ca> wrote: Hi Bill: I just received a call from Daniel Masih with respect to his annual request for a City Proclamation for Brother Sister Community Day. This year’s date is August 15, 2019. Page 155 of 192 2 Daniel has been advised that he needs to send his official request to you no later than July 5 in order to have it included on the July 16th Council Agenda. For your reference, and for Daniel’s I am attaching a copy of last year’s proclamation. Many thanks, Cathy Contact: Daniel Masih www.niagarafalls.ca The City of Niagara Falls Confidentiality Notice The information contained in this communication including any attachments may be confidential, is intended only for the use of the recipient(s) named above, and may be legally privileged. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, disclosure or copying of this communication, or any of its contents is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please re-send this communication to the sender and permanently delete the original and any copy from your computer system. Thank you Page 156 of 192 05_._m__ 330:3:982._u.o.max83 2.333mm=m.ozSmea <<mU£3"<<<<<<.:_mem::m__m.nm 83....$-:..§Us.33 m8:893“$-83 _.&onm:®:_mamSa.__m.ou _<_m<o_..:30.2.3. _u_»OO_.>_<_>._._OZ <<:mmm>m_w832.m_m§oo33c::<Um<_mq¢q_om$n_83m_o<wcm?émmsUqo?rmqm magmagma.magSmcoa:5:3m<:m<mm:m_.ma_miom:5:0253009mag <<:mxm>mw.o:§-m_m2oo33c::<03:mmmmoo_m_masaomsomcmomcmm; c:o_m1_:mmEmsome:Em»m<m_.<cog<m:ocE=<m33830205oomximzom2::mmo: 0:6:mag s=._mmm>m.m_.o§m7m_m8qoo33c::<Um<:mm8.6:m28.92w?siomzomo:<<<Em mm:U1:mm8@m=..m3.m3__<3m3cmqm:32ozm82mm<3:mmcaseinHoom?smqo:_Nm:m :32osm0.2“mag <<_._mmm>m.Emmom_9.w83m7m_m$?Oo33c_._:<03_m8Qmm?mn:_o__omémamzmmw2 Emn_m<man_am?siomzom8m__no33c::_mm38,6:EmBm_:o_m3m3m2_o<mmag 9062.0:..o_1m__“soosm_m_m:9:. ZO<<.qzmxmmommmm_._.mmmo_.<mo._._._>._._.<_:om>._Am3o.>036_<.m<o_._no :m$_o<_u8o_m_3>55”8.~08mm..m3=..m_.-m.w.$_,oo3=:=._:<Um<...33m0.29. Z_mom:m_um__w. >028_<_m<o«<_:omxmio m_<_m3Um_.m10.20930: >cmcm»,3.N93 Page 157 of 192 NATIONAL POLYCYSTIC KIDNEY DISEASE AWARENESS DAY September 4, 2019 WHEREAS, Polycystic kidney disease (PKD) causes abnormal cysts to develop and grow in the kidneys and the enlargement of cysts causes kidney function to decline. It equally affects men, women and children – regardless of geography or ethnic origin; and WHEREAS, the PKD Foundation of Canada is the only national charitable organization dedicated to fighting PKD, a progressive, life-threatening genetic disease, through programs of research, advocacy, education, support and awareness in order to discover vital treatments and a cure for PKD and improve the lives of all it affects; and WHEREAS, in September, walks will take place in several locations to honour friends, family and supporters impacted by PKD to help raise funds for research and improve the quality of life for those afflicted with PKD, including many (Town/City) residents; and THEREFORE, I, (Name of Mayor), Mayor of the Town / City of (Town/City Name), do hereby proclaim September 4, 2019 National Polycystic Kidney Disease Awareness Day in (Town/City Name). Page 158 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019 - A by-law to authorize the payment of $16,863,038.46 for General Purposes. THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: That the City Treasurer is hereby authorized and directed to pay the attached list of disbursements for the period from May 16 to June 26, 2019. Passed this sixteenth day of July, 2019 ..................................................... .......................................................... WILLIAM G. MATSON, JAMES M. DIODATI, CITY CLERK MAYOR First Reading: July 16, 2019 Second Reading: July 16, 2019 Third Reading: July 16, 2019 Page 159 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019 - A by-law to amend By-law No. 2002-081, being a by-law to appoint City employees, agents and third parties for the enforcement of provincial or municipal by-laws. THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1 . By-law No. 2002-081 is amended by deleting Schedules AA”, “B”, and “C” and that Schedules “A”, “B”, and “C” attached hereto shall be inserted in lieu thereof. Read a First, Second and Third time; passed, signed and sealed in open Council this 16th day of July, 2019. ............................................................... ........................................................... WILLIAM G. MATSON, CITY CLERK JAMES M. DIODATI, MAYOR Page 160 of 192 SCHEDULE “A” 1. Chief Building Official: Salvatore Valeo 2. Inspectors: Tammy Agnoletto Louie Baldinelli Rick Bayley Jim Boutilier Luciano Chieca Tom Detenbeck Frank Devereaux Effat Effat Tyler Esau Mike Formica Kellie Kubik Christel Meyer Roger Pigeon Bryan Plata Cesar Ramires Phil Ross Ellen Roupas Fred Sacco Ben Trendle Brian Sparks Jo Zambito 3. Municipal Enforcement Officers: Robert Davis Sandro Elia Doug Evans Mike Formica Brian Sparks Gerald F. Spencer Heather Stones Page 161 of 192 SCHEDULE “B” 1. Municipal By-law Enforcement Officers: Paul Brown Tim Burshtein Tom Craig Ed Czban Robert Davis Mike Formica John Grubich Dave Rogers Philip Rudachuk Bart Skiba Brian Sparks Heather Stones Salvatore Valeo Dan Wilson Page 162 of 192 SCHEDULE “C” 1. Parking By-law Enforcement Officers: Tim Ball Paul Brown Marianne Catherwood Julio Cavaliere Joe Corradi Adam Cousins Bill Crowder Mario Digianni Brandon Erb John Garvie Ryan Giles Cathy-Lynn Hanson Varghese Kuruvilla Coady MacIsaac John MacLeod Andrea Malgie Robert Mascia Krista McGowan Philip Rudachuk Chris Russell April Smith Thomas Tavender Kim Watson Page 163 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019- A by-law to amend By-law No. 79-200, to rezone Lands DTC conditional on the dwellings that are located on the Lands being demolished and removed within two years of the passing of this by-law (AM-2019-013). WHEREAS a large area of the City of Niagara in the vicinity of the Fallsview tourist area was designated Tourist Commercial in the 1967 Official Plan of that City in anticipation of the expansion of the Tourist commercial business area of the City: AND WHEREAS the same Tourist Commercial designation was maintained over the lands in question (“the Lands”) by the 1993 City of Niagara Falls Official Plan; AND WHEREAS the anticipated expansion of the Tourist Commercial Area around the Fallsview Subdistrict never has occurred; AND WHEREAS the City of Niagara Falls’ Comprehensive Zoning By-law, By-law No. 79- 200, as amended, enacted a Tourist Commercial zoning on the Lands: AND WHEREAS the Lands consist of individual lots owned by individual property owners; AND WHEREAS many of the individual lots that make up the Lands are occupied by dwellings; AND WHEREAS the dwellings on the individual lots that make up the Lands are, in nearly all cases, unsuitable for and undesirable for tourist commercial land uses; AND WHEREAS the unsuitability of the dwellings for tourist commercial land uses has, in some instances, led to the dwellings being allowed to fall into disrepair; AND WHEREAS it is in the public interest to demolish such dwellings that have fallen into disrepair; AND WHEREAS in some individual instances when a property owner has torn down a derelict dwelling situated upon a lot within the Lands, the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation has increased the municipal assessment of the lot thereby increasing the tax burden upon the owner of the lot; AND WHEREAS the reason for the increase in assessment is that, so long as the dwelling, no matter how derelict, remained standing, MPAC assessed a given lot as residential property, but as in the event that the dwelling located upon the lot was demolished, the same lot was then assessed as vacant commercial land; AND WHEREAS the Council of the City of Niagara Falls has resolved to provide an incentive to the owners of lots supporting derelict dwellings to demolish those dwellings promptly. THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. The Lands that are the subject of and affected by the provisions of this by -law are described in Schedule 1 of this by-law and contain dwellings on the date of the passing of this by-law and shall be referred to in this by-law as the “Lands”. Schedule 1 is a part of this by-law. Page 164 of 192 2 2. The purpose of this by-law is to amend the provisions of By-law No. 79-200, to rezone the Lands conditional on dwellings being demolished and removed within a specified time period. In the case of any conflict between a specific provision of this by-law and any existing provision of By-law No. 79-200, the provisions of this by-law are to prevail. 3. Upon the demolition and removal of a dwelling existing on the date of the passage of this by-law from a portion of the Lands and the establishment of landscaped open space on the same portion of the Lands, the provisions of this by-law shall be shown on Sheets C5, D4 and D5 of Schedule “A” of By-law No. 79-200 by redesignating that portion of the Lands from TC and TC-1103 to DTC. 4. Notwithstanding any provision of By-law No. 79-200 to the contrary, the following uses and regulations shall be the permitted uses and regulations governing the permitted uses on and of a portion of the Lands, upon which a dwelling, existing on the date of the passage of this by-law, has been demolished and removed and the zoning of the portion of the Lands has been changed to DTC. 5. The permitted uses shall be the uses permitted in a DTC zone. 6. The regulations governing the permitted uses shall be the regulations specified for a DTC use. 7. All other applicable regulations set out in By-law No. 79-200 shall continue to apply to govern the permitted uses on the Lands, with all necessary changes in detail. 8. No person shall use the Lands for a use that is not a permitted use. 9. No person shall use the Lands in a manner that is contrary to the regulations. 10. This by-law shall remain in full force and effect for two years from the date of passage of this by-law, after which time this by-law shall expire and be deemed to be repealed and of no effect. 11. The provisions of this by-law shall be shown on Sheets C5, D4 and D5 of Schedule “A” of By-law No. 79-200 by designating the lands TC and numbered 1103. 12. Section 19 of By-law No. 79-200 is amended by adding thereto: 19.1.1103 Refer to By-law No. 2019-____. Read a First, Second and Third time; passed, signed and sealed in open Council this 16th day of July, 2019. ........................................................................... ................................................................ WILLIAM G. MATSON, CITY CLERK JAMES M. DIODATI, MAYOR S:\ZONING\AMS\2019\By-laws\Byam013.docx Page 165 of 192 o_._.<omz_>o>m>_u>_._um w<-_m<<2o.8.;I >c<-_m<<8mS:o:NmEmmxmoczoz9“mmama_<_m::m:m:om>m6m3m:.5:::6._.o<<:0* mo:mam.qmmumozzmEm8mo_Bmimsmzommo:<:_mm31rmccmomgmagmo:mcUm_ momq. ._.Im00:20:.O.”._.ImOO_N_uOW>._._OZO_u._.ImO_._.<omZ_>0>_»>_...>_u_um mz>o4w>m_uoE.o<<m” 4.>moma_<_m_:.Hm:m:om>o_.mm3m3Qm?mq_umcEm:<mm.No.5.manBmqmcm2<mm: ._.:moo?oaaoz23m05o?z_mmmS_um__mmm03:man.:5Oo8o8:o:2:5 A92:2mo:mammm._.o<<:.?mmnmozsm3m_3m:m:ommo._<Emmon4055O<<3mQ _m:QmQ8258mm5%momq.403zm.5m:u<momq8:63::_o_um_Uocsqmar magBmzimsmsommon_<:_mmonO3ossmq_m:n_mammozvmammmo:m:cm_moma :03<<___o<<Nome8mE:oxw3m»m_<so3:on:m:<_mcgmo?8:6$36man oozaaosmmmmm?9:_:Em>9mm3m:nmmmzmosma3920._m:m$_u<w_uc8<ma man.mS:o:.NmQ. N..26_<_m.<o?man9?05%m6:m8U<mS:o1Nma8mxmoimEm$3momq _<_m_2m:m:om>m:mm3m3. w.:50.?O_mq_Amm:m8_o<mS:o1Nmq3maxEmoo8oB.6mam.2.688ma8 am__<maEm$5moma_<_m::m:m:om>©6m3m3. Wmmn.m33*.mmoosamac.._.::.a:33“ummwmm.mmmzmamanmmm_mn_.323:095m: .2»8...%<o.“.:__<.No.5. <<__._._>_<_o._<_>amoz«o:<ormmx.L>_<_mm_<_.u_ou>:__<_><om Page 166 of 192 mo>o_<_>_Z._.m2>Znm>mmmm_<_mz4 ._.:.m>mmmm_<_m2._.Gm2mn.a<mas_um_2.cm2mm.~89 wm._.<<mmm2_ ._.Imnamuom>:az01:._m._.O<<2am«am...mam :.Em.4o<<:J .>:a. ._.:mnomvom>:o2an._.:mn_._.<onz_>m>m>_u>:.m A.Em=n_2: <<:mmm>mEm40$:a<<:mEm_m:amammnacmamm_.muumama$03zmEmE<mama8Em3::_n€m_ E:5%2.mza_m«mm_ma:mE_m3..Em3m_3m:m:nm.aamxmaazmza«mum:Em«maw >20<<:mmm>mEmQ2a<<:mEm_m:amammnacmammmEm:cm_mama19:<<a<<mama.8mE:.axa3m?m_< So3:a«Em_._<mzaE«mmua:mE_m3..Em3m::m:m:nm.aumwmaasmsa«mam...Em_.maw >20<<:mmm>wEm92:mm£338um_+o:.:.nm3m_:_<_m::m:m:nm>n:<_:mmcue:Em._.a<<:.m_.m:am“ >20<<:mmm>mEm._.o<<:Emmmm_,mma82:23nm_Am_:_<_m_3m:m:nm>9._mmEma:EmQ3}52? 292._.:mmmmomm_:no:m_am_\m.aa:am"Em3:Em_oo<m:m:.G3338a.._3m9msaoEm«moaamsa <m_:ma_mna:m_am«m.aa:.Em38.3msam:3n_m_..n<2<E_E_mEm«m_m<mn_3o<<_mamma.Emum_.:mmmm_.mm m1a=o<<n >m:n_.mHI_<_>_z:mz>znm>n._._<_._._mm EH._.EmQ2Em__nm1<ac»Em3__o<<_:m_<_m_:nm:m:mm>na<_.ammasrmuumama.mm33:131.; >m_.mm3m:n mamamamwmaiw E<<:;m«8:2a_ma 30:E._:mmzaa_.m_:mmm3m.:nm:m:nmm__8Emma:Em_m<m_o...mm_.<_nmuqaiamaa:EmQ2 ma?a:3_.mE.mama EmQ2Em__umlazzEm_<_m_3m:m:nm>o:<_:mmmmEm<m«m3253m:a<sEaSEm:mnmmm:< 2$2.?ma<m:nmmcu_.a<m_U<Em._.o<<:. Pm._.:m._1o<<:Em__nm2<ac.“Em.qa__o<<_:m_<_m_3m:m:nm>n:<:_mmasmEm:cm_mama‘mm33:1: EH>mqmm3m:n &mamam_.ma:.m 3<<_:.nm_.na33_ma 30:E_:mmzaa«m_:mmm3m::m:m:nmm__8SEEEm_m<m_aa.mm_.<_nm2033o:Em492: _oo_..aa:am<<.___o<<moma mmmmH3m Page 167 of 192 Hm PA Pm em 3 Fm Pm ._.:m.8<<:Em:umlozsEm_<_m_Zm:m:mm>n:<_:mmmmEm<mam3958ms:s:EoSEm :mnmmm:<9nmumminma<m:mmmuu_.o<m_c<EmQ2. ._.:mQ2mag._.o<<:Em:vmlozsEm_<_m_:.nm:m:nm>nE::mmmm"9:3Ea>m«mm3m3ozEm 53%E92:o:mEma:_m:>=m:mEma:m«m8.no33m:m3mmm3_m::m«<H.BS.mun:Em: 833cm8Um_+o_.3Em_<_m::m:m:nm>22:2:3.Em>m«mm3m:n_m325.3233 mnnoimznm<<_EEm835ms:no:n::o:mEm«m_:. mun:Em:_o8<amm::mnmmmm«<38::Emamzmrmnc€3m3mamm:am«<__o:8um_+o«3Em _<_m_:.nm:m:mm>n:<_:mm.$1.3m<3.83mmo3$n8..8U383:Em_<_m::m:m:om>35_mm. mmn:Em:um%o_.3Em_<_m_3m:m:nm>2.1:m83nm83Emssm? S_um1o_.3_:mEm_<_m::m:m:nm>n:<Emm.mmn:Em::mm_ 3_<_mnm1m_m\mn:€3m3Eau1:n_u_m& EE_mQeano3Um»m353man 8ma:€3m3E3w3m_:S_:mm3moon.«mum? mmEEm:812cc”Em_<_m_:..m:m:nm>n:<.:mm3mmnoamsnm<31.” 3_.m<m_m2mmwsnm.mnzam?mmamuaonmgcwmm::n_ca_:mu_.o3uEmmmmag:533wmmuosmmw mm$c_Emaa<Em«mmumm:<m3c:_n_um_:<$.0323m8:39man. 3>:<_m<<.oqamw.4m:<nos:ow._.1c::m_2no3umnm3_.::ma_m:o?«Em.«mmc_m:o:oa «mn:__.m3m33Emmo<m3_.:m3293%..Emmo<mE3m30.“0:810.ca32_<_c::n€m_ mo<mE3m:.rmama?no33_mm.o:._umum23m3ca0385ms?<<_Eo:nqm?anzzmEm mm:mB_:<2Emmowmmoim.?mzgm?m::n_:a_:m._.:m_<__33:_.:_<_m_:.nm:m:nmmaamam*3 _<_c:_n€m__.:m:<<m<mmmmm?05303310xmmc_m:o:Nmm\8.2.Em_<_::.n_um_>3.moor m.O.88.m.mm.mmmamzama. 2EmamEocacmm852.2Umszmmsm:<2Emm:Eo_._mmmm?9:3Emmco<m2,5umqmmwmurm. mmm:Em:8o<<Emm:Eo«:<<E_Eu8<Emm8.‘Em:_m:m_.?msamwg. mun:Em:Smwmman:333qmngdm1m:_<_m::m:m:nm>n:<_:mm.8Emmmzmwmnzoz1Em «mmumn:<m3::_m:.m__.2.man3_mmmn8Emmm3m_m<m_2%§_magEma.:<mm:Emxmmmag «m.8_:m81:8o<<:_m:gm.Emmm«macawEm:cm_:83.mzg8:83m:3n_m38_u8<mEm onn_.:._,m:nm2m:_<_m_:8:m:nm>n:<_:mm\man_om_.:n:_m1<8Qm?mzan_m:3m3368mm:9. __._mamn:mnm3m_3m:m:nm.Em53%owqmno?m8cm32;mag833mg.:n_:mmE5mwm:3 __3:mn_8:<<o1Aoqama.23mEmma.m:vm_.<.moim_.o:Em_mmagH328n_.onmn:o:Emsm. 2m3:3Em.<Eocacm:m<mEm»EmoEm«Emm3:38umlols_<_m_3m:m:nm>22._mm3G oU:mma8um3.o_.3vcwmcmsn83;>m_.mm3m:.oEm:mg8vmlors_<_m_3m:m:om>2._mm3 m:3m_<JEEPo_\Emmum1..o«3mg_<_m_3m:m:nm>m:<_:mm3ms::mm:mEm82BmssmsEm ow.Sm_3c:_n€m_:<Emm_<m<<1:m:zozmm8EmoEm«.:EmoEm«E:m8nolmnaEm ::mm:m3n8«<umlozsmzmm8Emmmzmmmmzos3Emo_._m_:m_SEEmm<m:335.Emo1m_:m_ 3m<Emqmcuoz838:2Em_<_m_:.nm:m:nm>2_<:<“mzg.cue:2_mmm.nmm<m:333:3$5 <<1:m::o:n.m.3m<.nm_.3§m.nm.E:m>m_\mm3m:¢ ummmN2“m Page 168 of 192 NH mp mm mm mm >3_n:mN._.><_<_mz4 mmE3::_n:om_:<Em__cm«m%o:mE_m+3Em8mm1m___<_m::m=m:nm>2.mm822333 Em:92:..oRmm3Emouuomim3::_n€m_._2_:mnnoamznm<<.EEma__9s:mu8<_m_o:m2EH >m_.mm3m_.:. >w._._n_.mw.mmzmzi Em.35:Em__o_.a_:m<no33E:nm8<<EEmn:<E3:mEEmn=<.m_<_m:mmm_.omxoma<<m<m. EmQ2Em:o:::m1_<no33::_nm»m<<_EEm._.o<<:EwocmsEmU:mn8_,.__E.mm:.:n:=m mm_.<_nmm.>:<zozmmm_<m:o«32:3,.:32En>mqmm3m3Em__cm823umGo:m__<ow<_m m_mn:,o=_n:.m:m::mm_o:msnGmmmn:<mmmcaEmzmxnccazmmm92..o__o<<_:mgm=<m2mm__o__o<<R Emnoauo?mzoz3Em40,2:2mo:mam H_<_::_m_um_nm::,mU_,_<m mo:mam.ozr~>mmm ._.m_m«Eo:m_mo.n..md.$oo >.:m:zo:”_u:mn3_,._:¢mw::nE«mmm..<.nmm mv.3Em._.o<<:u E._.oEmQ3:._.Emno_.uo«m:o:2EmQ23zmmmmwm_um__m F0.wox85 $8mHm:_m<><m::m z_mmm«mmm__m.02Kmmm» ._.m_mu:o:mnmom.mmm.$mm >:m::o:u_<_m:mmm«3xomE2m<m Em.mm_.:mmEmqmnommqmm8m:m3E8«mmo_<mm:<Emu?mmmzmmsm9:cm3;>m«mm3m3mm8. oum..m:<m_<mmuommE_m.>:<EmucnmEm"83:9cm_mmo_<ma3onmwmzsmmamEm:cm33:3 8EmumqammqmmummzmQ__1>m3_=§:a<momama.zoEmu?mEm__cmm:_u3_:mm8mnos? 2.3.5.mE.:.m:o_._ow3ma_m:o::3:Em_.mmumn:<mn:_1>&a_m:.m:<m0383:m<m:2.m «mmmc:mc_moEmo::::<8_.mmo_<mF9:_._m<mcmm:::m:mnmmmE_. ._.Emn:<Em___:am3:_2Em._.o<<:mmmi?magmm<mEm._.o<<::m..3_mmm:63manmmmi?m__ n_m_3m.mm3m:gmowu_.onmma_:mm3.._o&.mm3mmm.oq_:_.S<.:_n_:o__:mammE.mag$93mam mmmmzmnm_nom?wmanmxumsmmm<E_n_._Em._.o<<:3m<m:mnm_:.m::m_.9.Eng:«mmcizm3.039. m1m_:m&_.mm:<9._:&_.mn:<:63m:<m_mmmammzcqm3EmQ283m::m_:ms;«mum:Em ._.o<<:.m53%.0.‘um_+o_,3.3oczmmzozmEamqE_m>m_.mm3m:_n3m:<<<m<<Em$om<m:u_.o<Ema Em"2%umammamurEm _ :3muu_<8m_m_3mmzuzmmo_m_<9:3Em:mm__mm:nm2Em._.o<<:. 562.3.Em._.o<<:mmqmmm8u_.o<amEmmmam«mn_u3nm_:n_m3:3nmzo:. mmE3::_n_um.2mam__nos?mnnowmmagm:c.no::,mn8..mEm:u_.:.Emmmman3m§nm_:mmm__ :38m?smEm8::2E3>m1mm3m:nEm_:.o.Sm:nm8<m_.mmm__....&cm_os: 3P438no33m:mm3m33E:83_.m2.man8.,Em2339.35:EmacsEm8:.Qmn8« Em__cussmam3m::m_:_:mc_m:nm8<m_.mmmmmocE:mm_om_o<<..0323_u<$3_:m:_.m:nm no3um:<:m&__mm:mma8imzmmnnccazmmm3Em_u_.o<_:nm20:310man9.mmz?m?oé ::m:n_m_mnmzgim3Emno_?o_.m:o:2Em.35:2mo:m_._mmanEmno_.uo_.m:o:2Em vmmmm3m Page 169 of 192 mm mm mm Q2225%;mm__m.m<Em:nm0...m:n:_:m:..m:nmEm:_um_2.o<Emm.8Emno_.uo_.m:o:9"Em 40532mo:mamman._.Emno?owmzozcaEmQ22zammamm__m3Em333m9.488 2_:m_.:.m:nm£38..2ms2§2.5._m_m:m8«<u_,_o_..8Emmo33m_._nm3m32EHnos?mna magm_.3:m__<Em_.mm.4m«3..Em9.32%o3Emnoasa2.:mmoEm2smmwcmnimmwm_o<<._.no33m3_m_mm=m3_:2.<_:m:3:nmuo__n<_:m:1_._mmmmimnE3.um:< n_m_3m3.,_§___<_:_.:«<::n_:n_:m.523.umGo:m__:_.:_.<3&2u_.oum2< am3mmmmmm32:2225.cumzmmmmsmmzmmznm2Emno:2mn8_..5::m 3.33:3=3:0*mwooobooum.‘o2.3m=8\.£o.ooo.ooommmxmmm?m..E_m uo:n<Em:.:n_:am‘ES:2cm__3:mm.8” H.2m33mEmnowuowmzoz3Em.35:2mo:mzmEaEm no€o3:o:3EmQ22z_mmm_.m_nm__mmmm:mnE_:o:m__:m:_.mn_h N.n_.ommEma<\mm<m_.mE_:<0*_3m_.mmGn_m:mm m.no::,mnEm_E...< P_<__:_3:3E_:<US35.<$._:m:zoznm28:mm__~:_o:o_,son. _,m:m<<m_8._.EmnoSo_,m:o:2Em3,5.0*mo:mammagEm no8oS:o:3EmQ22z_mmmS_nm__m m.E2_c2m\oo3_._m§_oumszosmI?ma?m_m9.«comm::n_:&:m qoon\wm<mSm£.no3u_mnm2_u_.o_.mnE m.2%»:man>mnEm:8_we:20:SEH~o,:o:_._.muo_,::m?cmm3 Em3.nm_M3m_.o.‘oEm_.uonm::m_uo__:S:G..so1%0*m..ma:m_ _3um__3m:¢ 23.0558>:.83oc_m:3<GENESEm3_:_3:3=3:1mmbooboo umwonn:_,_.m:nm. os3mm>:83oE_mA02.5mSE8_‘<no<m_.mmmmE5.um:<=m_o<. mnnami_8.i_a.Eqmn?no3um:mm:o:u_,o_um3<Qm3mmm.man.::_:m:_.ma m:33oc._m.3..m__mama<mE_n_mmo<,3mQow_mmmmac<Emno3Sn.8_. :mmo_3Emmxmn::o:12%>m_.mm3m:n.<<_Em333:3=3:3 3.80.08umqonncimsnm. ._.Zm>mqmm3m_.;Em:mzmcam8Em353m:n_E3:EmumwammEmqmnomagEm..._,mm_umn:<m m:nnmmmo_,mms:mmm?zm. «Em>mqmm3m:»_mmmmm:<mmm2_m::m_,<H.mom.man@3558Emmm..mm3m:$cmczmmaEm um?mmgmm__:m<<_EEm3m_:nm:m:nmomEm53%.E32E123.32»m«33m»mEH>m_,mm3m3 £5:m_<_:m3_mmmnax8.3o:Em<,:._:m:zozom8EmoEm«um3<. zEEm_.um_A<Eu::225.822mm&m:3m:r_:sEo_m30..um?omEH>m_.mm3m:n.5465Em :13<<2:m:nosmmio?EmoEm_..<,E_Enozmmsn3m<cm::_.mmmo:mc_m<<EEmE.$2. 3:32am.2«mmm«<mmEm1mE:oqm<_m<<3&2_uonm::m__<«m_.mQm:c.no3«mm8_.m3.03<<o_._A_:m o:Em_.m:gm. vmmmb3m Page 170 of 192 wm_.n32um:cm2%>m«mm3m3m:m__cm3:<§o__<o_,_om3m__<___mmm_._=§_a9.::mio_.nmm_u_m_o< m:<8::2ncau?mi_.._:§2_o33m.32:msaSmQ2mmzmmEm”Em$33323:5 >m_,mm3m3£5::2cmmm¢2a,_uS16:ESE::1o_,nmEammmnn. _z<<_._.zmmm<<=mxmo_n:532.8:m..m.8:m<m9.2mxmncnmg3;>m_.mm3m3. ._._._mnoE.oz>:ozon._._._m._.O<<Zon35mam \\U....,..u\\.1.cm: 23:9.Sm<mmm.mn_m,_8u vomiosu_<_m<o_. cm:%.>\% zmamunm_d_mgomma nausea”Adi:Qmqx <<m:m<mEmmc:81~<8E2.Emno?oaaoz. ._._._mnoE.oz>:o2on._._._m92O1z_>m>z>_u>_._.m .N.v\ \\§\§\..T van 22:9333_<_.05%: comic?_<_m<o« 3:% 23.9<<_33_<_mGo: vomiozu>n:=mQ3em; <<m:m<mm::.o..:<8Egg:6nozcoazoz. vmmmmcmm Page 171 of 192 Jaaaw zsnun NAT 3‘-|°'Z Win S353 2861 CIVN3331555313‘-'!F”°°3 PX‘-VSDBOBTJOZ33UEM°\|VPEH3‘i"E‘{3S 3U!1EHS33U3U31U!3W3!J31J°:l\9|/V\“"W W015“3 5102 53535533SE)3)! 610?/UT/9 -(qduaaueg uJcu;san12A[2nuE auxxau wumauu nap s|9 amp}0 qasual sq:am uMn|.]$sanlen)axeuzgxmdde am san|2A man.‘laulgepsgp SN:zna|u!M paunqyxsgp Jo/pun pa:npaJdaJ aq AeuJ Iuaq:LuoJ;apem sa1do:pJeI.]Ju ‘uugwuJJu;ug Jo ’sa5euJ;mgsgpasaua}0 ued on ‘amp suu?ugsn ug 9155.1"2 aumssa sAasn 'E3Ep sgq:pa asn sq:uucu;Hugsye sa?emap I?elgpug Ju jegluanbasuaa qeauapgaugqegaads Jo;mqzu plaq aq mu “nus M13:14;04:53Btu uaxuaa asea|d 'uagJeuJJo;ug Jaqun;Jag ‘s?ugmup Jo suzld legagga 52 paJapgsu-3:aq mu neqs pus Aluosasmund :nnA2|ImauasJO}papuaxug an ugajaq paugeauaa sxugmuppue sdem an”may at]:;a ssauamdnuaoJo Azzxnnz any a)52 ‘pauduzg Jo ssaJdxa ‘sauuwem Jo suog:r::uesaJdaJ cu semen:(Mn aim snag 21222;“;a MEDauxpun "S!s2,_papyuud 5!asp sun. 009‘ZL?L C POINT ABINO'RD NORTHcmnaming seuw '=3I‘Z00 u an Mil-l3H.l.3N E{I}IE[JRIOJ :10 NMOJ. GK TEIQQVHDS J____J STIV:I VHVDVIN50 M13 CD!THHOVHDS 33UEU3].U[E|N - /Uepunoa |ad1:)1unw €U[]3JlUB:)pE0};| pua6a1 _'s"1‘1'i1'Je1u3e;Npadde1puepa|aqneq::5 1uauJaaJ3\-/aaueuauugew am]1105 -snag E.lE3E[|\|.V alnpaqas V7Page 172 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019-__ to amend By-law No. 2018-32 A by-law to amend the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan for Niagara adopted through By-law No. 2018-32. WHEREAS The Council of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls has designated Lundy’s Lane as a Community Improvement Plan Area by by-law No. 2018-32 passed pursuant to Section 28(2) of the Planning Act, on the 27th day of March, 2018. AND WHEREAS the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan was approved through By-law No. 2018-32 AND WHEREAS an amendment to add an Eligible Cost to the Tax Increment Based Grant incentive program under the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan is desired; AND WHEREAS such amendment would conform with the Official Plan of the City of Niagara Falls Planning Area; NOW THEREFORE the Council of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls, pursuant to Section 28(4) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990 enacts as follows: 1. That Section 3.2.3 ‘Tax Increment-Based Grant’ of the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan adopted under By-law No. 2018-32 is hereby amended with the addition of the following Eligible Cost: “4. Redevelopment of a vacant property that does not have direct fro ntage onto Lundy’s Lane or a property with an existing commercial building that does not have direct frontage onto Lundy’s Lane to a multi -unit residential use including site preparation/planning costs, interior and exterior renovations costs or new construction costs, and new public spaces on private lands as reviewed on a case by case basis.” 2. This By-law shall come into force and take effect on the date that it is passed by the Council of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls. Read a First, Second and Third time; passed, signed and sealed in open Council this 16th day of July, 2019. WILLIAM G. MATSON, CITY CLERK JAMES M. DIODATI, MAYOR Page 173 of 192 /Z/. Na..gam]:..m \SCHEDULE 1 TO BY—LAWNo.2019- 2 i. :1 W mm Part‘Page 174 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019-__ to amend By-law No. 2018-31 A by-law to amend the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan Area adopted through By-law 2018-31. WHEREAS the Council of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls has designated the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan Area under By-law No. 2018-31 passed pursuant to Section 28(2) of the Planning Act, on the 27th day of March, 2018. AND WHEREAS the addition of certain properties specifically identified as: 5873 Brookfield Avenue, 6518 Lundy’s Lane, 5916 Carlton Avenue, 5926 Carlton Avenue, a Depew Avenue property used in conjunction with 6863 Lundy’s Lane and the rear portion of the lands identified as 7001 Lundy’s Lane, to the Lundy’s Lane Community Improvement Plan Area is desired; AND WHEREAS such amendment would conform with the Official Plan of the City of Niagara Falls Planning Area; THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. That the Schedule attached to and forming part of By-law 2018-31 is hereby deleted and replaced with Schedule “1” attached hereto. Read a First, Second and Third time; passed, signed and sealed in open Council this 16th day of July, 2019. WILLIAM G. MATSON, CITY CLERK JAMES M. DIODATI, MAYOR Page 175 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019 – A by-law to provide for the levy and collection of sums required by the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area for the year 2019. WHEREAS the Board of Management of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area was established by By-law No. 98-225 of the City of Niagara Falls; AND WHEREAS Section 208 of the Municipal Act, 2001, S.O. 2001, c. 25 requires that a Board of Management of a Business Improvement Area shall prepare a budget for each fiscal year and shall hold one or more meetings of the members of the Business Improvement Area for discussion of the proposed budget, and submit the budget for approval by Council; AND WHEREAS the Board of Management of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area has prepared a budget and presented that budget to the members of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area at a meeting of members of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area; AND WHEREAS the said budget was presented to and approved by the Council of the City of Niagara Falls; AND WHEREAS the budget of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area is raised by a levy upon the ratable property within the area of the Business Improvement Area; AND WHEREAS the Board of Management of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area has proposed that the budget be levied as a minimum or maximum charge pursuant to Section 208(3) of the Act; AND WHEREAS the City and the Board of Management of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area have undertaken and completed the procedures prescribed by Section 210 of the Act concerning notice of the consideration of a minimum or maximum charge; AND WHEREAS the Clerk of the City has determined that the vast majority of the membership of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area do not object to the minimum or maximum charge; THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. The sum of $48,000.00 shall be levied upon the non-residential properties located within the boundaries of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area. 2. Each property shall pay an amount calculated by dividing the sum of $48,000.00 by the number of non-residential properties within the boundaries of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area. Page 176 of 192 2 3. For the 2018 fiscal year the amount levied upon each non -residential property within the boundaries of the area of the Main and Ferry Business Improvement Area shall be $615.38. 4. This by-law shall come into full force and effect on the date of passage. Read a First, Second and Third time; passed, signed and sealed in open Council this 16th day of July, 2019. ................................................................ ................................................................ WILLIAM G. MATSON, CITY CLERK JAMES M. DIODATI, MAYOR Page 177 of 192 o_a<omz_>m>m>_n>_._.m w<-_m<<2o.83I >_m<-_m<<8m:Eo1NmEmmxmoczos2mEomzom>9mm3m3<<_E038:0_uo<<ma Om:mB:o:Ea;?mmcmozsoEm@33252m__om:om8Em0.28qEmoo:m::o:o:. 3m_:8:m:ommagonmaaozo+mmom.IocmmmagUoox8..cmmc<Em38Umnmnwnmi oz33%888;onEmmo:Emam0+EmOs?umémOammx. ._._._mOOCZO=:on._._._mOO_~UOW>._._OZon._._.__mO_._.<omZ_>Q>_~>_n>_._.m mz>oam>m1O_._1O<<m: \_.>Eomsmm>o1mm3m:nqm?ma.E:m4.M03‘man3%_um2<mm:Oimzo_uo<<m? OmzmaaosEm.mmO_u®_mam._.:mOO_.UO_,m:O39.EmO52z_mmm«m.um__mmm Eom:mmm_?mmcmozsmEmmwmsasm3m__om:om8Em0.2*2Emoo:m::o:o:_ 3mE8:m:ommagocmaaos0*mmom:IocmmmanDoor8«:mm3Em_u:m Umvmasmio:_m:qm_oom8QozEmmo:Emam2EmOs?nmémO?mm_b..o«m83. 28:<88oo33m:o_:m.E:m\__M08.mm£6038:m«m8__m:m«mv<mEo8<mn_ magm:Eo:NmQ. M.._.:m_<_m<o«mam0.2O_mEmam:m_.mw<m:Eo2Nma8mxmoimEmmma_._om:om >mamm3m2. m.._.:m03O_mEEm€53m:Eo:Nma8maxEmoo?uoazmmmm_Em«m8man.8 qm=<mqEmmmaEomsom>o1mm3m:.. Emmamlawn.mmoozams».._.:__d:33.833.masmn23$235cum:00:30: 2%3...%<2.E_<_No.6. <<__:_:_>_<_Q._<_>._.mOz_O_._.<ormmx;>_<_mm_<_.U_OU>._.___<_><O_N Page 178 of 192 HHOHZOH>n.~.wE<..wza aimEnmzna3%3or?.M_m3.025...SE. wmesmwz. OZH>EO.525.OH_ZHH~>.:O2H20:moonuonmmoa:..oo....o..w8mE39.:5_u<..m 3.25v..o<.=nmom0:310n:O~u0:V .E.m. HEBnow.vo.§e.o2OH.H:05.4ow2~>Q>W>H>H.H_m...no€o.:..:o.. :.oo..uo..wE.__._a2.:8.35am:5_uB$=oaom0:330?rs:§$..wn¢:v Ago...m:H......J.:eaSmoz?uEm:ww..3mm:V WMOE.>rm. >.ova.m:8o¢<=a..O2555%n_mmn..=vmm3.92. w.‘:5Coosmawsuma..__...m.&s58:008in.89.3.BEoaov.wmole:om:6_....=%samnm:5 333.22.3:5283..95%m..&3.953.055.2..F..=mmJo:E.m~..o_:m.<a.5...3.. :5oosmadomos.:_a=§5=8BEo_.m..u:o=cmuwe.Eoumm2...Don.»3..Ea5.:8E3 UmE..d:m=»cm2.2%....E...EamaEnmzmamxmz?umwnov.mm..<.naw.2...own.5...m..$..8 v9.3::8Coaamoo8:8.89.3.2awas“.:5CowamnmE:.%3..mac:—=..,_.omoGym.._u..m28 :58...»;eaoo..mEo=mno..S.=mn_:38...A22558:8:9.2...:Ennnenuv. 20$.embwmmoww58..mEo..w:o:o...:5oo.:_um..m»:o..ammo..Ean_5mango:N_.w..mon2...E oonmamqmnozO25oo<m=u=_mE5no..E:o...m..§_.=%2oo=§..ma8.3.3...ea.....%o_..=2.3.95mag ._.wCoasmon.9a....3ammammummo=o.<m_ uE:z§.o2m mo..:5.u=..uomnmowcamCoons?:5mo=9<:.mn_m.._=Eo=mm_..m:wE._u: Q 3 Q: 3 8 :>E.:awEmH355«omuoo»omm5.uwqmo....=.oua..J...:.=§.a=ono<m..rBowamw:m_€:omEw 3.3..uSi..o.m_.:.:...o€.._...=._Hana_B<m.mS:.8m_2:2...awc_m:o=m.o.dw_.m_m_:n_o::mm. comma.Eiwimvo...:=..=nmm.m:..=_....%.2,328...:um.=¢.:mE3maoqnomw3.:owEa89...name... Eoumn?zsnmmomon0..o<m..:B:5m3.:owEm33¢BE..<_.m:.o.,ca:2—§i=m:5mo..ooomE2. »=m_uu:o..EamE...o<m_m...anE.d.....o.:m...am:omz_n:.dn:<mm...:_mm.mE...o=awm.:.mc.:o:o..m. o...o:_m..w.:.u..E._m.uozomowE...wo..:.m__=8.._u..a§:o=m:.o..ao.eowEd.mo<w.,=.=w...m_..:=.o1Q _.w<:.mo.‘_u:..uo.\::m8.558.901?o<9,Eu»tmamo...—:.ouo3..:.m=m..o:o=ono<o.:E:8 wvusowim3:3 :>..:.o1so._W3...m2:w:<mu..:.ow=m:5Cooamoow$=Eov.nnm.no=:.wo»o_.m.mmmimwan wmmmmsmw :.w_.m...§63.:EmmzmB5..3.9.5:5:mm.:=3uFm==._&0..mS:.:oa._.o_E3.5:6 muoinon9.o_§_..9 :H=<...=..=..a.:w_H.=:Amv:33:w:mE.:omEo..2_oS_.v.,o<...o.m_.E:.:o€m_2...92:Kim. m?ncam...mm:_m:o:m.m=.%..=$.u~o<EoE_.358.Bi3.25.gas...22:.2:.w:o..%..m. n=..mo:<mw.E:=mmea%aw.oa§.%_.2.5.Ed...:.:m.Jnn_ocw.d:n.:o..mn:=:.:m:.w:<oo.. ..mm:_3oJ.wmanou.ca8:?m...o_..&...mEa.oc:mwno:m9.En5..2:m=Gw...mEm:..n_w.,oo:::o=E2. 8.m:=w8:8308030:on26a=<w8=.=o=r...r:..m.m..:.§=m22¢...<<=n_:mm._=:=w=...$..._ea wmmoa.ca:5=.m...=..uoE3..u..o8m&...m_moémmo=2.:...w...nm8..wmw.EmvommrQuzmuoz.:E:=_..m. oo=.E=.:a:ro_nu=y£.ono=.m.._.m_:m&..:o=onoo....ma:<mwane:o..E«mwuoo.omm:._§..%=m mzrmnuaonw 255:.onUa_..E=:rum:5:.om=:.mmo.3....Emoose:Cw =m§_:..:;m:_.m3:.nm:EnwzmEa.mccmnwaonu55......o_.o.:.om_.23$omEd.....:...m“o..SEW Q..oE&=msmvmmnom.wwrm?omno..S::=w322......vw..,o_m:.....von.o_oE...E..m.,om:o$.Sn:owo:<a m_.:um8..oamVnamao?amw=aqEn_.mmm._uo_vsEo...:w»o._EE.m=v._mv<,._._o_.n0..W%S_&cm%m._2_3 ca.Ban»9.m..wav.oo:.E=wao=.._.,§ao__m.n__....mm..o:m.8.30.wuo=::.=..m._m_¢8...o=w23.28. mn_u...mo..o:mmoon.w.._am.w.:m8umccm§_.oa.mno...mB_:....:2.amo:..n¢ow.uo::ao:9. oo:3::..m:o=0..:o...2.2aa..nm=_m8P2..._=o_:mnmm:w..m_omo=mooso?uzmm...%.§.39. u=..m..w.:8EJ.m:<...o=:.a=§_52ammmm.m.;:m._559,E6.m_.<.a_.=§..._.rug:Page 179 of 192 ca 3 8 3 8 as 3. 3 3 EV 3 ..§..&_.Bamsw:5_::n_mmmmn_.=.§_o:Morena?:>:m5n:§__.n..m..ow :§8..$:rum:5.:oE::mmm.3::E:6:85? ..Enm:nm:3:rmmEm_:oE::m3:91:imango:w :§na=mm._55%..:8En:.mE::.wmo.9::E:8:...a§mw:n_=_=w::8:o:mo_.&=_m:>:w :95:.%__._.:§..:3:6_:om:»:m$1.01:3maozo:_~w AAOMQ:2.§2.:.:§..Emm:mown.”m:..u_8&a.n.ao:n:o8..m.wwo?mm:mmmawu?3.9.:2.38 3:9 gown¢<:.._G:_:o::m::m:,:a.E_.am.3:53minoa::..=:a:_<<:a_.a<$_oo:$n_.9<:mn_ouEng:2 0:03no::mo:o:SE::8mm:m_.u:o=.:.::m_:.mw:o:.&m:.=u=:o:onmamomo_oo:._o5.:.o_E::m. ¢<_=.o:.::::w:o:.:::.»:m_:.mmmo:::mmQ:oF=.::m95¢:omiamea,.<:.mmv.82¢?co_wm.max! m:o:o_.wNE:.:.:mwo::9.m::oE&:mum::_2:_§_:.u:m».o::mE.eano:.::::mow:o:m:.=o::mw BEm€:v.:m:G. €12.=uN:..no:wm=—.m§._$m:=2:8B$3:mwo::5:Ewage:Hmw 2118.:=<:.2_..§§_Fa:w..m:a__¢m:rumEa_.:oB.::m810::W:mmozo:SW 25.3%,.rum:6_:mu:_:m_._.mm9.EmmE2%m:<:d:_:m_:m_5.2Ea::.._=n_wwSQnimmmm. ::8:::8:.9.W331Emmww.2:5.5:?u.::E:mVE333.vocaam.a.::mm:o:.o:€J::w. &€_§.m9::.an:o:.omowuo._m:oE:m.Emuomwr9:._:::m.macaw?mv:.v::m.giwr:§.:n_o:.:o_:. __§=%5o=.maonwwo.E:no_:m:»on:::.o9_o:o:.255..mooEo:S_2.::o::o:m_“ $.35....:wm:mEmmm=o_.m_£8£88::_:m:.m::mEm»unis:em.25C53saiw:82.3093 mmm53:8mmc:»=:nm3wozo?o:mo_..om:_n:.>:mzworma:9.m8za:.:=.=m3.43..En Eoo:o? 3H¢::..rmm:.$a=mmmmo"9:Emoomo:M. :E<:m:>25HEW: 9.0533w_.m:8::$8_:m:<w:om:om8:5§oo:mao859onn:E\2::o:_,o<EaCogmnm rwzumEmooo..mm:noSE.:5oo<o:w:~meawm_.wm.:a:.m543:,BEm:E.n2Em:93.5 m:oE:E.m:nmmo:2.5$.393..:3:3cm8:28wow?oo.:.:o:om:mo:35¢rNo3ea .m3::m::mo:33.ur8%35:.H¢_‘:..,.V R:8C833::2:5:W:%m._.:Enmmuoo?onu:%2:5oo<a:m:Bw::ww..mmEm:$:99:B :6m:n_on$5.H,w::.:5::55838£5::95Emam?838:::540::won7.8E mnE_:o::_853$cm:5A3v§:.m25:.mun:mx8:m:o:85..wry:coc:Emmm.:w8:5BE oo:&zo=mon9:58:8.:5._.a::5::w:8.:m:nw=v...m:n¢<».o_.28:o».2.68ox8:m:a:8_.::m. _u..o<Eo:EmzwWm:002530:Q9::502:2.33%. .25Com:mwa:or:o«<_wammm:m<_:m35Q5oE.o_‘E:5\8imumnn:5Eowamau?m::m:138 a:8::mE8:5Coo:8ma::m_.o_u<mooav?EmCnm:mmA_??amo:::2mmW.assas_,.E:. mxnnu»mmozaziwo_:9.a&3.W:9:58:8.9:58:8Sawcm8..:.:::8:E03.9.33 E2.?:.:an_:::mmaq.m::58:ExA8_:o::_m.:19.Elam::o:om8:80:5... HHOEZOHHEM H:oc:mEo_.::o:o».=5:3cm:5Cnm:mmn_C.:%.:8Eooioo:o_.o_u<wmnnaw8338mo:w.:_:o vwv::o:~8ova_::5miosicm8::o=E.m$3.08O>D.EaEnozuaNE.2.:z§9_&0».252. a.533mor:o<<_mn_mmn_E8:§$:8Haamzv. am: :mmmno:&:o:om9;58:8m:?_cm:69332on:5amzzeau:<:mmom:a3::n_9,mania: 8:5Cnm:mao.2::EaEnm:m3?m:n_m.nom?rmq(<5:m:womaaow:._m_.nmmw:n_amummm8:5 58:3:_L::%.558».o_.Eawinnuauamomon:5oo:m::o:o:.ouaumaonNS:_:wm:8:w:oocms _:om:_o:mmw:._3%m2.:8uc?omomcm:5ERUo_um.,::a:n02;Q0.owzmwmwnmma:ya2:2 03om23%..»maro:..2mo:ov.m??omm.m:n_:n=:m.:5:9:::8n_noEmE=.E:mom<mEo_om REE:8a.:a_.ma:8\uw_.mo::a_.=88.5%,omm.:a_,mo:8.n__.=_mea:.B:_:mmmmmmo:m_N5:BE 2:2cz?omomon58mm55.3mmama:8.528::6Ezdmm:n_.e_:2.5.».no2:83..<1::w.Page 180 of 192 AS 3 3 3 9 wonmqmwamnguns»:5_uE§=mcm503..<aEn_om5&2EmCannonmrm:Sam:uE.E=mon?W: oo::mo:o=E3.:8inonproComzmmnrmaam%...E._&W::5::.=m%Ew_%v_.ooo&=muwnwwxér. .233as:co:03:70..58m:.a&cm038:5EoanmmmEaun:==.2_3E?E828 23:9::6mica<:.:8:oonmoiomown.239:ooamasaoE5o~co=:8mwo=mEv\¢<:E.oEcm 95.€5.05=:.E=m:8mm=o§:J.em:8moammomsw.:SE:9cw=E.awmE.5E¢».o..9.08 «<:E5_n_no=mm=~8E89._u:_.uowww.2.5.5.$:6o_.wQ2.=2.2::5$5emmmoam?w€55:on Q5wnwwmmoorzwa33:6moe:_.:=_wno=ca3:5onwwncwmm.mo:onE?9.8..m=_um§=om9. Eu81m_eaEQcmm£30:5:8_.owmo=mEooE=_o=anown83.258mE2:zéaE. =EmE.oa.9.m%..w29.5__§==a=.3:5am.ao:<mEammmnman?03:35onownca95 €02? .55Cnmammw2.:ooivi2:::5.,om:._o:o=m5mgaa...aw:3:3..m%amo Wwmiozo:m\Wan_=:.a=§:m8Cmnmea>o:<5mm:. a?cwm oweM3:cumu:Exam...EmmeaummwmznmsaEm._.=m<3as&mmasm.:6ComingHwzam wxn_=n::m:8Eowzmmm?ramramm~88?‘ .26Cnoawaw£5:33.E9<=r?mswwmSxameaas:..m:=_u:_.mmomowonEd.3o_.owmaW:Exam. «Enm.o§_.m$.9&3Eamwm$wBm=$.22W:Emua?1:8Coozmoawcooznwsozom:8 §oo:mm.._55%2.Enwmuoo.em:5_:.on2.Qca95:5”owEmCoosmmmon:5Canaan5.5% win35ENown.010$5:m:_oB:m:N585:=.m_.mmo38EaCoosmoo2:3:EmEomsmaa ms»:E6‘23::wemmwmow_.ooo€.cm95;338.0.52:.c8<EmEmCoosmmoE5. ..o_w<m:»mmmmmwaoan=o:owmE595:09230:52:50:mm35%an_.ommo=wEv.znnommmwx8 a?ozinm$53505:»amm=2.mEm=S_awxom2,o:E.mamvwxmia. EQwzm.E.mno§z>2am areEoozmmo:33oo<m=E:mEammzwmmE5.ownanmozoimu A3 3 5 EV 3 AB 3 8 8E1:5Cannonmoo5333§§_=wanna:m.=:5Bw:=m_.E3on:532€853 regs 8uadz:ovaE3ownWm_u_.mmm:E:<omEu:_,owmo:wEm33$89.8..Ea<3228oo=aEo= cm:8SewingH.m=%£8:ova_._.2a.=m_.mmmo:mEm:38cmman:9:5: 8E.o.=u:<E3...~.o_§:..E383EBBEBE:EmCanaanFEE8:8mwmmwwnzoaomown. 895_,owmo=w_uJ>Emonoiwnoo2::Elna:.5385own9.03w%_.§=§<? 8no:.E%w.‘.:mmmo8_.=<2::w:Rmmo=mEm§=.=2aaonown;Emvoo8_.m§_:.:_.m“.<E..o.: :=:Sao=.m=£:..o:o:m3rs:9_a=§wano_§.w:o=m55:5oE_:o=am25..réua?oewu:6 ova£259.Enmwwaca«Baa...82.23..2830».onwooomw@538E3.3£233..23.o_. 2.6SEQ3.25u:_u:n:52ca3wmoumqn? 8anmc.$.30oo=»3_m9.m«Ea8vacuumo:25Eansmnm?E:_mK..am_:ww»an_3own“ 8E.m<m.:2:.:28noun:9.Ema.Ea.nimuzooo_.w.dA_:=mSE0:as:$50cssaomwmm? m==ov§:omoun=m_:3m=on8959.:5oo==::::vnso:=m§ao_§E<w =98onwqam9.vans:8ca22438<o_:o_omcaQ99.ma::u:.a.:25::E8wasommax060 $038e<E_o5:8«.19.§.§m=no:mm_:cm95.Sin:coin...”Saw.3$.E.=mEEown.“85 SE._.am§2_Ewouazosw :38£5.?rm95.5miaw.ooa?oca.aqwiumm.o_.SE9.ooc?mmvnonSuva.wB<m_onmmurmx.8 :6Cnaamam55%.:0.‘Eon.9.nO:m9.:O»Ed‘c::n=:m.m:.:oEE9.«mo.6.2.EnC833 §=%.:.o_:&:m_.EE_::m.<m=m.2:59:mam.rmizmoEE:¢n_w:~mn_E_.a.__==3o€w_ea wo<n_.=En.:m_1m:=:mBEmE:.o<u_m.ER2%wm?.m:v=:E:m%E_&E2:3..:8Eun.,o<m_on 03earmism33:5.03;—=._o«<<_.=..8=nozmniEonmnow 8oo?va.25.w:.2==§_mvmo?omaonwomOHVOum95Emw2mi..552:.9.2:Eda83.; _.nmmo:w_u_v._.3E_.mEa8a=wE.aw:m§n_85om.wmaim.no=n.mo8?mcv.oo=:&o8_.m.ao:m:=m=~m. 2o.._8..m2:._uo_.B:8omo».:_oCanaan35$mwiow cmanan:.E=::==5ComamouFER;EaEd.m=€~o<oEo=_m288032.5E22:25.53 muaommmm:a8:: 35103.Emnnoagom4.1?>E.:cwEo5,:eam..:<:.o=5n=::buimw Page 181 of 192 8 3 Q3 8 EVW::_.ammo::EmEan~=.mm:_:.m=:S.mmmu«E_o:.22:355:3mowea :5W:moooamaoo23:w:5:8.Em_.:w:o:mea_.an::.m_:mEm.mm.:m<an_,mwmo:wE< _:.mmn_.=§,._3.9:min81:53own9.Ed:w=::o_.5\23.$_m<2:.?:mn=c:o:“ 835:NE;3:53;:3meanm::..&:mw::nommmwJ._uo:::mw:aznmsomw§__.:&won:5smmm _§=_5&o::5Canaan.532 8:.z::§::5Conan:bmammEam:m:.:n::am.§=a$Ea529532;_o$.m._2530:E wmoonm§8omEuwr,w:n_oo:n::o:” m.:896:23:9,nE,:n..$::m:::o:on2.;58:3.<wow~oeaVHS.68own:8Com:mmu 55%W:mmoonR98om:.o_uw:,M5:8:959?mm3.2332.cm9:0295nnwmo:uEvaEa ::.:mH:m8_v.:oE,<00.0cm:3.Wa?smmonwEwswaosmm_.S§.$. ?4md.W>ZOH .28§nm:mmmE5:092:m:a_:m:.:m_:_:P:woqaw::n_948..wermmorwnow”.::.o:m:oE:5 Hmz:Ea9_::wman:2:9.2:5mm:5Eoosmawooocumnmono9a:z_mowW:nomm$mmo:aEa Seeing55%$5mo=o§=mm:mE.u:oaH 3am:1&8:E.oum_.Q::m_._§:oaao<a1:mu:unovoaan:8Enm?aw.m:n_E::w_u_.o_.§d\ me.EEQ.::_nmw=v.=uEa._..$.&25:::5EogmomH.w:%BE9»5.3.m:oE&:m u:oo:8:a.Eogmmo:.=:3<Q:o_=m.:.§_8:..m8ow.:..:.wao.m:._:E..mm:m.:o<am_u_o £::::n:rm:w:E:o=:~.4:95%Eu:$59:..ou_mom_:m:»com.=_o_.aon25.m:mm_.omm m.:o::»no;:mc_,m:nmEuzmo.H:mE.w:oano<m_.wma3:33w::3..:E:.:m:BEm95:»on ma2a099._....amna<m_.mm=:._m_.:._wE.u:$>u<:oJ.O_.mu:mNw:o:.mm§.%amé.._a2_ mo<o§wmm::o_.mm:_w:vm:o_:n::wmu_.:5:w_8.:02.aano=wvmm.2:.m__o$.:._m95ea 2%Boswwmamom0:0am:%_§o:u_:w:.mm338:mm:5:_,§89a___8§mE3. mvum?2::m:§<S.ommccaomwmo:E.o<Eam5.an_._a,.._2:§.@.>353Ema %aw_a§_N:.<..E:m50:035:3wa&no:w_:u_:mn_:.wE.a. 933:2m:._:§oE:oQ:_m:S:nao:m:oamoa0::o:2.man<§:m:5Cacao:C.:%.n: cm2.3.Edo£:am.o_ua:.8mn::oo:=.o:mn_3=5EowsmmaF$6Eowzmom?m:n_w9. _.a_wm:m89.3250:?:5Co¢:mmn_H::m_m.o:vEwaan.33..2._,oEwoa..:o.:ca; m:o_=n=:w.€3.05=:.:S:o:.wElwéa:mo.,mm_:o_:2522.2%5%_u..oimmo:m.2:: _:::m3.man::ooEo..:W:N:E:o::n:2_omm9:::5we_.mEmom::m:»cow»om$8: o_d.no.wam:8:amo».:5.FaCom?oo::_u3<m_:m:.mEa35¢mizaam.::m98: m:m:S:oomrmzEma:m:.mownwasmaSonmummmonOW0wmEEEo:m_53¢:53% mm25:...om1ao:<o_:»S.aw.w:§<mEuoE.5.3:w23.5..am:c_.omu:o:E.o<Ewm3.:5 ::._m:..<_.:m_.Amv.>353lmmn_wmmw:m8mW:§.E:m3.own£5:comnEEo::_52$ _:m=_.m Q5no::.:Q.&m_ma:mE_:m_u=3\323:8o:w:onn:2m:omE532:::3503.25%:5: ucobopooo020.325293..30:.~.on_:<_=_.=Q.m:n_:E:m35..uo_.mo:m_.:_.Ez<m:.._ amn?mm8u_.ou9dnm:o_:a=:m5%an:3.__m_.mon3..$2.onoE._.a:no.Oo<o3mm£5: %§mSE59...?5::3ca5:08:8:5mo__9S:mHEmanomno:.:.woEw_:mE:Q. mmimma8m:30:3?omowe.m:o_:n=:w3%8::82880».:o:::o::mE:Qoo<m_.wmo o:EEmu.wm=..Em:u:n_uooEo:.m_cum?_u_.oa:o_..mwe8319aonwqwmosm.o.:u_ov~m_.vm :mE=Qw:o:.o(<:mam:8_:oE_w:wE:Qw:8§on:w$.wEma52:?airc_.omn_3...: EouoawmwimmoE5:Emnn?8:8Eoo:mom.m35%.in2.oooscwmo:cm:5 58:3:Fmsmm3:5§8:mooonm:<omzmm3<m:$Mwmo:~m.oo::.wo.8_.moqum_.mo:mm9. 2.8.::5Cowsmmma0:E28muo:£EoEamrocizmOHU0m:n_:5:Eonmwmaaow00.0 pm25503.:53m=2_..2_mm._.o:...nm_umo:<o::¢_.mm.m:30.wv1mE.«<E.mma<a:.uE_=<cm ::a..om?m:?_uo..omw.=mE=QSmimw Q6E:o_:oE_m:wE=0.m:m:_.m:nw.no<o1:mu::om:m2_320:.<mEoEm82.235:5 Coa:mmm.oo<m::mEa::d:J\w:mmauve?33%:mE=Q8uoo_:E:mm:o__.w_<¢ _aaa=5:3:cm%b8.o8O>Um:aBu:%:o_<2&2:wo:mm$wm:n_ Aé:302.9.:53onm=m:_,w:oamm03.mo::w_.mwmo:mE<.ca:5Boimmmmman0:0.Bum .358wow:3:»33:93E:o::.mm:mm2.:_m:_.E_oozmwmmmuimn€_:o=muzaoi o.<:m_.$65:92:2 mun:cm:5§oa:moo.mm:m:_,::nmE532.:8:33.wmmE:.o_:.::aH 32%m§:mm..mBosmmmmimzmmwE».33cm§_a_.&3:5:Bozmmwooo».2.9 Page 182 of 192 Q. 22 3 5. Q35£525..0m53.m..c.,0mm2o:..2m_..m$552.2.5§55...m55.m2:mE.5..m.<0:_2_.m<55552;. 0:00.:3.2.5.50:».0..32.5.:0200.52.25%..5mv0..m2._5. 5v..o<2m8:w.m2:m2::25555.55552..m....w..552.025%222.5_...2=...J.2...E22:0.55: 2:850:38:20..53.025...:m:..m:5530255580:0.5.... Q65e<52<5«.B55.55?2.52:.5..5m.m2.0205:20»55.552555550m0:0.0.5Ed._0..o<2m8.. 2..55.on2.5E55..m55.m:.w.....w..5520255532.52.55.803.22.5552.cm:5..<5....m..25m. ..5u..5m5..820..m.255_.:m20:m.0..50:&20:m50:82:522:2.5C55:m55.mw0:525mw .>=200252552222.5228:0.:<22.2:m:..5..m5:2.052:58......55252505.80.5..25559.555 2:225=<5..802.0010..82..525520555.282.5E55352V2.258..55._.....uom553.5.. 55.225355om:.m....m..559.28..55.225250.02559.2.5§55:m55.m.:m:..w..5500:525...25E55555 222.2.0....2:582:5.0..mm..52.2..523.020..___....m..802055522555.0..02.5..5<E5..55m ..5552..mE58own.5582.5§55...m55.m2:m:..5:o52..53.55.5::2...5..5.§_0..50..2.:.m2o=.: 8.55.2..5.5.2220...2.5C555552:.—...0<E5802.09.5..5<E5=555m0200..52.:..5m:5m5..=02..m _.0c<2.52...:..5E..55.:5.:now.0m25555.555....8.3._.__..%.m=:22...5.»..»:...5m.5:22.5 555355::.0..0<5:.5:.m255..58..:.2:5n_.2..m=....5om0:082535::5:52.55.2255855025.. 5525.55022.:8:625:55$22.2555:.w.:.m:o5..5:.:..5.:5...m0..925.50»02.0835:2?5 25»..525=8.$0.:5:25:55v..0<E5252::0._0550:53.52wmm«<m2<5..0m25C55:m55.m0_.=mm:0: 8:._.2...m2:mac:2:m=..5..55..25w555_08..55om25=<5.u.E.010cm5....55.225350».2..m....w..55 5<E5:52:m2.5..5E:..5250<5..wm5.m5:22:28205m:0»50322.8wE....0<w_0..wm..55.:5:»_0%O20 2.5.2.52..m..;...55..5n_..:.5:.5:.m2:25.055:.:5.052.5»252:555:55102525552.0.5.2:25 55.225255om..:.£...5..o5E52..o0.:.u:w:55.12.2.55n..2..5....5..§ I >:2.0252552:250:82..E...._%:%._.53.25:.m:..5..m2.5.2.52.2225..255<0..8....0<E5823a :10..52558020am55.35515252.5:w5.55:55:59....0..n5:=2:520..ow0:2.00:52..235.. .5255$5:_.5252<5..522:..55o:._::55«<22.w5520..30m2.2mCn5:55w E2.55553555.5:2.2359:588.2550.....55:2:».o..80..2.3.2.5E.5::.....m5:5:2‘2..m=..m:55 mm.5255:2..2252:55:55.0...52.55555552.252.0.:25583:582525..30:0 wu2mm558J.u_.00m0m25moo:m8:E:m0».5:25:5:2:555:550..25E.v..:5...1:..5:.E.:mmm ..5n_:2..522:225555.5525..02.022:...i2.o..:2252:225585:2.2.23025..15....5:2..5...5E5w ..:.25..2.25C55.55._:.<5252%.»._0:.:2:50_0=mm30:.8E555man:2:m:..m:550:3......0w2.5 555555..225505.8m52.5««<22.2:5.65355.:0....u5:—.v.02.05::5:8:05:52:5283%.cm 2.05550535:25.65555585o<5..02.0.m0<5_._.5525:2m.._u5..<2m20..50532:.25E223.2.5 55535580:0_....0.:w2v.5.0:25.:m..2. 1~nO.H?O.H~<H.zm..>rr>...0zm 2..2.55.5..»02050..mE5..m2:555mmwQ2::53.on2.5020/.<0.._a0..25E5535225:252.5@55205 5:55:0..025.4555u..055.5n_0555:5m5......m.5.2555555552.5:up:53.5505"5:25.65:5.5.55.5:2 .§.a......m:5_.m5..55m0..02.5...un02552<52:mS=...20:mmm020E3...5..mo:mE<..5n_.:5. P A... 2.. 3. OW0>O.HH<.HHHm..m 020E3.5.Ed.2:5.60..555032.25:0255.025555.555A55522:5:5.:5..m5:5v.£25::5 .825552.5:2.55n..2..5&.5:5..0:82.55553522..5::m5:225:50..2:582..:mw:8:..552.2... ..5:_u55...5:.0<5.5:5.....5_0om50..5228Ed.0».2.5050302%.0555:2550..5:2:5.‘ 50:m:...5n2.5.5:.552055...:..2:§2....5:wF52.25.555:2..5E0<55:2.:52£0.230:2.5555552 2.2.255:250:955x55<w20..25.0.:2522:?82.5555.555.2505m..5w.5..55...w.:Q.25 559.555mow:0.<_52w5m2::0:052...::0»2.5.52025202535:2.2535.5582.5§55...m55.w _=.u..0<5.:5:.m.m.o.....$._m..2m5mm.50..r:m:.5mm55:523.0.52:2.55x5w52m502.2.55.5: ..2E:m...:_5mm5:5:2w.:..m555:25$.050..5m:m5:.mo»20:02..2.550:5505250u5..m20:m. 207<22.mS:n==w2.55x5Em2<:<on225255555.25555.555w5w..o.<_52w5m5:2mm..55m2.5.25 0..:..5Q:55on2.5555.5522.5.85258..02.0.5029,520....Q:o2..n:..w20022.8.5:225 C55..w55.m:5525w550..2.....<8020.52..5:.:w.51m_55:55.5.5:22.5555.5552:.2.5.. $9952.532:::502.5320...33.2.0.:2:582:5.053.85.52.w2<5..w5_<on:02.3.020.5 ou5..w20:m. 50.6%:22050.5nomam :.B:5255052:552:555:550555.0m250u5..520..m55.1520.:..:..m..m.:82.2m2:55:550..:3. 2....:..0<5....5:aB52582.5555352F5525Ex0..2.0..2.535:52.:om2.555535552.9.5.2:2.5..5..w0:5E5 £02.20:0».0.5.22.5522.0.._..n:..552<2.9.55552.5505.0..5.65:525:2.5x2w2=m0..2.8.5050$0.28. on2.5.=.2..n5..m:55.50:m3.520..9.025.520..2.o..5on2.5555.55552.5::3.802.05.0:823.5.E205 $125...82552.0.:02.0.5:52.2.5.50.52:505.0..5.65:5.:.5__..&..m222.0...:....:520:.2.5505.80200 .5.Page 183 of 192 omwoacismEd.25.0.5._.:am2._..m..a2.1%20:5:9.55£2.a..=...2.9:3..=895.9.8on :1.CooanaonowEnEnaswmmar:_.3<a...o=.m.ino..uomwmm?osow_r¢Eoosmmn52.2..a§.&EB ?rmEnozmaomrw=ra<a:53.30..cm8..=.r.m:=w:5Comsom2.9.:25..mo.3..528male?r.2...... Samw:2.5._u.d<m&o...m9.9..58:8Q=o_E:=mEm8..m:o_.o_u=mm:o=m:.am..wanna:_3as:.3 £.v=2.r_a. C. MN, 9. EV ....E<5..:m..m2nS<.w.~>2o..m iiEoasom2...En§oo=mmn.m....a3m».5»...mru:.5m..En98w:$Lw:..w_m..mmm.znmaoam. mmmm...a.:m.zmz.9.cmwo..oon.€m:o=2a2.5..w3uw_.J.3....2...?...3.2%.Eas38 33%.2.5%....0..=9..aEm8..mPu..o<Eam0.5.5....o<:_&=o:om8=5Eaasmnn..www..&..m 2%m....m..mm...o=.mBE_u..o<Eanan_..w_§m..m.:m....§.2.2.23=2.=§..2.m:....mmmo=m_o_v.3:. BoEnwnmaad:3cm:5Enmnmmm..e_%. H.E<E.H>.H~O20....H_H>w_H.:JDEw.<...E.mm _.=oo=mEa..w:o..cm:5_..m..a2:.u...<=awmm@332..53....:5Eoaamow“.5:wmm=...aw:..m.....a. BEocrmwmo:3.Ed.BE..=3%»35%E.r._.=.:<Q..a_..n==m.32....3.momma...omma?moo?az. o..o._.a.,§mo8m:vmnmonmo..w.,o_.a_dnro..<moo<m..§m.=m.wmwEma:cm9.oonzo?oa3Ed.23. «<5.:5:32...ooocumnozcm:5EnazmaaH....amo..E».o_ro..<:wm«<o=E:2rw<aoooc:.mn_E: 3..=5m..m=:..wo».E:Causes2.90:mo35ooo:_um:o..onEaEomnmaa52..3.:5Conzwwo o..EQ>=...o_..E.w,a_u..mmo=S:<am.mw<mEa98¢?mo..m5.3%.%.=.5moo..r..:..<G...o_Er:w ._§...Ermmam9..cm0.5..=am:mw..om...::ao..2:5:::moo.:_=n.3..Ed._.a..mo..».o..2.5:.:a W...5.28m_uo:m:._&.armEomammmn_o¢m.533...o_awmm2:.335.Emor?ma0.5..2m=..wa.3 ea%w__§&no.._.o..umo=m.u:2._onamwo..m.wmwiw.m..nn8mo..m.2%.;2:...=_uo..mo..mmo:..mo..:m 0..ma...5......Qom?ran25no.6H..aa—==:oamJ.Dd...m:0.1.3.%....a.9:8.%_..2_%0.. Ed..5835.2...;w..mm:..:o=§Eo8o..oo..:mo8n_2...:cawammzw$03.2.Eu.2......29.5 :2rm<monn..:.om9:3..maw..u::=mom:._mCanaano..:5:mamamonn..E.:o..omEmEnmnmaa 52..E.:5Eocsmowo..3o.=E3.nmm.mmmim.oo..:..n8~m.m:_u.no=:.mo.o..m.no...m..:m.._w..<o.._8: eauaaiammm.r.o_.::..m.“..d...mwmo...wEoormnwnm.Séczwomo..nom?2.8.22.:.a..9<:_..E... €_.w:.a......E=m5_§<.22.5..on2.5%....5:.3?..§oozm?wqmzonmommE=a.?rmConnmom .533umaomB..a..._a_5.2:.mm<o.§_=..§:50.5_.:_m:...:mmmrd...BEmmwra.w:25.. n_w.:.m.woao..m.m..:m.$32.3eav..oono&:wm«<52.Bow:1r...wr_a89.no....on$m$3..0.. ..:mr.wm8....ea9..2...;29.5:9.55onn......wmE:31.5w$:.:..wcm:5Eooaomo..:5En E5ono..E.:c..cm2.5Coozwna5%..E.:5Enmamao2.5m.=Eov.mmm.wmmiyoo=n:.n8..m.2.... oo:»§o8..m.oo...w:=w..:m.201835._.a..E§aom.r.o_E::mEa.o.€m..mmmo..now;mmmoommam .rmnmEr_..man.2.5.5.mlmmsmE:253:3.0..oz?iimm.mu<meaoxomu.3..mac._owm.%..?..mm 2..e._5a€..:..._m_.§5....W:.m0:.omowe;swmrwgnm.mac;3..<==.:_...:woo..a=o..dame Emmaz?wmEd5w&...%8B6.9.5...a2=.....$85.5.5:558:8.2..5:wE.<.<o .rwm.€...m:o..on$2.28....=r.m:o..cm2.:Coons... >:..n..mo=w_unouonv.o2..nn_5.o...=asuomwammmonomCnmsmow0..=5Coasmmm55%.5:.5 B3...861%on5...Enosmoo.9.0as::2.3:wr_o3..Ed.8%o..amiwmoHrmqwno.ro€a<o.. ooocabm..25Eomioa..o_m..m$ear.n_m.=::..om:50.5r.n_m=...:mmm.._.o:_m:n_w:..mEa n_o....w..%Fqmmuooaommnv.mznr_ommo...r..=..ma. «<3.Rmumon8:§:.2;m.__:§§3.0..Edono_....:_o..0..£55:6Cowammarwsmmmmon :5.=.§.9%02...CnonoaA:m....o..=§_....2.mm....:._=§...o..3.232.0..0.,<.o_m:o..omw..< m...<r.o..:.o..:m.E2..wmumo::m:8H.w..mm<<r_or$58;3.0..8ma55...9.3cm9..Comaoo A:~..._c..m....<...c==.m.:w_H....<..?§.§....EmEnwsmmmwry:.5:.5..a$.o..m=.=3.cuorrwmnos ¢<rm.mom<m..8..8=R:m.mEaEooamma5....”.=..w_m:a..83.3..Iwnadocmm..rm§..oom0..8 ..wa.5.3.0..m..<r.o..:.w=.m_w38.§axon?8:59:9.»:5.m..%..50..%..ma.o=8 ..w.:a&m83.0..Ewxmaocmm=.ms=§on83253.2.m...<r,o...._..a=S_rm?w..oma_.om:3 5:5.onmama:05ono..20:5:9o.._...2<.8_...<mooo=:.mm9:3..:8Enozmwmwwomimamo: :5Enmnwma5:....r.:..w.raHas...omowry:....o<EoEm5838o..Ed.cm5>_...§..E. Wmv8mm..§:<wm25...=2omoaEd.:.mo..:.u:o....o_w:=w8EwNw.¢o..mm=..m_§§o...532.ca .5052...EoozmnmE2... <<:_.o=.:=.3..m:8monmmoiw.Ran26.2:895o..:5C838a§__..§.3.Ed. mo<o..=:.n..§Hw:=..o..mQu....m:w=»8Ed.m=<._.2._=2a.Fmim3Era..o...w&w_mono:5..amumQ9. :§.:.o=.m__E§.§omEa.9.25..o..<.or.:o..omm=<r.o=....a:§_E2;..mmvmo:..m:5Comsmma 5....2.5..<<o.._E=3rw<aooo...,_.oa9:31.5m..w:n:m94....C8589.:5Comammmaon:m >::.o..mNmmWo_....omm=§m<om.zmo.ooo:vw:o=0...§.<...$0:90EomnmmmH.m..n_m.2.9.r..nm..wmm :5...ma5oomr3.8m:§.=._.&R...m&m_5.2,.5Emumo?cm:8Esmmuaozmm._.a§.§cu _...a..nr9So_wmo..owm..i_.o:....o=§_E2.:.or.E..mEd._.2s....2...m.:w8:._o=$8.roCoonmoa 5%..as.:5mwnWm25:.m..m=.o<mr=.om:=m.:.n_.€§_...om8..m:a..aaSEnnmBo§om:6 mo:o..Ea.2.5.E:cm:5§oa..maa$2?Page 184 of 192 3 am. 0:0£5:_.m<am:..m::mn=mm.Eo__.:::m$3.9::=:S:o:.amimmameam=._::o:o:.m<m=mEo3 omomp_mc<o_.E352mzmimE5:mgas...3.:85858::ma«3%58:8. aswzamO1uE..>cra>25.—.~wESH2>.EO2 >:95:"an%m=_=A:mU<@=»3H.£.m:::vmi:3%...a2_5_:m<oonc=:o::2,a:::o_.R:5.o:m9.39.0 onmamozociaw«SE8ones? 3 3 EV :%9__:WEmma5:=59....umv::o=~cm:658:3mommam9:Ewanna:monm.<2:9,.:o:$m nmmmimrm3:::oq.m:mmznr%?_=a:9Gianna:23::mgmvaN52213...528mvmo5;:m :5%@==rmmcam:%:§:&30:58:65$:mm? 3;%§:aEmma5:558:30E:8umnmo::m:oaasonoo..=n:m:oo2::Bi2.5.no<a:m=_w. mm_.oa_:a.:mV$35onoo:n::o:moo_:mw:m._E2%58:8.9:9,mm::53_.%:_.aS5: mcvmmamosCA8m.:o<o.m:n_25..age:rmw:2ram:_.nBm&om5.3::J35N59.21.8: .518mnma5;:m=8gamma:=532.%=<¢§_5258:85.oa:mo¢.omEEmommmow$.50 80%.:eaEm_.:m_:52.38.2:5:2:3wcmiommUmwmmam...E58:.828m_.mn5::m$5 %?_=:3.32.:o:<m..Q._Exown8En58:39on5:Enommoomm%».=_.23%$85.onmm 58?8mmaa.:5oun_.m:o:m._:m::o:m:omonno=m::ono:0».Enown¢<o_._a.«<31:E_.oE.m mm?.,.<_.§m::o:com_uwo5....m:5%@=:rum3%%_.<2.&cwown8:55na:mwo.Eo<<m<n_.. «<3._.nm_5Q8m:v.mzor%:_=_.A999.Em:m_,.m=Ed805:.3_=a=§_.:.m=§:no.2.m%m=_: 23%mag?2.mm58?8$8..:5ouo_.m:o:.:_mm:8:m:owomoo:m:.=n:o=om$50:6¢<o_,wm mou(<En_.:56£5:ca:0$3585SEO:Eomm:m:=.oEB:ow::orEB._.ommo:m_m_m &:m¢:8.co9:5:25::m3.3;omG3?m:m<m=.ano%.___.wrm::2cm._$5&8ox?2 :558:3»rmwoo:._:..w:nam8E:mo::<nE.m£5:%.m...__25::Samwmmag.2118::o:oo :.o_.mo».3.2:95m::we_o:mmm:5583$:_2.$:2.vnonoamm25.m:95&=ma:om2:.Exam m:wE=.cv:m.mmemo:8no::._m8:52.EnomEB:n_omm:_x R:85838Howm<o_=:SQ35:30:.E_mm:_c.:En<2.:m&E:om.m:_§_a._2on:.mo_<o:r 93%mi253..o_.m:9<m_.mmmwimm8o_.mm:5Nm:o=Exam?m:m_.:m_mmEm:o:9,9:9, _.mo_.mm:mNm:o::39.aa>§E.E.hEkm?m:.m:mm_:m_:.no_:cowEoP_.mm&=m::o:r_E=Em2o:. Emworie:onm:::m_._.m=wm:2:033.0:=:n_mam:v\>E.:nmEm5:5.9.ma?a9.oonmoim82. moncmamoum5=5mvuo.:::a_:omm:<.::m8a.88232.:n_:Em.9.cm255oa:woa0..cmm:onon E?2.35.3:um:o».5_u3um_.Q.o_.Emwwmm:<wo:o_.m_mm&m:q:o:.3.:55:“?cm29:8? mm:5ommmEmwUR :m2.5%mmEn:mmmimw:553583M5233.oo_:u..E:m:65oo:moamoowimm: §&§ao=omsm:_c.:v8womEa58:8:2.=5..mo_.mm.:Nmmo:.m..:m:ma.:m_:.no.:_mow:.o:. nmm&=m::o:..:n=Em:o:.&mmo_::o:9.m::=E,_.n:om$9:o_,o%8_.m._.a..._.2:2>E.:om_o_m55 m:m8Em:.m=:n:m::mmna0..::m.m2m:momm:mmm_.amm8em8mmwmasseson:2oo:moo:m<oV.0.. Km2.58m.Eo&<oqoq_E:Em8_,cm:85o¢:mao9.onm:2.onEd‘m=wm::.:m_um:am5 uqocmnaoaségaam=:mun:»%a._..=9=$_:m_=m::<mom8m9.=_;§§_3..m:mmmammm?mow 83%?_§_§.2.=28:mmn=:<av. Rmzwméaan9%.:oooE.m.:8:m::_..:n<nQammoms:weown:mmmm:..a£5::33...Q5mrm::m<w EmLE5.3:m3.20:.ms:5:mango:8m:v.2:9.3%;ca..aEa.:mmZia:ownW«B338:§$=%. 2.m.”E2on5:3:5: 3 3 8..a::m&\Ed.._%é:8.:658:39v_.o<Eo:Em.Ea5on=mmwwrmzvmu.803_e.2=E_< E5:n_a:.m::m:Bmmosmiecoma.=o=_._.wmcw0:53_.o_:aav.:.mo_.m:m_:u::m8..m.:m:<m:v.man:%:_=_n9. 88.¢=.m_.0:8:65oa=man_§__%9.88:=m:m8:553:823.9.25.9:...a:3n5. wminwEn58:8::95%Em...8amva.=D10@omom:oo:m:o:m:m»a:::§:o:.Eazuo::5 $333..om$59.5mxw:5:2.2..838.m:aw?mcm:553382::Emum?8:855%on m:v.um:.=anmomm::9:58:85:3mcmo_:8_u.W235:m:n_mg:rémm_:Emmmio_:m=:9. m::2:::83:8meansm::939mmx:5oxE_,m:o:cm:53:538:E£8::02?am omaomzmzo:m=:$::§m:o:29d:5Q5om:68::m:oE&:mm:3352.ox8:m5o:m.Page 185 of 192 2.2.2..O2~OH2<2>.2.m..dHw2.2 :5225:.2.55:“.5:252u_.5<5::52on252352$2:2E_5:§22<u5..mo::2:wEd.o222mm2o:9.m52w2w2:m:32 532220:=:2o_.2252.2o5:o55.5:2.322:5.2185.2222.5.>52cm002.2.5ono25_.8552?9.2%5:2: 225..5<5_:2:528:22255o::.o2owE52.2552.925..25:2:252».2:w_u222Q.25:252:582§§=_5:52. o_u22mu2o:2.mm2m»;<5:5:5o:222e:£5:_52.ow22uo:523=52.92:2om2:55o:mE:522.2.252523: 2:o<22522:::o22:m25:52:8:252:52m2.m=:5oo:m2:52momm825m€o:5on2523:25_.E<E5::02.25 2:25:5525559.225..5:55oE2:m25:55.25: 2m.20.2.2022 2322:85?amo25_e<2m52:.o<22522:22m2:55:55.5<5J\:o255_.52:2_.52O2.2555:2252=:25_.2.25 2L2o5:55E52252:§.22:m5:235%2.525222.55:2:2.5..mo:.3.59:25..9.E25255:.o:253:22825 5262255552.53%mm2.o=9<m” .21:02.0:2O:2w_.2o240:5:05:52:20:2:5. .226C:2<5_.w2Q><5::5.2222.25259 .no_,o:8.OZ2<2mQ223 .2;5252v25:5”£38.33 mam;_.3£2u<25m®ocm.oc_: >n5:2o:_225%D3259mm.2<2m::m5_..2352mmS25m5_.<2§ Ho.252255.555:32,25OE.2§.w2o:cm25023.omZ2mwm32:525 $82<2o:2mo:m._.$. Z2wmE.m2..m=wOZSmmm: .2.52522_o:5Hc8.u&.dN_ 225522”2.25:2225_.®:2mmm_.:m:2_m.5: >25:2o:_22.:2wo=2225_..Z2:mw_.:2u:=m2u2_.5559” o_.8:3325..m2n2..5mm.9.2:22<22=m22::m5:22:25m2m:w_5mcm.5255.>3:.5255::25..2.25 2:255:55“32272522<5_.522.5Eo:m22<on3259:29.22:2.525:528_;_<5:55:m2<5::25:55852? a5o52<52,on922:2522<5.,52E25_55:.o:25:52$205was28.?o:5w%_..§C3:22::5 2555528::<5:55:2522<5_.52o:2::mm:._5w=m2:5mmC5» 23925%o25_.2<2m5m2u5o2252..8255022.2%5552253.25225:».51222.mm?wmo.2=2.:J..2.5:5_.m5:5< £5:25m2<5:5.25$352.5mm22552m_.5.2:2«523252325m2<5:E552Ed:25mu_5:25.20. 9,2.052222:222:952m:0€55.25:o22o5_.5n=2:.5::5:2m5:3.2:2.>225:52:3255525::522.02553: W25:22:2o:52:2550:.cw5:522E2229.3.2.25:5. 22.2wH2<20<>2.O2»:4ma>r:>dozm>222.::m.no:>.:oz 2225:.5::2E:2o:o2.222mE255553..:3:_,5:mo:.O2uQ:52:..5n2=2_.5252:255:58522305:25:25:558 :.5_:c<55:2:cm2252:m2m=52o:m.2::2u3<5_:5::mm:22522225526:.252..2o5:m522..w:2m.ea558:5225 2..m:2m8mno.:222o:mw2m2.mo8J\802:0. 22.mcmzwz?oz 02:022222:2525_.2m2:.€22.052:<m222:2:man8..:.2:w2:m2:252:255:55.8m=w2u5:2252:55:5529.mun: _,5:mo:w_u25252::o».2:5mm02.0:52‘_.5.2=2_.52:.$2.53»m55:_,2Q9,5:5um5:5<o25_.w2o:u_nE.n:m5m.2% m2<2:w252L255=m55N:25:3.252:5::o255.E255nSo225u:25.0:022::02_52225258252:55:35 2:.5:2.noun.2m_:wm5wca20%o55ww2o:5225_.52d.. 22.20>mm52Z:2a 2.25555555525::3255:22528mmm2m:.3...”?9.m:2:_2o5:552.8_.2m22m5:2oE2wm2o:m::25_.2:25 2:255:55ea2525:52:on2:252L255:n5£22.95252:22..5225:5955:.o2.O2uQ,22,252..oo:m5:255%25 22225222:2.8325aa=:m5:5_.5222m5n52o:.2u3<22522:5»252:255:5825:255:22.528mmm?:25 _.2m22w5:2oE2mm2o:m.525:2.2m2:55:5502.2525:52.:om22m58:558mm:o55mmo.._:=:2n22.m2 52.2.3520:2225:»2:550:55:»omown. 22..2.2.2.b2w 2.25?2o5:m5525:53‘mm:.55m8285:2258252\w:2m.2:52E22:m5<5Q25:25_.5o2q.2.55Ba5255..o2.:5: 225:.5:o=E2.§:552.559:2?235.5529..5255255:22.252:255:55£522:95:25..2:83.2%mm_,55::5:? 22.252.2o5:m5n22Lu:2m.22.252:20:22E:«<22:252.2553522Lm:2mm:2258:5E.o222ww2o:om0:0 :25:.5_.:..2:u2c:2.5:625.om2.2m2:255:55E2255O2yQvm2:22.2225:8:555.2:252:5255::E3.:5 22222.52:2:02.0655252255820.... mu Page 186 of 192 E.20::E:>m:0:H.—>w—.FE.< Zo8_.:::::o:cm:558:82._8:.:.:8::mam.:::m:»cm:558:8m:::8:883.558:88cm:3 ::.S:0.:::o::m::o:m:88:=8n::u:8::::=5.:::o::m::o:mw:::mE.i<o:5.:8:8::_:::o:2. :mm:m:_:a:r E.mdnnmmmowm>73>mm5zm aim58:8m::=8:E.m8:83.5:.cm::::38.:mvein:::n.98:,8mu8:<mm:8nmmo_.m::: 82:58::mm:m:m. N». 9 3 3 E 3 @ 3 9 E QHZHE H:2::588929.8:::o_.::m:8m:_m=_:«:E::2o:_<25m:o:_8:8EE.:_eaS8<98“ 22%?:uo.¢:m=8.:mwo:=:omo::o_.SE:.a:.8:8:ao.:::::a::::o=8_.mo:8_.m:::$8 823:885::Jim58:8...___§.8:._._88:::m_.._::Qm:::_:«axuaammmosm8?...8:5: 58:8ea:28:5.n:§o:_:_.830:2,9:9.unis:53%:331:8:5::m«8:8:» m£.€_m:8:::_888“__::n::::m__9...::o_:8m..<1::82::oE_:::::oE__m8:S__.:m::8o:o:: E.;>..:o_o__».o=oc<m:5.::::_:Q,on:.828_.omm_.m8=8uo:.mm—.o::::m€25522:9.8388: 80:0:3B188:28:.._8~mo:__25:85:83.88::38?::m5:958:::::<E=:_. _:::_.2.m::r:mmoo.::o:.:5::03.880382.2:3SEQ. ._;:.m58:8oonwna?m:88:28:m88:_n:_8.28::8$382::82898:8m:£8: 3:38.,::n_mE8_.88w:=38..:m_.8:._o:nm.8mo:::::m.n:mn:mm:o:m.8:_.m8:n::o:m.€::.:::8m :::::8_.w:::&:wm.2:899.218:9.8u::_. Zon_::mno:»:::mm:93:m::::8.5888:onoo:m:.8::2E8F:.:om.:9.5::<:13::..J..:m o8:::m:83_::o:w:::omE.:_o€:_::::w8:w_::n:c:_:::8::=r9.om::::S.m:€ca0283 <o:::.a:8:.<8::8538:.5":o::m=::2m8on_::::w_8:2.3.58om.:oE.o<:&c:woo:.::..m: 885:::9.:3:omH70:2:cm:8::_:8m::=98:8::<_.a_::o:w::u838::83.33021.9. »:::.5:om:8:mo:.::::8:m8:m8mo_.=8:5::858:8. %:o3.1898:::5.9:58:8«<5:288::2.96:8::v.1w:no..om:8om8:0:::m:<oE. cm:5.8:8:2.8:23»2:2.:::::o333. mxoaun:mo:8_.§8968mm?_:_.o<Em:::2::58:8.88:w:_.€<<:_:88muo:w::_83.,:moé: coma:::988:8:50:58:5:no::8:o:E3.:8:omo:::o:.888:0::::_8..mo::::8om:5 58:8. :%58:83::o:_v.:8:_8:8:.m:E:_m_:m_:m:9,0:82.18_:o_=ma::<218::w_.8:8:. 389:8::2:83&8. .2558:88m::::0:::<o:81m:n88m:w8_.:1:58:89.:o:859.00».:m:::%:2:8:5 5::%2.::<812.880: Zo2:58..am::<omEa_u_.o<§o:mcm:858:825oo:m:::8:2:28:em:5‘9:9._:_.o<5mmo: 9<_§:o:9.:995:3.202:58.,9:::8:::=:m::_8m8x858_:.S.E:m3.:53.3‘8:9 :o::n_3.3.0§:<a_..>3.3%.:..:::_.oo..8?:::88_.oZ:m:31m:.=:8_,:858:8:1::2 2838:m:2:75.,o?::n1m:r>m::m_nE.::3:_8.835803:21%:3::29.80.38:w:.‘J. .49:::w9:9.9.».:::m_,882:8cm9:.”1w:.onEa$8858onBaxO25:_.:w:~:B3:::<m. ::3:uaoimmo:om.::m58:85:3538:8:8=_£:_,.:<:=:2.::8:».o_.8::_o3::: :.::_.:8a2.:3.8::onoo:.6o8:n_.=1mEo:o=:9:2:3:.5:E8:_98%onn::_8:.9:: _u8<§o:2:.:8888::9::558:8ea388.:::::mE.o<§o:m,5:83:5:5:E:388 ::n_082,.28$33m::=8:m:mm5:moo:9:::mmo::=c:m882:8:8:@3330:2::: <:_E.m:mo_.8::_m.::::E:=n::_a—:.o<5w:o:_:8028,cm2:3:m::mS::::v.828::9::o».$5 :_nm:_..:<:=:cu=:m:mo_.8::_aE.o<_m:o::83:8: HE:58:8.::m:=:o:<E8:=8::_8::.oo::8:o:2::2::58:8:.<::%35.A2. ::v5:o32:9:5:a3_::<8m:o:m.::&m::=9::no_:_:_v~2::::m25::8mo<m_.:m::3 :..8_.:88::::8:»,o_.8:5::8o_.:::82:::8_::Bcm:833:8omO:.::o:2::8§_§_ :55amO::::::_.n:o:.:_o9885:. 1_/::m58:838.:8m:m:n:::a8:88::.:5‘:=E_8_.omoo=:8::::mQ:n::::moo:Eo:¥:.8 5o5mn:,o_:o3:5.88:omiio:,.<:a:mwwnaa::a8:88:a::o1m:5_:5:=0».2:8:3:8: 8m3:9.no:m:::o08::::8m:.:m:=:_..__=9:. \aS=::iE.ux?hwm..=§:..e=::\<\m\~E22,....:.m:::=.m..Smm\:=:§Q Page 187 of 192 H2¢<E.2?mmQMHNHON.9m93%E55$8o=§_9%C85833.28mw?mam»$9521:3. OZHEOm.O<<H$~?H2Hw>.EO2H20. mu: wvn 23:9 39 22:9._,m::§?mE.n=mo: .329Wow.mama0o=m=:E: =><o_:35:52_=_2E.52....=5n.=_.o§_. HEMOOEOEHHOZomHim054ow ZH>®>b>EFS wvn .:::omZ.90%: E322 WV: .w=_O.§mnmo=¢<. 05OF...» :25.5:=52.V5E2.:503.5.5. .3.Page 188 of 192 momhudrm:>.. m~g..A.OEom=5H>2Um»=mEomzmmuH.>2.Um armbv_.:_mH5:4222§~mm..._:mc::5moi:?an3.O—:E::<»03¢?“.54..m_z:_o....m_.._E 26no1w__.o_.:<. I Page 189 of 192 E88:o:»_E:.£_Zmwmwz.H..w:mE3Uocmiinu.we:Ma?a WELLANDRIVER 5 Page 190 of 192 mnmaudim3w: egg?Wmm_1o:o=m\Won_=:.o.._.§:mnoCmamo=n_>o:<3mmV .25Cna?aa£5:non _.Uaoamo.cmo_?E_.ma?a:6F232.38..EnEnosmnu5.5%5HQmmmio...$5.052.5 §nw=mc_..m?izosnonmoi. N338SQnrm:m¢w8:895.5wro..a==n.Fm.m=mro_.¢==¢Eczema:Amaommoaoo:=o_22.32. 5.»:w8%235.::8.£5_.&mE:.o§_mmoiq,_.m:m—.o:Q=.§AZw<.mm_u_oémaiv:8E593om Zw.P:.w_wowozanmmEa9m25%;.wo~:=m:_mOonmmisnos>=:_o_.3\A3:5:uommw:w8n_mwosav. 9CEBU0..w=oc<o<m::mEoE=E=m0:asEomzmomExam. 9mag»om:as__o:EmEomammm55%E?vmnsmamm.m=.=aE$:=_.w_Bou8Q5us?omosq9% 58:822.?2.5Ceosmoim213a:acumen». m.5392a._§._38.:9.o?m?smm90Eoanmna_..w=.._m9.m5.953ommgonE:.:w_am...”3..:6... moowimu1<:ammm. EmnE§oE Pwe.m8m8_.n_m:Q.EaCoanmaoSE3_.am_.o=mE_awonm:EE=8_E:oacm:5EomsmmmBEEP m=o_E:=m.w._.mmm23%.8_.=o<w_cm3:.onmu=n=dwnm3525.3.m=o.<EEo<mreawsv._N¢<= BEunoumnv.:...:.:n=m=nmEB55:5so§_a§_cmmE_.%=._m:n_o§._an5FaEdm.dam B?awswsom3:=55:Bicumnwmwmoa_B_u_.o<o=._o=88:8&.<9§Ea_uE.E=mEd?mm %2=&:ooommwQcm35Eooioo. _u.E:5ono=:.o=nmomSQrmmi.ma:3?m<a=rcuaEm_.mm:8.m»E»:o=Em»ooo:_.mon90 Enmzmaa5:?:5En?ammSEno=Eon 2Emw..w~wm<m..0a_.:..o—02:3Q=na..=N:a=w_0c=:.a_Uwiv §m..4.m$3S o.H::5m<mE0».asm:<WoE=a.:w_mE=.=5Enmnmma«<5»:o=o<<EmZomaE.o8no_.SE :dEmn=m»m_v~noimo.ownmt ZmwwmnwE<m..0o=:5_02:3Q=8.,=w:o.§_Oe==.=_U35 §m.mmq.SS P>=2.5:3.333Ea933030:2::ax8..=w_mE_8_.oEm_.w~um3a:_w:<:595:9_.o_a8n_8 :5Eo?aooaéonwon:5§8=maaream.wan_=E=8=E_oacm:5EooaouEa?m=o_E:=m wammmo=E=mm:n_cam"_.w.=o<mr3:5$53mvo=m=&:Qcm:5Cnanmma. n..2538:5».mmwuimmmER:5ownm9<m~02.3m_‘£.mS«<5BoE=Nm582.BEEva r:m1.m..a2::Bom9.<man35.om$58..on:53252.on:5OEE.z:<mO_.oow\<«o=w=a_C.<o.n own<1::93nmmuonmmnamo:93K9:2_.m_owmnn_3.0:.E5»E30..uwawmwmoc==mnRm(5.5 EmCoanmama201$.BE$5.532:::50_.no_$a<n_.man8E0953:2GEE.H...£.oon. G Page 191 of 192 CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS By-law No. 2019 - A by-law to adopt, ratify and confirm the actions of City Council at its meeting held on the 16th day of July, 2019. WHEREAS it is deemed desirable and expedient that the actions and proceedings of Council as herein set forth be adopted, ratified and confirmed by by-law. NOW THEREFORE THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. The actions of the Council at its meeting held on the 16th day of July, 2019 including all motions, resolutions and other actions taken by the Council at its said meeting, are hereby adopted, ratified and confirmed as if they were expressly embodied in this by-law, except where the prior approval of the Ontario Municipal Board or other authority is by law required or any action required by law to be taken by resolution. 2. Where no individual by-law has been or is passed with respect to the taking of any action authorized in or with respect to the exercise of any powers by the Council, then this by-law shall be deemed for all purposes to be the by-law required for approving, authorizing and taking of any action authorized therein or thereby, or required for the exercise of any powers thereon by the Council. 3. The Mayor and the proper officers of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls are hereby authorized and directed to do all things necessary to give effect to the said actions of the Council or to obtain approvals where required, and, except where otherwise provided, the Mayor and the Clerk are hereby authorized and directed to execute all documents arising therefrom and necessary on behalf of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls and to affix thereto the corporate seal of the Corporation of the City of Niagara Falls. Read a first, second, third time and passed. Signed and sealed in open Council this 16th day of July, 2019. .............................................................. ............................................................. WILLIAM G. MATSON, CITY CLERK JAMES M. DIODATI, MAYOR Page 192 of 192